Hi ggirl87 and welcome to ehealth: First of all, because he was your first everything doesn't mean he should be your last...You are young...
As far as getting used to being with someone else, this happens...Maybe you didn't have enough time dating and being with guys and this is what you need...
Now for him throwing the other guy at you....This, IMO, is his way of not feeling guilty for what he did...Personally, I doubt if he feels anything, but he knows how to dig low and hurt and uses it...
My best advice is to find life...A relationship must be strong and filled with love and not accusations by both parties...Honey, be happy...Life is far too short...Take care...
Caroline