Nutrition Forum - Diet Sodas : Okay to Drink If ... ?
Medical questions     Health forums     Help    

Diet Sodas : Okay to Drink If ... ?

New Topic  Reply  Ask A Doctor - Offline
Medical Questions-> Health Forums -> Nutrition -> Diet Sodas : Okay to Drink If ... ?
Medical Questions
Author Message
11firecrackers

New User, Becoming EHEALTHy
Joined: 25 May 2007
Posts: 7
Diet Sodas : Okay to Drink If ... ?
Posted: 07-09-07 21:14pm

All right, I'm sure you've all heard all this stuff about diet sodas and the artificial sweeteners, and their negative effects.

I'm no professional, but summed up, said effects would include increased hunger, which will cause you to eat more (due to consuming the sweet, calorie-lacking substance, and thus your body believes it should be recieving calories when it is not, so it craves more). Also, if I recall correctly the artificial sweeteners will promote the release of insulin, which helps store fat. And, of course, there's the "Oh, I'm drinking Diet Coke, so if I go and have that cheeseburger it'll level it out." I've also heard that the drink can slow down your metabolism, but I'm not sure on that one.

Anyway, due to the reasons stated above, apparently drinkers of diet soda are more likely to become obese than those who drink regular soda.

So, what if you're smart about these things? What if you fight the negative effects brought about by not overindulging on food and by sheer will power?

For example, say I'm to have myself a can of Diet Coke each day, while also doing the following:

-Completely ignoring the cravings brought about by the soda. If my stomach rumbles, I'll get over it. I'll distract myself somehow, and eat as I normally would any other day without cheating.

-Not letting the word "diet" trick me into eating more than I should. I know that what's on my plate is more important than what's NOT in my drink.

-Drinking my can a day at night, after my final meal. Metabolism slows down when you go to sleep anyway; since I'm not eating until breakfast, I do a quick exercise routine when I wake up and then eat.

All my life I rarely drank soda, and just drank water most of the time (with the occasional diet soda here and there, but definitely less of an amount than the average soda drinker). I'm getting sick of it; but, since I was never a big drinker of regular soda, instead of thinking "oh, this diet soda is better for me", I'll be thinking "whoah, this isn't exactly a positive change; I'll have to be more aware of what I'm eating and when".

So, all these things considered, would a can of Diet Coke a day be no threat to my weight? I definitely don't want to put on the pounds that those who are heavy drinkers of diet sodas apparently tend to put on, so I don't want to start drinking the soda until I can get a few opinions on my plan.

Thanks for reading my wall of text, and more information is welcome. :]
|
FL Charm

Supporter
Joined: 25 May 2008
Posts: 26
Location: Florida, USA
Thanks: 0
Thanked:1
diet sodas
Posted: 06-06-08 21:42pm

The reason diet sodas and other things artificially sweetened make you gain weight is because the glycemic index of Splenda, Equal etc. is higher than sugar. Sugar is 70 and the sweeteners are 80. What this means is that when you ingest this, your blood sugar rises, and when it falls you are hungrier than you were before you ever ingested it. Also Diet Coke has alot of sodium and there are other drinks out there that have less, like Diet Rite (0) or Diet Chek(0). I use Stevia from a company that makes one with 0 glycemic index. I like the liquid flavored ones--English toffee is to die for in coffee and Orange Stevia tastes just like real sugar in tea and ddoes not raise your blod sugar one iota!

Lee
|
health_nuts

New User, Becoming EHEALTHy
Joined: 28 Jul 2008
Posts: 6
another idea
Posted: 07-28-08 17:04pm

I also heard somewhere that sodas with artificial sweeteners trick your body by telling it to ignore the sugar cues wrought on by an influx of sugar. Basically, because the sweetener is artificial your body learns to ignore it so when you actually consume products with sugar, your body thinks it is just sweetener and ignores it, also leading to weight gain.
|
Ingi

Supporter
Joined: 09 Mar 2006
Posts: 8786
Location: Grinning like a Cheshire Cat,
Thanks: 161
Thanked:194

Posted: 07-28-08 17:17pm

What is in diet pop - or regular pop for that matter - that has any nutritional value? Nothing. So why consume it? I'm not saying never have any at all - but one every few days seems like plenty. Treat is like a dessert or a treat.
|
health_nuts

New User, Becoming EHEALTHy
Joined: 28 Jul 2008
Posts: 6

Posted: 07-28-08 17:29pm

yeah, that's generally my approach as well. i have a diet soda every now and then, but i make sure i don't overdo it. i have a friend who drinks diet coke in place of water...now there's where it gets dangerous...
|
Ingi

Supporter
Joined: 09 Mar 2006
Posts: 8786
Location: Grinning like a Cheshire Cat,
Thanks: 161
Thanked:194

Posted: 07-28-08 17:39pm

Yes, because diet soda is not water. It is filled with chemicals and things the body doesn't know what to do with.
|
Related Topics
This Forum This Category All Forums
Jump to:  
New Topic   Reply
Medical Questions -> Health Forums -> Nutrition -> Diet Sodas : Okay to Drink If ... ?



We comply with the HONcode standard for trustworthy health
information:
verify here.