Abortion Debate Forum - Any Doctor/nurse That Can Rip a Foetus Apart Is Sick

Birch replied on July 9th, 2007

Supporter

They are providing a service women need. I'm sure they all do it for different reasons. I don't really think of them as saviors; just professional medical people doing their job in a somewhat risky environment.

|

meblonde01 replied on July 9th, 2007

Supporter

Re: Any Doctor/nurse That Can Rip a Foetus Apart Is Sick

Jules wrote:

I came upon the quote in the title on another abortion forum. It made me think. Please, no applause.

We often discuss abortion as being a right or wrong act on the part of the woman but what of the person required to perform that act? Are they cruel? Inhuman? Lacking compassion? Or are they saviours to desperate women, life-savers and professionals deserving respect? Question

I guess it is what you are capable of doing for a living. So people can do certain things and feel nothing about it while others couldn't. Some people would say they deserve respect while others would say get a real job you can feel good about doing.
I could not do it. And could not understand anyone that did.

|

Birch replied on July 9th, 2007

Supporter

Re: Any Doctor/nurse That Can Rip a Foetus Apart Is Sick

meblonde01 wrote:

Jules wrote:

I came upon the quote in the title on another abortion forum. It made me think. Please, no applause.

We often discuss abortion as being a right or wrong act on the part of the woman but what of the person required to perform that act? Are they cruel? Inhuman? Lacking compassion? Or are they saviours to desperate women, life-savers and professionals deserving respect? Question

I guess it is what you are capable of doing for a living. So people can do certain things and feel nothing about it while others couldn't. Some people would say they deserve respect while others would say get a real job you can feel good about doing.
I could not do it. And could not understand anyone that did.

They were there for you when you needed an abortion.

|

Jules replied on July 9th, 2007

Moderator

Re: Any Doctor/nurse That Can Rip a Foetus Apart Is Sick

Birch wrote:

They were there for you when you needed an abortion.

Ouch!

|

Anne123 replied on July 9th, 2007

Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy

There are plenty of jobs out there I couldn't imagine doing, but are a necessary service to society/our communities.

Personally, I couldn't be a doctor performing abortions but that is because I couldn't be a doctor at all - to either humans or animals - because I can't handle blood/surgical situations (unless it's my own blood) and needles really gross me out. Being a surgeon or assisting in surgeries is something I could never do because of how much it disturbs me - but surgeons are needed.

Other people whose jobs I could never do: police officer, paramedic, firefighter, farmer, airplane pilot, butcher, fisherman, garbage collector.... I could go on and on.

I'm glad there are people with stronger stomachs who will do the jobs I can't imagine doing. Thank goodness for all of them!

|

Birch replied on July 9th, 2007

Supporter

Re: Any Doctor/nurse That Can Rip a Foetus Apart Is Sick

Jules wrote:

Birch wrote:

They were there for you when you needed an abortion.

Ouch!

Oh, I didn't mean it to be like that. Just a matter-of-fact statement rather than snide. It's hard to get that across in type. Smile

|

Jude-Love replied on July 9th, 2007

Active User, Really EHEALTHy

"Abortion doctors" are niether of those things. They are gynecologists, serving their patients wants and/or needs. People who go into health care take an oath that the patient will always be in charge and be making the decisions and we have to help them regardless of what we think or feel.

|

young Girl replied on July 9th, 2007

Especially EHEALTHy

all i now is i couldnt do it
some one has to i suppose but its like those people who euthinize dogs or put animals to sleep taht are in shelters every day
they CHOSE to be what they are for a reson and i cant understand who would want a job of destroying any one or anythings life

people who perform the abortions went through that kind of schooling knowing what they were gunna do
they get up and go to work everyday knowing what theyre gunna do and the go home and go to sleep everynight knowing that tomarrow, they'll do it again

|

meblonde01 replied on July 9th, 2007

Supporter

Re: Any Doctor/nurse That Can Rip a Foetus Apart Is Sick

Birch wrote:

meblonde01 wrote:

Jules wrote:

I came upon the quote in the title on another abortion forum. It made me think. Please, no applause.

We often discuss abortion as being a right or wrong act on the part of the woman but what of the person required to perform that act? Are they cruel? Inhuman? Lacking compassion? Or are they saviours to desperate women, life-savers and professionals deserving respect? Question

I guess it is what you are capable of doing for a living. So people can do certain things and feel nothing about it while others couldn't. Some people would say they deserve respect while others would say get a real job you can feel good about doing.
I could not do it. And could not understand anyone that did.

They were there for you when you needed an abortion.

you don't know that! You don't even know how I had an abortion.. So I would watch what you say when you are not AT all informed,,It doesn't look good!

|

meblonde01 replied on July 9th, 2007

Supporter

Re: Any Doctor/nurse That Can Rip a Foetus Apart Is Sick

Birch wrote:

meblonde01 wrote:

Jules wrote:

I came upon the quote in the title on another abortion forum. It made me think. Please, no applause.

We often discuss abortion as being a right or wrong act on the part of the woman but what of the person required to perform that act? Are they cruel? Inhuman? Lacking compassion? Or are they saviours to desperate women, life-savers and professionals deserving respect? Question

I guess it is what you are capable of doing for a living. So people can do certain things and feel nothing about it while others couldn't. Some people would say they deserve respect while others would say get a real job you can feel good about doing.
I could not do it. And could not understand anyone that did.

They were there for you when you needed an abortion.

Birch there was a question ask. Are they Cruel? Inhuman? Lacking compassion? Or are they saviors to desperate women, life savers and professionals deserving respect?
When a question is ask that mean you are being ask your opinion. This forum will not have anyone in here that disagree or feel different about things if eveytime they answer a question they get jumped on like they did something wrong just because they don’t feel the same way you do. Or something rude is said to them personally like you said to me. NO one is right in any of the debates. We are only speaking our feelings. And if we can't do that without getting pounced on with rudeness. Well, it will get pretty boring in here if the only ones in here are ones that agree with everything you say! What would there be to discuss?

|

young Girl replied on July 9th, 2007

Especially EHEALTHy

Re: Any Doctor/nurse That Can Rip a Foetus Apart Is Sick

meblonde01 wrote:

Birch wrote:

meblonde01 wrote:

Jules wrote:

I came upon the quote in the title on another abortion forum. It made me think. Please, no applause.

We often discuss abortion as being a right or wrong act on the part of the woman but what of the person required to perform that act? Are they cruel? Inhuman? Lacking compassion? Or are they saviours to desperate women, life-savers and professionals deserving respect? Question

I guess it is what you are capable of doing for a living. So people can do certain things and feel nothing about it while others couldn't. Some people would say they deserve respect while others would say get a real job you can feel good about doing.
I could not do it. And could not understand anyone that did.

They were there for you when you needed an abortion.

Birch there was a question ask. Are they Cruel? Inhuman? Lacking compassion? Or are they saviors to desperate women, life savers and professionals deserving respect?
When a question is ask that mean you are being ask your opinion. This forum will not have anyone in here that disagree or feel different about things if eveytime they answer a question they get jumped on like they did something wrong just because they don’t feel the same way you do. Or something rude is said to them personally like you said to me. NO one is right in any of the debates. We are only speaking our feelings. And if we can't do that without getting pounced on with rudeness. Well, it will get pretty boring in here if the only ones in here are ones that agree with everything you say! What would there be to discuss?

agreed

noone should make this stuff personal

|

Jude-Love replied on July 9th, 2007

Active User, Really EHEALTHy

Re: Any Doctor/nurse That Can Rip a Foetus Apart Is Sick

meblonde01 wrote:

Birch wrote:

meblonde01 wrote:

Jules wrote:

I came upon the quote in the title on another abortion forum. It made me think. Please, no applause.

We often discuss abortion as being a right or wrong act on the part of the woman but what of the person required to perform that act? Are they cruel? Inhuman? Lacking compassion? Or are they saviours to desperate women, life-savers and professionals deserving respect? Question

I guess it is what you are capable of doing for a living. So people can do certain things and feel nothing about it while others couldn't. Some people would say they deserve respect while others would say get a real job you can feel good about doing.
I could not do it. And could not understand anyone that did.

They were there for you when you needed an abortion.

Birch there was a question ask. Are they Cruel? Inhuman? Lacking compassion? Or are they saviors to desperate women, life savers and professionals deserving respect?
When a question is ask that mean you are being ask your opinion. This forum will not have anyone in here that disagree or feel different about things if eveytime they answer a question they get jumped on like they did something wrong just because they don’t feel the same way you do. Or something rude is said to them personally like you said to me. NO one is right in any of the debates. We are only speaking our feelings. And if we can't do that without getting pounced on with rudeness. Well, it will get pretty boring in here if the only ones in here are ones that agree with everything you say! What would there be to discuss?

I really have a problem with you making this statement. In another thread, you made the claim that women who have abortions will go to hell for killing their baby. Regardless of whether or not you think such an absurd thing, you had no business being rude and ignorant and plastering it here for women who have had abortions to read.

Do some growing up yourself.

|

AyaMiyaki replied on July 9th, 2007

Especially EHEALTHy

The ironic thing here though, .Jude, is that meblonde herself has had an abortion. Birch was merely pointing out the fact that the medical personnel she "could never understand" helped her achieve hers (whether it was a medical or surgical abortion).

And it has been said already, by .Birch herself, that she meant nothing mean about pointing this out. It's strictly a fact.

|

Jude-Love replied on July 9th, 2007

Active User, Really EHEALTHy

And that just makes .Mel's comments all the more ridiculous.

|

meblonde01 replied on July 9th, 2007

Supporter

Jude-Love wrote:

And that just makes .Mel's comments all the more ridiculous.

but she pointed a finger at me when I was just commenting on a question ask! that is being personal...she pointed me out and directed a comment right to me not to the question or her feeling but right to me.. That is taken it personal.

|

Jude-Love replied on July 9th, 2007

Active User, Really EHEALTHy

meblonde01 wrote:

Jude-Love wrote:

And that just makes .Mel's comments all the more ridiculous.

but she pointed a finger at me when I was just commenting on a question ask! that is being personal...she pointed me out and directed a comment right to me not to the question or her feeling but right to me.. That is taken it personal.

Reap what you sow. You're rude on here and spit personal insults all the time.

|

young Girl replied on July 9th, 2007

Especially EHEALTHy

meblonde01 wrote:

Jude-Love wrote:

And that just makes .Mel's comments all the more ridiculous.

but she pointed a finger at me when I was just commenting on a question ask! that is being personal...she pointed me out and directed a comment right to me not to the question or her feeling but right to me.. That is taken it personal.

[edited by moderator. Stop bickering and start debating please]

|

Birch replied on July 9th, 2007

Supporter

Re: Any Doctor/nurse That Can Rip a Foetus Apart Is Sick

meblonde01 wrote:

Birch wrote:

meblonde01 wrote:

Jules wrote:

I came upon the quote in the title on another abortion forum. It made me think. Please, no applause.

We often discuss abortion as being a right or wrong act on the part of the woman but what of the person required to perform that act? Are they cruel? Inhuman? Lacking compassion? Or are they saviours to desperate women, life-savers and professionals deserving respect? Question

I guess it is what you are capable of doing for a living. So people can do certain things and feel nothing about it while others couldn't. Some people would say they deserve respect while others would say get a real job you can feel good about doing.
I could not do it. And could not understand anyone that did.

They were there for you when you needed an abortion.

Birch there was a question ask. Are they Cruel? Inhuman? Lacking compassion? Or are they saviors to desperate women, life savers and professionals deserving respect?
When a question is ask that mean you are being ask your opinion. This forum will not have anyone in here that disagree or feel different about things if eveytime they answer a question they get jumped on like they did something wrong just because they don’t feel the same way you do. Or something rude is said to them personally like you said to me. NO one is right in any of the debates. We are only speaking our feelings. And if we can't do that without getting pounced on with rudeness. Well, it will get pretty boring in here if the only ones in here are ones that agree with everything you say! What would there be to discuss?

I answered the question already. I believe they are medical professionals who are doing a job; nothing more, nothing less.

This is a debate forum. You post personal opinons, be prepared to hear responses you're not gonna like. If you want ponies and sprinkles, throw a birthday party. You should be able to defend your feelings.

You have time and time again refused to discuss your abortion experience. I'm not saying that you have to; but you cannot get all huffy when someone makes an assumption that, well, a professional provided you with an abortion. If you have something to add that will enlighten us, and perhaps see your point of view a little better, maybe you should share it.

|

meblonde01 replied on July 9th, 2007

Supporter

Re: Any Doctor/nurse That Can Rip a Foetus Apart Is Sick

Birch wrote:

meblonde01 wrote:

Birch wrote:

meblonde01 wrote:

Jules wrote:

I came upon the quote in the title on another abortion forum. It made me think. Please, no applause.

We often discuss abortion as being a right or wrong act on the part of the woman but what of the person required to perform that act? Are they cruel? Inhuman? Lacking compassion? Or are they saviours to desperate women, life-savers and professionals deserving respect? Question

I guess it is what you are capable of doing for a living. So people can do certain things and feel nothing about it while others couldn't. Some people would say they deserve respect while others would say get a real job you can feel good about doing.
I could not do it. And could not understand anyone that did.

They were there for you when you needed an abortion.

Birch there was a question ask. Are they Cruel? Inhuman? Lacking compassion? Or are they saviors to desperate women, life savers and professionals deserving respect?
When a question is ask that mean you are being ask your opinion. This forum will not have anyone in here that disagree or feel different about things if eveytime they answer a question they get jumped on like they did something wrong just because they don’t feel the same way you do. Or something rude is said to them personally like you said to me. NO one is right in any of the debates. We are only speaking our feelings. And if we can't do that without getting pounced on with rudeness. Well, it will get pretty boring in here if the only ones in here are ones that agree with everything you say! What would there be to discuss?

I answered the question already. I believe they are medical professionals who are doing a job; nothing more, nothing less.

This is a debate forum. You post personal opinons, be prepared to hear responses you're not gonna like. If you want ponies and sprinkles, throw a birthday party. You should be able to defend your feelings.

You have time and time again refused to discuss your abortion experience. I'm not saying that you have to; but you cannot get all huffy when someone makes an assumption that, well, a professional provided you with an abortion. If you have something to add that will enlighten us, and perhaps see your point of view a little better, maybe you should share it.

I won't answer you birch, because no matter how nice I try and tell you my stoy of what happened to me I feel you will pick me apart.. Just like you already do..

|