Parenting Debate Forum - Breast Milk Or Formula?
Medical questions     Health forums     MarketPlace    

Breast Milk Or Formula?

New Topic  Reply  Ask A Doctor - Offline
Medical Questions-> Health Forums -> Parenting Debate -> Breast Milk Or Formula?
Medical Questions

Boobs or Bottle?
Boobs, definitely
82%
 82%  [ 19 ]
Bottle, definitely
17%
 17%  [ 4 ]
Total Votes : 23

Author Message
Tylanas

Especially EHEALTHy
Joined: 13 Jul 2005
Posts: 12985
Thanks: 3
Thanked:0

Posted: 06-23-07 11:24am

Idony wrote:
IHeartMyBostonTerrier wrote:
sillyakchick wrote:
I think people should get over the stigma that moms who choose formula are "bad" moms. We all have reasons for choosing one or the other.


i definitely agree. it can be extremely hurtful to a mother who tried her hardest to breastfeed but couldn't for some reason.


yes, yes it can :'(


I definitely agree there shouldn't be a stigma attached to formula. It's very good!! There are so many reasons women choose formula, and they're all good. Remember, it's the woman's choice Smile
|
Idony

Supporter
Joined: 23 Sep 2006
Posts: 1611
Location: virginia beach, va usa
Thanks: 11
Thanked:0

Posted: 06-23-07 11:41am

Eiri wrote:
Idony wrote:
IHeartMyBostonTerrier wrote:
sillyakchick wrote:
I think people should get over the stigma that moms who choose formula are "bad" moms. We all have reasons for choosing one or the other.


i definitely agree. it can be extremely hurtful to a mother who tried her hardest to breastfeed but couldn't for some reason.


yes, yes it can :'(


I definitely agree there shouldn't be a stigma attached to formula. It's very good!! There are so many reasons women choose formula, and they're all good. Remember, it's the woman's choice Smile


im first going to say, i am *not* trying to argue with you here eiri but it is not always the womans choice

sometimes women can *not* breastfeed, ive been trying very very hard, but in the first week my daughter lost a lot of weight because she wouldnt eat so we started supplimenting with formula then we found out she is milk protien and lactose intolerant (found out the hard way...4 days in the hospital, blood work, urine, spinal tap, worst way to find out) so i had to feed her soy formula in the hospital and then the doc said it may be best to continue formula because my milk could cause problems, it wasnt until recently (2 weeks later) that i found out i can still breastfeed if i take al dairy out of my diet, so im trying but she has been on bottles for 2 weeks and isnt taking the breast well, not to mention my milk supply has been severly decreased because of not feeding

i do however beleive all women (if able) should try breastfeeding, everyone knows about bottle feeding but you dont know how breastfeeding is until you try it and you dont try it (usualy) until you have a baby, so how do you know its not for you? also the colostrum is so so important for baby i think everyong should breastfeed for at least the first day or 2

im not trying to be mean to those who didnt im just saying why you should

formula is not bad, but its deffinantly not as good as breastmilk and if you give it a shot and its not for you at least you can say you tried

~alicia~
|
Tylanas

Especially EHEALTHy
Joined: 13 Jul 2005
Posts: 12985
Thanks: 3
Thanked:0

Posted: 06-23-07 12:33pm

Idony wrote:
Eiri wrote:
Idony wrote:
IHeartMyBostonTerrier wrote:
sillyakchick wrote:
I think people should get over the stigma that moms who choose formula are "bad" moms. We all have reasons for choosing one or the other.


i definitely agree. it can be extremely hurtful to a mother who tried her hardest to breastfeed but couldn't for some reason.


yes, yes it can :'(


I definitely agree there shouldn't be a stigma attached to formula. It's very good!! There are so many reasons women choose formula, and they're all good. Remember, it's the woman's choice Smile


im first going to say, i am *not* trying to argue with you here eiri but it is not always the womans choice


Oh, no, I totally understand ^^ I was just trying to say that in cases where she does have the choice, she should have the right to chose formula and not be called bad.

Quote:
sometimes women can *not* breastfeed, ive been trying very very hard, but in the first week my daughter lost a lot of weight because she wouldnt eat so we started supplimenting with formula then we found out she is milk protien and lactose intolerant (found out the hard way...4 days in the hospital, blood work, urine, spinal tap, worst way to find out) so i had to feed her soy formula in the hospital and then the doc said it may be best to continue formula because my milk could cause problems, it wasnt until recently (2 weeks later) that i found out i can still breastfeed if i take al dairy out of my diet, so im trying but she has been on bottles for 2 weeks and isnt taking the breast well, not to mention my milk supply has been severly decreased because of not feeding


I can empathise with what you've been going through, and I never meant to imply that all women and all babies are capable of breast feeding. By "it's the woman's choice" was was simply trying to reaffirm that there's nothing wring with formula, and it was also a reference to being pro-choice in general XD

Quote:
i do however beleive all women (if able) should try breastfeeding, everyone knows about bottle feeding but you dont know how breastfeeding is until you try it and you dont try it (usualy) until you have a baby, so how do you know its not for you? also the colostrum is so so important for baby i think everyong should breastfeed for at least the first day or 2


I agree. Colostrum is something formula just can't provide. Again, a child can survive just fine without it, but it is an extra layer of protection etc.

Quote:
im not trying to be mean to those who didnt im just saying why you should

formula is not bad, but its deffinantly not as good as breastmilk and if you give it a shot and its not for you at least you can say you tried

~alicia~


Very well said!
|
rasuyoung

Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 17 Jan 2006
Posts: 464
Location: Long Island, NY
Thanks: 0
Thanked:1

Posted: 06-24-07 10:31am

I voted for breast, but I'm not anti-bottle, either.

My mom breast-fed all of us (7 kids!) for an extended amount of time. I was breast-fed until 15 months, which my mom said recently "wasn't long enough" and made her feel "guilty" (!). I grew up knowing nothing about formula, and my mom snubs her nose at it.

I know that when I have a baby, she'll expect me to breast-feed. I plan on breast-feeding as long as I can, but from babysitting and now working at a daycare center with infants, I see firsthand that bottle-fed babies seem just as bright and healthy as breast-fed babies.

I think breast-feeding is a great bonding experience for mommy and baby and hope I'll be able to do it without any problems. If there were problems and my baby did best on formula, I would be happy to give it to them. I won't really know what will be best for me until I'm there.
|
Bratz72

Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 24 Jun 2006
Posts: 433
Location: ,
Thanks: 3
Thanked:0

Posted: 06-24-07 14:30pm

I breastfed my daughter ...everyone commented on how tiny she looked and i began to worry however my doctor assured me she was doing just fine ...my niece the same age was formula feed and was a little porker? ...although now my niece is very tiny and my daughter pleasantly plump and very healthy not saying my niece is very skinny due too being formula feed however she did develop alot of allergies not sure if this has anything too do with this either....my best friend is having twins anytime now and a nurse told her she will prolly have too formula feed as well because her breasts are quiet small and she doesnt think she will have enuff to feed both of them. So then she doesnt know if she should breastfeed one and formula feed the other ....i told her too try breastfeeding both and if there not getting enuff supp with formula
|
Tylanas

Especially EHEALTHy
Joined: 13 Jul 2005
Posts: 12985
Thanks: 3
Thanked:0

Posted: 06-24-07 16:23pm

From what I've heard, the size of the breasts has nothing to do with how much milk they can produce...
|
rasuyoung

Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 17 Jan 2006
Posts: 464
Location: Long Island, NY
Thanks: 0
Thanked:1

Posted: 06-24-07 23:21pm

Eiri wrote:
From what I've heard, the size of the breasts has nothing to do with how much milk they can produce...


When .I first read this, .I read it as "the size of the cans has nothing to do with how much milk they produce..." Laughing
|
Related Topics
This Forum This Category All Forums
Jump to:  
Goto page Previous  1, 2
New Topic   Reply
Medical Questions -> Health Forums -> Parenting Debate -> Breast Milk Or Formula?



Page 2 of 2
We comply with the HONcode standard for trustworthy health
information:
verify here.