I Find a girl with small inner labia to be MUCH more attractive. For multiple reasons.
1) The look of a wrinkley piece of skin which seems to serve no purpose is un attractive to my eyes. (Again Thats just my personal Preference)
2) Every Girl Who I have got with who had the bigger inner labia seemed to not be Nearly as fresh as the girls without it. - I think (This is my hypothesis) that the Bigger inner labia encloses secretions, sweat and requires more effort (Not a worlds more effort just a bit more) to clean
3) Small inner labia's look tighter, they also look more youthful and less used (those are all misconceptions but none the less are burnt into my physical attractions)
4) Small Labia is Cuter
So the bottom line is I love da peachy ones. They just attract me more. Sadly this is the preference of most males. Well Most young males these days. If I were to put a realistic percentage from my perception of the matter I would say it's a 75% of men like smaller inner labia and 25% just love vagina regardless. Which I would say kind of works out well anyways for all you girls out there with big juicy inner labia's, cause 0nly 25% of women have the bigger inner labia leaving 75% of you without. So if you are not happy with the extra meat guys, just find another girl. (Kinda shallow I know)