I have something funny to add to this about eyebrows looking fake. When I was a kid I used to catch the bus at my friends house down the street. Her grandmother lived with them. She had sparce eyebrows and used to pencil them on. She seldom go them even and she used black pencil which looked really fake on a gray haired woman, but what the heck she was an old lady, who cares right? One morning she was all dressed and ready to go to town, but she had grabbed the wrong pencil. She had bright blue eyebrows. We were like

and laughed for months after that.
Terra, please don't shave off your eyebrows. Your face is separated into 3 sections. from your chin to your nose, from your nose to your eyebrows, and from your eyebrows to your hairline. If you shave them off your face it will look very funny and they never grow back the same way.
Go get some brown liner and buy some translucent powder to dab on them after so if softens your lines.