So you are bored by the guy who treats you well, and want the guy who treats you badly? This is a classic self-esteem problem. Subconsciously we are attracted to people who treat us the way we feel we deserve. Many many many women ends up with men who are jerks, and a lot of the time they somehow *need* to be treated badly. It can also makes you feel like you are in control, because someone who is too keen can make you feel trapped.
Have a think about what you want from a relationship and from your life. And from yourself. What do you get from each of these men? Quite possibly, neither is right for you. You need to understand yourself first.