Introduction
Acupuncture is one of the oldest, most
commonly used medical procedures in the
world. Originating in China more than
2,000 years ago, acupuncture began to
become better known in the United States
in 1971, when New York Times reporter
James Reston wrote about how doctors in
China used needles to ease his abdominal
pain after surgery. Research shows that
acupuncture is beneficial in treating a
variety of health conditions.
In the past two decades, acupuncture has
grown in popularity in the United States.
A Harvard University study published in
1998 estimated that Americans made more
than five million visits per year to
acupuncture practitioners.1 The report
from a Consensus Development Conference on
Acupuncture held at the National
Institutes of Health (NIH) in 1997 stated
that acupuncture is being "widely"
practiced--by thousands of physicians,
dentists, acupuncturists, and other
practitioners--for relief or prevention of
pain and for various other health
conditions.2
NIH has funded a variety of research
projects on acupuncture. These grants have
been awarded by the National Center for
Complementary and Alternative Medicine
(NCCAM), the Office of Alternative
Medicine (OAM, NCCAM's predecessor), and
other NIH Institutes and Centers.
This fact sheet provides general
information about acupuncture, research
summaries, a glossary that defines terms
underlined in the text, and a resource
section.
Acupuncture Theories
Traditional Chinese medicine theorizes
that there are more than 2,000 acupuncture
points on the human body, and that these
connect with 12 main and 8 secondary
pathways called meridians. Chinese
medicine practitioners believe these
meridians conduct energy, or qi
(pronounced "chee"), throughout the body.
Qi is believed to regulate spiritual,
emotional, mental, and physical balance
and to be influenced by the opposing
forces of yin and yang. According to
traditional Chinese medicine, when yin and
yang are balanced, they work together with
the natural flow of qi to help the body
achieve and maintain health. Acupuncture
is believed to balance yin and yang, keep
the normal flow of energy unblocked, and
maintain or restore health to the body and
mind.
Traditional Chinese medicine practices
(including acupuncture, herbs, diet,
massage, and meditative physical exercise)
all are intended to improve the flow of
qi.3
Western scientists have found meridians
hard to identify because meridians do not
directly correspond to nerve or blood
circulation pathways. Some researchers
believe that meridians are located
throughout the body's connective tissue;4
others do not believe that qi exists at
all.5,6 Such differences of opinion have
made acupuncture an area of scientific
controversy.
Mechanisms of Action
Several processes have been proposed to
explain acupuncture's effects, primarily
those on pain. Acupuncture points are
believed to stimulate the central nervous
system (the brain and spinal cord) to
release chemicals into the muscles, spinal
cord, and brain. These chemicals either
change the experience of pain or release
other chemicals, such as hormones, that
influence the body's self-regulating
systems. The biochemical changes may
stimulate the body's natural healing
abilities and promote physical and
emotional well-being.7 There are three
main mechanisms:
Conduction of electromagnetic signals:
Western scientists have found evidence
that acupuncture points are strategic
conductors of electromagnetic signals.
Stimulating points along these pathways
through acupuncture enables
electromagnetic signals to be relayed at a
greater rate than under normal conditions.
These signals may start the flow of
pain-killing biochemicals, such as
endorphins, and of immune system cells to
specific sites in the body that are
injured or vulnerable to disease.8,9
Activation of opioid systems: Research has
found that several types of opioids may be
released into the central nervous system
during acupuncture treatment, thereby
reducing pain.10
Changes in brain chemistry, sensation, and
involuntary body functions: Studies have
shown that acupuncture may alter brain
chemistry by changing the release of
neurotransmitters and neurohormones.
Acupuncture also has been documented to
affect the parts of the central nervous
system related to sensation and
involuntary body functions, such as immune
reactions and processes whereby a person's
blood pressure, blood flow, and body
temperature are regulated.3,11,12
Preclinical studies have documented
acupuncture's effects, but they have not
been able to fully explain how acupuncture
works within the framework of the Western
system of medicine.13,14,15, 16,17,18
According to the NIH Consensus Statement
on Acupuncture:
Acupuncture as a therapeutic intervention
is widely practiced in the United States.
While there have been many studies of its
potential usefulness, many of these
studies provide equivocal results because
of design, sample size, and other factors.
The issue is further complicated by
inherent difficulties in the use of
appropriate controls, such as placebos and
sham acupuncture groups. However,
promising results have emerged, for
example, showing efficacy of acupuncture
in adult postoperative and chemotherapy
nausea and vomiting and in postoperative
dental pain. There are other situations
such as addiction, stroke rehabilitation,
headache, menstrual cramps, tennis elbow,
fibromyalgia, myofascial pain,
osteoarthritis, low back pain, carpal
tunnel syndrome, and asthma, in which
acupuncture may be useful as an adjunct
treatment or an acceptable alternative or
be included in a comprehensive management
program. Further research is likely to
uncover additional areas where acupuncture
interventions will be useful.7
Increasingly, acupuncture is complementing
conventional therapies. For example,
doctors may combine acupuncture and drugs
to control surgery-related pain in their
patients.19 By providing both acupuncture
and certain conventional anesthetic drugs,
some doctors have found it possible to
achieve a state of complete pain relief
for some patients.10 They also have found
that using acupuncture lowers the need for
conventional pain-killing drugs and thus
reduces the risk of side effects for
patients who take the drugs.20,21
Currently, one of the main reasons
Americans seek acupuncture treatment is to
relieve chronic pain, especially from
conditions such as arthritis or lower back
disorders.22,23 Some clinical studies show
that acupuncture is effective in relieving
both chronic (long-lasting) and acute or
sudden pain, but other research indicates
that it provides no relief from chronic
pain.24 Additional research is needed to
provide definitive answers.
FDA's Role
The U.S. Food and Drug Administration
(FDA) approved acupuncture needles for use
by licensed practitioners in 1996. The FDA
requires manufacturers of acupuncture
needles to label them for single use
only.25 Relatively few complications from
the use of acupuncture have been reported
to the FDA when one considers the millions
of people treated each year and the number
of acupuncture needles used. Still,
complications have resulted from
inadequate sterilization of needles and
from improper delivery of treatments. When
not delivered properly, acupuncture can
cause serious adverse effects, including
infections and punctured organs.26
Clinical Research Sponsored by NCCAM and
OAM
Created by a mandate from the U.S.
Congress in 1998, NCCAM is dedicated to
exploring complementary and alternative
healing practices in the context of
rigorous science, training complementary
and alternative medicine (CAM)
researchers, and disseminating
authoritative information to the public
and professionals. Research on acupuncture
has been supported by NCCAM and OAM, and
continues to be supported by NCCAM.
Examples of projects and findings are
discussed below. (For the most updated
information on current and past research
projects funded by NCCAM, consult the
Computer Retrieval of Information on
Scientific Projects (CRISP) database.)
As of March 2002, NCCAM supports 16
Specialty Centers of Research, where
scientists conduct studies on CAM for
specific health conditions and diseases.
Scientists at two centers are
investigating acupuncture therapy:
The Center for Alternative Medicine
Research on Arthritis, at the University
of Maryland in Baltimore, is conducting
research exploring the efficacy, safety,
and cost-effectiveness of acupuncture
treatment for osteoarthritis of the knee,
and the mechanism of action and effects of
electroacupuncture on persistent pain and
inflammation.
The Center for Addiction and Alternative
Medicine Research at the Minneapolis
Medical Research Foundation, Minnesota, is
carrying out preclinical trials of
electroacupuncture to map the parts of the
brain involved in dependence on opioids.
Other research on acupuncture that NCCAM
funds includes the following:
A team led by scientists at New England
Research Institutes and Massachusetts
General Hospital is conducting a pilot
study that may move forward into a
large-scale clinical trial, on the effects
of acupuncture on hypertension.27
A pilot study at the University of
California at Los Angeles on the effect of
acupuncture on heart failure patients has
shown some interesting preliminary
results. Patients treated by acupuncture
had significant reduction in sympathetic
nerve activation, which is usually
increased in this group of patients and
has an adverse effect on the disease
course.28
With the support of OAM, researchers at
the University of Maryland in Baltimore
conducted a randomized controlled clinical
trial and found that patients treated with
acupuncture after dental surgery had less
intense pain than patients who received a
placebo.19 Scientists at the university
also found that older people with
osteoarthritis experienced significantly
more pain relief after using conventional
drugs and acupuncture together than those
using conventional therapy alone.29
OAM also funded several preliminary
studies on acupuncture:
In one small randomized controlled
clinical trial, more than half of 11 women
with a major depressive episode who were
treated with acupuncture improved
significantly.30
In another controlled clinical trial,
nearly half of the seven children with
attention deficit hyperactivity disorder
who underwent acupuncture treatment showed
some improvement in their symptoms.
Researchers concluded that acupuncture was
a useful alternative to standard
medication for some children with this
condition.31
In a third small controlled study, eight
pregnant women were given a type of
acupuncture treatment called moxibustion
to reduce the rate of breech births, in
which the fetus is positioned for birth
feet-first instead of the normal position
of head-first. Researchers found the
treatment to be safe, but they were
uncertain whether it was effective.32
Then, researchers reporting in the
November 11, 1998, issue of the Journal of
the American Medical Association conducted
a larger randomized controlled clinical
trial using moxibustion for breech births.
They found that moxibustion applied to 130
pregnant women presenting breech
significantly increased the number of
normal head-first births.33
Acupuncture and You
The use of acupuncture, like the use of
many other CAM treatments, has produced a
good deal of anecdotal evidence. Much of
this evidence comes from people who report
their own successful use of the treatment.
If a treatment appears to be safe and
patients report recovery from their
illness or condition after using it,
others may decide to use the treatment.
However, scientific research may not
support the anecdotal reports.
Lifestyle, age, physiology, and other
factors combine to make every person
different. A treatment that works for one
person may not work for another who has
the very same condition. You as a health
care consumer (especially if you have a
preexisting medical condition) should
discuss any CAM treatment, including
acupuncture, with your health care
practitioner. Do not rely on a diagnosis
of disease by an acupuncture practitioner
who does not have substantial conventional
medical training. If you have received a
diagnosis from a doctor and have had
little or no success using conventional
medicine, you may wish to ask your doctor
whether acupuncture might help.
Finding a Licensed Acupuncture
Practitioner
Health care practitioners can be a
resource for referral to practitioners of
acupuncture, as more are becoming aware of
this CAM therapy. More medical doctors,
including neurologists, anesthesiologists,
and specialists in physical medicine, are
becoming trained in acupuncture,
traditional Chinese medicine, and other
CAM therapies. In addition, national
organizations (consult your local library
or search with a Web browser) may provide
referrals to practitioners, although some
organizations may encourage the use of
their practices.
Check a practitioner's credentials.
A practitioner who is licensed and
credentialed may provide better care than
one who is not. About 40 States have
established training standards for
acupuncture certification, but States have
varied requirements for obtaining a
license to practice acupuncture.34
Although proper credentials do not ensure
competency, they do indicate that the
practitioner has met certain standards to
treat patients through the use of
acupuncture.
Check treatment cost and insurance
coverage.
A practitioner should inform you about the
estimated number of treatments needed and
how much each will cost. If this
information is not provided, ask for it.
Treatment may take place over a few days
or for several weeks or more. Physician
acupuncturists may charge more than
nonphysician practitioners. Check with
your insurer before you start treatment as
to whether acupuncture will be covered for
your condition, and if so, to what extent.
Some plans require preauthorization for
acupuncture.
Check treatment procedures.
Ask about the treatment procedures that
will be used and their likelihood of
success for your condition or disease. You
also should make certain that the
practitioner uses a new set of disposable
needles in a sealed package every time.
The FDA requires the use of sterile,
nontoxic needles that bear a labeling
statement restricting their use to
qualified practitioners. The practitioner
also should swab the puncture site with
alcohol or another disinfectant before
inserting the needle.
During your first office visit, the
practitioner may ask you at length about
your health condition, lifestyle, and
behavior. The practitioner will want to
obtain a complete picture of your
treatment needs and behaviors that may
contribute to the condition. Inform the
acupuncturist about all treatments or
medications you are taking and all medical
conditions you have.
The Sensation of Acupuncture
Acupuncture needles are metallic, solid,
and hair-thin. People experience
acupuncture differently, but most feel no
or minimal pain as the needles are
inserted. Some people are energized by
treatment, while others feel relaxed.35
Improper needle placement, movement of the
patient, or a defect in the needle can
cause soreness and pain during
treatment.36 This is why it is important
to seek treatment from a qualified
acupuncture practitioner.