Join Our Community!
Parenting > Parenting Community Forum > Raising Children
Welcome to the eHealth Parenting Community connecting patients, doctors, and people who like to help.
For more information about Parenting Community, read the topics below or use our FREE Ask a Doctor service!
Ask a Doctor
User Profile
Q: Raising Children
asked by: Steph0906 on December 3rd, 2006
New User, Becoming EHEALTHy
My husband and I were having a discussion about raising our children. He believes I can sometimes be too rough on our son - he's 4. What I mean by too rough is making sure he sits still when necessary, ie - church, dinner, etc. Talking with a situation appropriate volume, putting his clothes away, putting dirty clothes in the hamper, putting his cup in the sink when he's finished, and so forth. I was raised with what I believe was a healthy .F.E.A.R of my parents. An example of what I mean by fear is there was no sneaking out of the house because the locks would have been changed and you would be fending for yourself for awhile. My husband on the other hand got in trouble as a teen. Not to give too much info, but he was put in juvenille detention, broke out, came home, and his mother gave him cash and hair dye so he wouldn't be caught/sent back Rolling Eyes .

My question is: do you believe that there has to be a certain level of discipline and what do you do to discipline your kids?

I personally believe that spanking can sometimes be necessary to get a childs attention, only when other alternatives have failed. But what I found works best in my situation is taking things away and having him earn them back.

Comments..........

Steph
Did you find this post useful?
|
Quick Reply


Replies(6)
User Profile
Kia replied on December 3rd, 2006
Supporter
I was bought up wih respect not fear.
I didn't often get a spank because i'd be told "stop it or you will get a spank" the threat was enough.

You have to be sure you don't cross the line though.

But I personally think too many parents are too soft today and the world would be a better place if parents weren't afraid of discipline.
Did you find this post useful?
|
User Profile
Steph0906 replied on December 3rd, 2006
New User, Becoming EHEALTHy
The threat doesn't work with my son. He is all boy, aka hard-headed. Mind you he is very polite and has great manners.

I have a lot of respect for my parents, but I still have a certain level of fear. If I were to say a curse word in front of my parents today (i'm 26), they would toss me across the room, not literally, but they would definetly voice there opinion. Some people don't view cursing as disrespectful, but I was brought up not to even try certain things with them.
Did you find this post useful?
|
User Profile
Kia replied on December 3rd, 2006
Supporter
Same here.

If I ignored the threat I got the spank - a short sharp slap across the thighs or buttocks (anywhere else is just wrong).
Did you find this post useful?
|
Avatar
AlliE_18 replied on December 3rd, 2006
Extremely EHEALTHy
I think its good your son puts his clothes away, 4 is old enough to know you dont leave clothes all over the floor. And to put help you put toys away at the end of the day. Simple things like that.

I agree with what u said about taking something away and he has to behave good to get it back.


Like kia mentioned, I think they should respect you but not fear you.

Edited cos I put too much personal info in.
Did you find this post useful?
|
User Profile
Jules replied on December 3rd, 2006
Supporter
I was smacked as a child, and so was my brother, sometimes even with a cane which my dad kept on top of a picture in our living room. Dad only had to look at that cane and me and my brother would run away and stop being naughty! We weren't viciously beaten or anything, it was a whack across the arse with the cane as we were running upstairs or something. It was something which my dad's generation thought totally acceptable. My husband and i, however, do not intend to use smacking as a punishment for our son. I don't believe it is necessary and it would be hypocritical of me to teach my child not to be violent but to punish him with violence myself.

That said, I don't classify a smack on the bum as child abuse. I don't think there is anything wrong with it; we just choose not to do it.

There certainly is a dreadful lack of discipline in today's society. You don't need to smack kids to discipline them but I think there is a lot of guilt among parents today because they believe they need to give their children all the material things. What children truly need is a stable home with loving parents who set boundaries and stick to them. That makes children feel secure.
Did you find this post useful?
|
Avatar
Sophie585 replied on December 3rd, 2006
Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
When I was younger, my parents used to smack me sometimes if I was bad or too lippy with them. Looking back, I don't think it did anything other than hurt me phsyically and hurt my feelings. Even if the smack didn't hurt, it would hurt me that they had the intention of hurting me, if that makes any sense. I can see why some people would agree that spanking is ok, but for me personally, its something that I am going to try my hardest not to do. I have a younger brother, and when we've fought its been sooo hard to restrain myself from smacking him. But I want to try to be different with my daughter. I would love for her to be able to look back on her childhood and say "my parents never laid a hand on me." like .Kia said, even just the threat of a spank was anough for her.

I don't believe spanking is wrong, but like .Purent green, i'm going to try not to do it.
Did you find this post useful?
|
 
Subject
Message
Jump to: