Medical Questions > Debate Forums > Abortion Debate Forum

Question For Those Who've Aborted (Page 1)

Where I live there is a very prominent clinic and they do not allow your support person to comfort you during the procedure, I am a doula, childbirth support, but I am thinking that I want to go into abortion support, because of my own negative experience being alone. Do any of you think that that would be/have been beneficial to have someone by your side as sole support for you before, during, and after the procedure reassuring you that it was ok and that you were making the right decision for yourself???? Thanks in advance
beth
Did you find this post helpful?
|

User Profile
replied October 23rd, 2006
Active User, very eHealthy
Re: Question For Those Who've Aborted
bthomas wrote:
do any of you think that that would be/have been beneficial to have someone by your side as sole support for you before, during, and after the procedure reassuring you that it was ok and that you were making the right decision for yourself????


i think that it would be 100% beneficial without a doubt. My own personal experience was having to deal with it alone. The abortion nurse was unbelieveibly rubbish and out of line and I only realised after when I came on here. I had no support whatsoever throughout the whole expereince and I would have appreciated even a little moral support when I was at the clinic. So yes it would be beneficial to have someone for support.
|
Did you find this post helpful?

User Profile
replied October 23rd, 2006
Extremely eHealthy
Something which I just don't understand when I hear stories about women who have been treated badly during an abortion is why on earth do such people do that job in the first place if they hate the women so much? You can't exactly be judgemental of a woman having an abortion if you have chosen a career that means you are aiding them in their abortions! There's no excuse for it. If you are a nurse and you have a problem with abortion then go and work in a paediatric unit or something - not an abortion clinic!
|
Did you find this post helpful?

replied October 23rd, 2006
Extremely eHealthy
Some private clinics allow a support person inside with you while the abortion is taking place, but many do not due to safety fears.

I was very sedated, so I was painfree, and probably would not have noticed a support person :p

i work in an abortion clinic, I love it =) there are too many people who work in jobs that they do not like, and it is a shame.

Definately call a few clinics around and see if they need someone =)
|
Did you find this post helpful?

User Profile
replied October 23rd, 2006
Extremely eHealthy
I was very fortunate to have a woman who was from a different city yet there with me through the entire process. She wanted to know how the clinic operated and take some of that experience back with her to her own clinic. I was asked if it were okay if she were "assigned" to me and I gave my consent. I was emotionally fine with the abortion, just nervous about the medical procedure itself. As it was, I passed right out! (i do that with hopitals, surgeries, getting blood drawn...Etc) and it was very nice to have comfort and someone to hold my hand.

I think clinic should adopt this practice as a norm, if women would like it. If I were you, I would fully seek out to create this service. Go for it, it's a great idea.

Side note: I was however irked that my boyfriend could not be with me. I would have liked him to go through the experience, and I think if men did they would be more understanding.
I can understand why the leave the men in the waiting room but it would have been quite nice to have him with me. Share in this experience, too, honey, you will forever be a part of it.
|
Did you find this post helpful?

replied October 23rd, 2006
Active User, very eHealthy
Your post assumes that this service is not provided at a majority of clinics or service provider locations. Most do have a volunteer program in place to offer women someone compassionate to hold their hands through the procedure. Call around to the providers in your area.
Peace,
jenn
|
Did you find this post helpful?

replied October 24th, 2006
Thanks, I just know that the clinic in my area does not offer this service. I do not assume that none of them do, I just wanted to see if this is something women would like, I know I would have really appreciated it.
|
Did you find this post helpful?

replied October 26th, 2006
Experienced User
Re: Question For Those Who've Aborted
|
Did you find this post helpful?

replied October 26th, 2006
Especially eHealthy
Eugena, this is an abortion support forum. Your post is clearly anti-abortion, and unfortunately does not belong on this forum. Only posts supporting the woman's desicion and helpng her through the experience should be posted here, unless the woman specifically asks for reasons for and against aborting. As this is not the case on this topic, your post is innapropriate.

I am sorry you had such bad expereinces, but as you stated, most (not 99%, but more than half) women who abort do not regret it. I am sorry you regret your desicion, but you must remember that it is in the past. Regrets do not help us; fixing and learning from mistakes does.

You also should not frighten other women into thinking that they will feel the same way you did. Most do not feel as sad as you do.
|
Did you find this post helpful?

replied October 27th, 2006
Active User, very eHealthy
Re: Question For Those Who've Aborted
eugeniabrown wrote:
no one told me that a single abortion may prevent me from having a baby again.
no one told you because it's not true. Unless you suffered some unusual complications, abortion is the safest medical procedure in industrialized nations and does not render women infertile.

Quote:
the bottom line of it is money. There are many women who suffered bad complications after abortion, but if they go back to the same guy, he will tell you it should be expected for the fear of lawsuits.
this is completely untrue. First, your provider or a nurse with your provider should explain the natural effects of an abortion. If they do not, .A.S.K. secondly, if you are experiencing problems, call someone immediately. Thirdly, all providers carry hefty (and incredibly expensive) medical insurance. Sue away, if you want, because they are covered and it will not harm their practice. And lastly, since the insurance is so expensive, most providers do the abortion at cost because to charge you the real cost of it (factoring in insurance, etc) would be too much for anyone to afford. That is why the vast majority of all providers have successful ob/gyn practices to actually pay the bills. Those who provide abortions do so because they believe in helping women, not to make money. Most of them end up having to do other work, ob/gyn work, to actually make money.
Quote:
or even better yet, he will send you to a "buddy" of his so now you will have two "doctors" with an opinion that everything is okay, and it is you who is crazy.
from this post, perhaps you should heed their suggestions. There should be low cost or free psychiatric services in your area.

Quote:
the best way to help women is to to help them to do the right choice and not go through with the abortion.
the right choice is whatever is right for the woman, not what is simply "right" in your opinion. You do not know all of the women who choose to obtain an abortion, you do not know what their lives are like, you do not know their situations, and therefore you are in no position to pass judgement.

As for the rest of us, the best way that we can help women is to support them in their personal, private decision, not make self-righteous judgemental statements that only show your level of ignorance and lack of compassion for real women going through this decision.
|
Did you find this post helpful?

User Profile
replied October 27th, 2006
Extremely eHealthy
Re: Question For Those Who've Aborted
eugeniabrown wrote:


dear beth,

i think it is wonderful that you would like to comfort women... What would you tell them? It is okay to have and a abortion and that 99.9% of women are just fine after it?
I have been there and let me tell you, there is not a single moment of my life that I do not regret it. No one told me about the dreams I would have. No one told me that my heart will be torn apart. No one told me how sad will I feel when I saw a little child wondering "how would my child look like?" no one told me that a single abortion may prevent me from having a baby again.


The best way to help women is to to help them to do the right choice and not go through with the abortion.



Eugenia.

magdalene's hope: a post abortion journey.



that is complete bs, sorry but I had 2 d&c same medical procedure as an abortion and I was able to have kids. If that was so true it would be considered medically unsafe and therefore woman would die of infection.

Please stop spreading lies, this is a support forum!
|
Did you find this post helpful?

User Profile
replied October 27th, 2006
Extremely eHealthy
I had 2 medically necessary abortions and a staph infection and still ended up having children along with 2 m/c prior to the abortions, you might think of getting other opinions I even surprised my doctor when I did complete both of my full term pregnancy's, you might think about getting some other opinions. My kids are grown now, out on their own and are doing great!
|
Did you find this post helpful?

replied October 28th, 2006
Wow!!!
Well, firstly, I will support women the way I see fit for each individual woman. Some need to just know someone is there with them holding their hand and crying with them. Others need to hear that they are stong and have made the right decision. And yet, some just need you in the room with them while they internalize everything.
Bottom line for me is that whether or not you regret your decision afterwards, something drove you to make that decision.
Eugenia,
would it really have mattered to you if someone had said all those things?
Most women (imo) have an abortion because they feel backed into a corner and that is the best way for them to deal with a very difficult situation. Most women do not come to this decision lightly and it is by far not an easy one.
I regretted my first abortion, still do, bothers me and brings me to tears, does that mean that I wouldn't have appreciated support through the procedure..... Um no! My second abortion 5yrs later was completely different, I felt nothing but relief afterward, would I have appreciated support during that procedure too, despite my emotional condition.... Yes.
I am firm believer in a woman's right to chose. Not necessarily abortion, but her right to chose. I'm really only looking for opinions and stories of support on this subject to see if this right for me and if other women think this would be a helpful service.
Thanks again (didn't mean to go off on a tangent)
|
Did you find this post helpful?

User Profile
replied October 28th, 2006
Extremely eHealthy
Did you feel that you were forced or pushed into your abortion or did you just feel that you did what was right at that time? Did you not research the abortion and did you not feel that it was your choice. Most nurses are understanding if they work in these situations, it could have been your attitude too. I am sorry that you had a bad experience and I realize that having an abortion is not an easy situation but there comes a time where you have to move on and sometimes we need some help with it and there is nothing wrong with that, we pretty much all need some help sometime in our lives, mental health is a good place to start although they may not be able to help you, they know of other organizations that can.
Good luck!
|
Did you find this post helpful?

replied October 29th, 2006
Experienced User
Re: Question For Those Who've Aborted
|
Did you find this post helpful?

replied October 29th, 2006
Experienced User
|
Did you find this post helpful?

User Profile
replied October 29th, 2006
Extremely eHealthy
Re: Question For Those Who've Aborted
eugeniabrown wrote:
diamondsz wrote:



please stop spreading lies, this is a support forum!


i am not the one spreading lies, and if there is only one woman saying "abortion really hurts", let me be that one.


Thank you.


it doesnt real labour hurts more, I hemoraged with my frist child and with my second I had placenta left in me which required a d&c to remove left over pieces
|
Did you find this post helpful?

replied October 30th, 2006
Experienced User
Re: Question For Those Who've Aborted
|
Did you find this post helpful?

User Profile
replied October 30th, 2006
Especially eHealthy
This forum does not promote abortion. This forum provides support for women who have already decided or are considering abortion, without giving them crap over their decision. Supportive, not promotive. There is a difference. Have a nice day.
|
Did you find this post helpful?

replied October 30th, 2006
Experienced User
|
Did you find this post helpful?
12 >>