I'm surprised with these results. I lost almost 12lbs the first 2 weeks and finished my weight loss after another 4 weeks. I lost 20lbs total and kept it off for 6 months before something happened that made me gain a few lbs back. I plan to go back on phase 1 for at least a week and then maintain my weight again.
I have no idea how some people think this diet is too restrictive, you only cut out carbs and sugar (sugar is the real culprit) for 2 weeks and then you can start eating a couple servings of good carbs, chocolate, whathaveyou, and all the fruits and veggies you want every day. Plus I love that I can have wine.
Personally any diet where you restrict calories or have to count things is too restrictive for me. I have to eat when I need it because of my low blood sugar and this diet was great for that. Plus, I could never do weight watchers because you have to attend meetings and pay for things, whereas with South Beach I only paid $12 for the book at Walmart and bought the food. Cooking all that fresh food was difficult, but my fiance did it with me and we would switch off cooking our meals for a few days at a time.
Note- I did not exercise during this diet because I couldn't afford gym membership or equipment and I was working 2 jobs. But I thought it was amazing that I could lose the weight without it. Doing yoga and cycling afterwards helped me maintain. I am going to start cycling indoors.