Abortion Debate Forum - to Sunshine page 2
medical questions | health forums

to Sunshine

New Topic  Reply  Ask A Doctor - Offline
Medical Questions-> Health Forums -> Abortion Debate -> to Sunshine
Author Message
nightangel73

Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 09 Nov 2005
Posts: 2774
Location: ,
Thanks: 19
Thanked:18
Re: to Sunshine
Posted: 01-19-06 11:38am

jenn_smithson wrote:
nightangel73 wrote:
most of these girls who abort children don't know god.
first, according to the .A.G.I, 56% of .Women in the .U.S who obtain an abortion are in their 20's. They aren't "girls" but are .Women.

Quote:
they were not raised in a christian home, nor they received a christian education.
again, according to the .A.G.I, 78% of the .Women who obtain an abortion report a religious affiliation. Http://www.Agi-usa.Org/media/press kits/2005/06/28/abortionoverview.Html

"the highest proportion (43%) identified themselves as protestant. Twenty-seven percent of women having an abortion identified themselves as catholic, and 8% as a member of another religion; 22% reported no religious affiliation. Thirteen percent identified themselves as "born-again" or evangelical, three-fourths of whom were protestant (not shown)."
http://www. Guttmacher.Org/pubs/journals/3422602.Html< /a>


one thing is claim to have a religious affiliation and other is being actually religious. A person who loves god in their heart is not going to have an abortion. It just doesn't happen. But feel free to think otherwise.
Did you find this post useful?
|
sunshine424

Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 17 Nov 2005
Posts: 397
Location: New York
Re: to Sunshine
Posted: 01-19-06 15:01pm

nightangel73 wrote:
jenn_smithson wrote:
nightangel73 wrote:
most of these girls who abort children don't know god.
first, according to the .A.G.I, 56% of .Women in the .U.S who obtain an abortion are in their 20's. They aren't "girls" but are .Women.


Quote:
they were not raised in a christian home, nor they received a christian education.
again, according to the .A.G.I, 78% of the .Women who obtain an abortion report a religious affiliation. Http://www.Agi-usa.Org/media/press kits/2005/06/28/abortionoverview.Html

"the highest proportion (43%) identified themselves as protestant. Twenty-seven percent of women having an abortion identified themselves as catholic, and 8% as a member of another religion; 22% reported no religious affiliation. Thirteen percent identified themselves as "born-again" or evangelical, three-fourths of whom were protestant (not shown)."
http://www. Guttmacher.Org/pubs/journals/3422602.Html< /a>


one thing is claim to have a religious affiliation and other is being actually religious. A person who loves god in their heart is not going to have an abortion. It just doesn't happen. But feel free to think otherwise.


agreed. There are a ton of people around that world that identify themselves as part of a religion but don't actually practice it.
Did you find this post useful?
|
Tylanas

Especially EHEALTHy
Joined: 13 Jul 2005
Posts: 12976
Thanks: 3
Thanked:0

Posted: 01-19-06 19:38pm

I must agree with jenn's data. Mostly because it's true. Secondly, I love god (or whatever it is that's up there, i'm not sure) but I might still have an abortion if it came to that. That doesn't diminish my love for god.
Did you find this post useful?
|
nightangel73

Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 09 Nov 2005
Posts: 2774
Location: ,
Thanks: 19
Thanked:18

Posted: 01-19-06 20:31pm

eiri wrote:
i must agree with jenn's data. Mostly because it's true. Secondly, I love god (or whatever it is that's up there, i'm not sure) but I might still have an abortion if it came to that. That doesn't diminish my love for god.


and what is your imaginary god about? What are his rules? The only thing I can guess is that your god is okay with taking away life.
Did you find this post useful?
|
nightangel73

Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 09 Nov 2005
Posts: 2774
Location: ,
Thanks: 19
Thanked:18

Posted: 01-19-06 20:42pm

hahahahahahaha wrote:
nightangel73 wrote:
and what is your imaginary god about? What are his rules? The only thing I can guess is that your god is okay with taking away life.


kind of like yours.


the question was not addressed to you.
Did you find this post useful?
|
Tylanas

Especially EHEALTHy
Joined: 13 Jul 2005
Posts: 12976
Thanks: 3
Thanked:0

Posted: 01-19-06 20:47pm

nightangel73 wrote:
eiri wrote:
i must agree with jenn's data. Mostly because it's true. Secondly, I love god (or whatever it is that's up there, i'm not sure) but I might still have an abortion if it came to that. That doesn't diminish my love for god.


and what is your imaginary god about? What are his rules? The only thing I can guess is that your god is okay with taking away life.


i follow many things from the bible, but I also reject some things. I take bits and pieces from all religions. I believe that all religions are worshipping the same god (even the polytheistic ones, they have simply splitnered him) they just refuse to admit it.

My god is your god, but you have assigned things to him that are not true.


Last edited by Tylanas on 01-19-06 20:48pm; edited 1 time in total
Did you find this post useful?
|
sunshine424

Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 17 Nov 2005
Posts: 397
Location: New York

Posted: 01-19-06 20:47pm

eiri wrote:
i must agree with jenn's data. Mostly because it's true. Secondly, I love god (or whatever it is that's up there, i'm not sure) but I might still have an abortion if it came to that. That doesn't diminish my love for god.


yes, can I ask too, what is your ".God" like? You are really confused I think. You talk of god and your love for god. Yet you talk trash quite often too about the "man" up above. Eiri, for the 100th time, which is it? You do or don't believe in .God? I would just like an answer.
And yes, your "god" must feel it is okay to kill.
Did you find this post useful?
|
sunshine424

Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 17 Nov 2005
Posts: 397
Location: New York

Posted: 01-19-06 20:48pm

eiri wrote:
nightangel73 wrote:
eiri wrote:
i must agree with jenn's data. Mostly because it's true. Secondly, I love god (or whatever it is that's up there, i'm not sure) but I might still have an abortion if it came to that. That doesn't diminish my love for god.


and what is your imaginary god about? What are his rules? The only thing I can guess is that your god is okay with taking away life.


i follow many things rom the bible, but I also reject some things. I take bits and pieces from all religions. I believe that all religions are worshipping the same god (even the polytheistic ones, they have simply splitnered him) they just refuse to admit it.


My god is your god, but you have assigned things to him that are not true.


maybe .Y.O.U assigned things to him that are not true. Why is it that nightangel assigned things that are not true. Assume much?
Did you find this post useful?
|
sunshine424

Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 17 Nov 2005
Posts: 397
Location: New York

Posted: 01-19-06 20:48pm

nightangel73 wrote:
hahahahahahaha wrote:
nightangel73 wrote:
and what is your imaginary god about? What are his rules? The only thing I can guess is that your god is okay with taking away life.


kind of like yours.


the question was not addressed to you.


it's called "obnoxious".
Did you find this post useful?
|
Tylanas

Especially EHEALTHy
Joined: 13 Jul 2005
Posts: 12976
Thanks: 3
Thanked:0

Posted: 01-19-06 20:52pm

sunshine424 wrote:
eiri wrote:
i must agree with jenn's data. Mostly because it's true. Secondly, I love god (or whatever it is that's up there, i'm not sure) but I might still have an abortion if it came to that. That doesn't diminish my love for god.


yes, can I ask too, what is your ".God" like? You are really confused I think. You talk of god and your love for god. Yet you talk trash quite often too about the "man" up above. Eiri, for the 100th time, which is it? You do or don't believe in .God? I would just like an answer.
And yes, your "god" must feel it is okay to kill.


for the 101st time, I do not believe in the christian god as you portray him. I diss the bible and the people who wrote it, not god. There is a difference; the bible was written by mortal men, and god surpasses all of that.

Imagine god is a gigantic discoball. Every single religion is looking at one single mirror on that ball and declares it as the "one true god" (or thay pick more than one, like polytheistics) but almost no one sees the whole ball, and none of you want to admit that these facets of god are what makes up the whole.

That is how I see god.
Did you find this post useful?
|
Tylanas

Especially EHEALTHy
Joined: 13 Jul 2005
Posts: 12976
Thanks: 3
Thanked:0

Posted: 01-19-06 21:01pm

As for killing, god understands that things die. In buddhism, if a child dies, it was meant to be (i don't believe in fate but I do believe in the buddhist belief of reincarnation, sort of). It's soul just returns up to... Nirvana, like a large pool of souls... But it's one biiiig soul, like a big bowl of soup. Little drops come out, expereince life as humans, and then return to the big soul. That's my belief anyway.

Souls cannot get "lost", or "wasted", because they don't get a chance to live life. They just go back up and wait until the time is right.
Did you find this post useful?
|
sunshine424

Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 17 Nov 2005
Posts: 397
Location: New York

Posted: 01-19-06 21:04pm

eiri wrote:
as for killing, god understands that things die. In buddhism, if a child dies, it was meant to be (i don't believe in fate but I do believe in the buddhist belief of reincarnation, sort of). It's soul just returns up to... Nirvana, like a large pool of souls... But it's one biiiig soul, like a big bowl of soup. Little drops come out, expereince life as humans, and then return to the big soul. That's my belief anyway.


Souls cannot get "lost", or "wasted", because they don't get a chance to live life. They just go back up and wait until the time is right.


of course .God understands that things die. When it's your time, it just is. But he does not understand killing. He doesn't tolerate that. He forgives, but killing is not acceptable to .God. If a child dies, it was the child's time, but killing a child does not mean it was the child's time. Your "bowl of soup" example is pretty trippy. Lol
Did you find this post useful?
|
nightangel73

Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 09 Nov 2005
Posts: 2774
Location: ,
Thanks: 19
Thanked:18

Posted: 01-19-06 21:06pm

eiri wrote:
sunshine424 wrote:
eiri wrote:
i must agree with jenn's data. Mostly because it's true. Secondly, I love god (or whatever it is that's up there, i'm not sure) but I might still have an abortion if it came to that. That doesn't diminish my love for god.


yes, can I ask too, what is your ".God" like? You are really confused I think. You talk of god and your love for god. Yet you talk trash quite often too about the "man" up above. Eiri, for the 100th time, which is it? You do or don't believe in .God? I would just like an answer.
And yes, your "god" must feel it is okay to kill.


for the 101st time, I do not believe in the christian god as you portray him. I diss the bible and the people who wrote it, not god. There is a difference; the bible was written by mortal men, and god surpasses all of that.


Imagine god is a gigantic discoball. Every single religion is looking at one single mirror on that ball and declares it as the "one true god" (or thay pick more than one, like polytheistics) but almost no one sees the whole ball, and none of you want to admit that these facets of god are what makes up the whole.


That is how I see god.


and you don't think eiri if god is that powerful that he couldn't be able to get his message across written by mortal men? He is the god of the mortal men.

I agree that others religion do point out the same god. I have indian coworkers and for how the describe their religion the principles are the same. Do not kill, do not steal and so on...I actually asked my indian coworker today what do hindus think of abortion. She told me "it's a sin"
Did you find this post useful?
|
Tylanas

Especially EHEALTHy
Joined: 13 Jul 2005
Posts: 12976
Thanks: 3
Thanked:0

Posted: 01-19-06 21:13pm

sunshine424 wrote:
eiri wrote:
as for killing, god understands that things die. In buddhism, if a child dies, it was meant to be (i don't believe in fate but I do believe in the buddhist belief of reincarnation, sort of). It's soul just returns up to... Nirvana, like a large pool of souls... But it's one biiiig soul, like a big bowl of soup. Little drops come out, expereince life as humans, and then return to the big soul. That's my belief anyway.



Souls cannot get "lost", or "wasted", because they don't get a chance to live life. They just go back up and wait until the time is right.


of course .God understands that things die. When it's your time, it just is. But he does not understand killing. He doesn't tolerate that. He forgives, but killing is not acceptable to .God. If a child dies, it was the child's time, but killing a child does not mean it was the child's time. Your "bowl of soup" example is pretty trippy. Lol


it's not acceptable to your god. Your misinterpreted god. God understand the value of life, and how people are more worthy than fetuses.
Did you find this post useful?
|
sunshine424

Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 17 Nov 2005
Posts: 397
Location: New York

Posted: 01-19-06 21:22pm

eiri wrote:
sunshine424 wrote:
eiri wrote:
as for killing, god understands that things die. In buddhism, if a child dies, it was meant to be (i don't believe in fate but I do believe in the buddhist belief of reincarnation, sort of). It's soul just returns up to... Nirvana, like a large pool of souls... But it's one biiiig soul, like a big bowl of soup. Little drops come out, expereince life as humans, and then return to the big soul. That's my belief anyway.




Souls cannot get "lost", or "wasted", because they don't get a chance to live life. They just go back up and wait until the time is right.


of course .God understands that things die. When it's your time, it just is. But he does not understand killing. He doesn't tolerate that. He forgives, but killing is not acceptable to .God. If a child dies, it was the child's time, but killing a child does not mean it was the child's time. Your "bowl of soup" example is pretty trippy. Lol


it's not acceptable to your god. Your misinterpreted god. God understand the value of life, and how people are more worthy than fetuses.


l.O.L!!!!!!!!!!!! Are you being serious? Tell me for your sake that your joking!
I'm pretty sure .God does not feel that any human is more "worthy" than another. That's basic belief and knowledge! Have you hit your head?!
Did you find this post useful?
|
jenn_smithson

Active User, Really EHEALTHy
Joined: 15 Nov 2004
Posts: 808
Location: Texas

Posted: 01-19-06 22:40pm

sunshine424 wrote:
of course .God understands that things die. When it's your time, it just is. But he does not understand killing. He doesn't tolerate that.
he seemed to have tolerated it just fine when he was the one commanding the killing. If you are going to follow the bible or support it, then you should take another look at how god is portrayed in the old testament. And don't forget to take special notice of the instances where he, himself, commands the killing of innocent women, children, fetus', and animals.
Quote:
he forgives, but killing is not acceptable to .God.
so then is it only "acceptable" when he commands the killing? Does that mean that the crazy guy on the corner who kills someone and claims that god commanded him to is acceptable?

You don't get to pick and choose the pieces of the bible that support you and deny the rest and then turn around and tell other people that what they believe in is wrong.
Did you find this post useful?
|
nightangel73

Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 09 Nov 2005
Posts: 2774
Location: ,
Thanks: 19
Thanked:18

Posted: 01-19-06 23:09pm

jenn_smithson wrote:
sunshine424 wrote:
of course .God understands that things die. When it's your time, it just is. But he does not understand killing. He doesn't tolerate that.
he seemed to have tolerated it just fine when he was the one commanding the killing. If you are going to follow the bible or support it, then you should take another look at how god is portrayed in the old testament. And don't forget to take special notice of the instances where he, himself, commands the killing of innocent women, children, fetus', and animals.
Quote:
he forgives, but killing is not acceptable to .God.
so then is it only "acceptable" when he commands the killing? Does that mean that the crazy guy on the corner who kills someone and claims that god commanded him to is acceptable?


You don't get to pick and choose the pieces of the bible that support you and deny the rest and then turn around and tell other people that what they believe in is wrong.


yes jenn if god is the one commanding the killing then it is acceptable. He is .God. The crazy guy you describe claims that god commanded but really god didn't commanded. But if truly god had commanded then yes it would be acceptable.
Did you find this post useful?
|
jenn_smithson

Active User, Really EHEALTHy
Joined: 15 Nov 2004
Posts: 808
Location: Texas

Posted: 01-20-06 00:51am

nightangel73 wrote:
jenn_smithson wrote:
sunshine424 wrote:
of course .God understands that things die. When it's your time, it just is. But he does not understand killing. He doesn't tolerate that.
he seemed to have tolerated it just fine when he was the one commanding the killing. If you are going to follow the bible or support it, then you should take another look at how god is portrayed in the old testament. And don't forget to take special notice of the instances where he, himself, commands the killing of innocent women, children, fetus', and animals.
Quote:
he forgives, but killing is not acceptable to .God.
so then is it only "acceptable" when he commands the killing? Does that mean that the crazy guy on the corner who kills someone and claims that god commanded him to is acceptable?
You don't get to pick and choose the pieces of the bible that support you and deny the rest and then turn around and tell other people that what they believe in is wrong.


yes jenn if god is the one commanding the killing then it is acceptable. He is .God. The crazy guy you describe claims that god commanded but really god didn't commanded. But if truly god had commanded then yes it would be acceptable.
?[/quote] then the question still remains how do you tell the acceptable killing from the unacceptable killing if you are simply using the bible as your guide?

The bible was written by human, fallible men. To many in their time, they were the crazy guys on the corner claiming fantastical things about god. How can one human claiming that they were commanded by god be taken any more seriously than another human claiming to be commanded to a certain action by god?

And, not only did the god of the old testament command people to kill whole races but he also commanded lying, blackmail, and thievery. His will be done!
Did you find this post useful?
|
Tylanas

Especially EHEALTHy
Joined: 13 Jul 2005
Posts: 12976
Thanks: 3
Thanked:0

Posted: 01-20-06 13:45pm

sunshine424 wrote:
eiri wrote:
sunshine424 wrote:
eiri wrote:
as for killing, god understands that things die. In buddhism, if a child dies, it was meant to be (i don't believe in fate but I do believe in the buddhist belief of reincarnation, sort of). It's soul just returns up to... Nirvana, like a large pool of souls... But it's one biiiig soul, like a big bowl of soup. Little drops come out, expereince life as humans, and then return to the big soul. That's my belief anyway.

Souls cannot get "lost", or "wasted", because they don't get a chance to live life. They just go back up and wait until the time is right.


of course .God understands that things die. When it's your time, it just is. But he does not understand killing. He doesn't tolerate that. He forgives, but killing is not acceptable to .God. If a child dies, it was the child's time, but killing a child does not mean it was the child's time. Your "bowl of soup" example is pretty trippy. Lol


it's not acceptable to your god. Your misinterpreted god. God understand the value of life, and how people are more worthy than fetuses.


l.O.L!!!!!!!!!!!! Are you being serious? Tell me for your sake that your joking!

I'm pretty sure .God does not feel that any human is more "worthy" than another. That's basic belief and knowledge! Have you hit your head?!


you have what you believe, I have what I believe. If your god loves people and hates death so much, why did he let the dinosaurs die? Why is there diesease and famine?

God isn't as involved in our lives as you'd like to believe. He set up earth, and maybe he tweaked something here or there to make sure that all of the lucky coincedences that were needed for us to develop happened, but beyond that, he just watches and doesn't interfere.

Or maybe, he made the universe with the thought that "if I make billions of planets, one of them is bound to develop life." in fact, I bet a lot of planets have life. We just have to find them.

I believe god (the collective soul I spoke of) just watches us, and welcomes us back whenever that happens to occour.
Did you find this post useful?
|
~*~Jillian~*~

Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 01 Feb 2005
Posts: 1759
Location: Tennessee, USA

Posted: 01-20-06 18:02pm

eiri wrote:
sunshine424 wrote:
eiri wrote:
sunshine424 wrote:
eiri wrote:
as for killing, god understands that things die. In buddhism, if a child dies, it was meant to be (i don't believe in fate but I do believe in the buddhist belief of reincarnation, sort of). It's soul just returns up to... Nirvana, like a large pool of souls... But it's one biiiig soul, like a big bowl of soup. Little drops come out, expereince life as humans, and then return to the big soul. That's my belief anyway.


Souls cannot get "lost", or "wasted", because they don't get a chance to live life. They just go back up and wait until the time is right.


of course .God understands that things die. When it's your time, it just is. But he does not understand killing. He doesn't tolerate that. He forgives, but killing is not acceptable to .God. If a child dies, it was the child's time, but killing a child does not mean it was the child's time. Your "bowl of soup" example is pretty trippy. Lol


it's not acceptable to your god. Your misinterpreted god. God understand the value of life, and how people are more worthy than fetuses.


l.O.L!!!!!!!!!!!! Are you being serious? Tell me for your sake that your joking!


I'm pretty sure .God does not feel that any human is more "worthy" than another. That's basic belief and knowledge! Have you hit your head?!


you have what you believe, I have what I believe. If your god loves people and hates death so much, why did he let the dinosaurs die? Why is there diesease and famine?


God isn't as involved in our lives as you'd like to believe. He set up earth, and maybe he tweaked something here or there to make sure that all of the lucky coincedences that were needed for us to develop happened, but beyond that, he just watches and doesn't interfere.


Or maybe, he made the universe with the thought that "if I make billions of planets, one of them is bound to develop life." in fact, I bet a lot of planets have life. We just have to find them.


I believe god (the collective soul I spoke of) just watches us, and welcomes us back whenever that happens to occour.


how do you get that god isnt involved in our lives as much as we'd like to believe ...??? Every single thing that happens on earth...Happens because god made that plan ...Birth,death,etc...All gods plan ..So I really dont understand how god's not involved as much as we seem to think he is...
Did you find this post useful?
|
Related Topics
This Forum This Category All Forums
Jump to:  
Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4  Next
New Topic   Reply



Page 2 of 4
We comply with the HONcode standard for trustworthy health
information:
verify here.