I tried to do it epidural free, but didn't succeed.
I was in labor for two weeks before my water broke. Once my water broke, progress just stopped. So they put me on a pitocin drip. Which made my contractions really strong and one after another.
I tried nubain. They told me it would ease the pain and let me rest for a few hours. Nope!! 15 minutes after it was given to me, I was in worse pain than before!
After another 2 hours I was begging for the epi. I was so mad at myself. I really wanted to do it without but I would've never made any progress if I hadn't!
It did help a lot. By the time I started pushing, it had worn off so I felt everything. But like I said, the only reason I got to that point is because I had the epi, and could relax enough to let my contractions make their progress.
I have a friend that was given too high of a dose and didn't feel anything, which I would soooooo not want. I think that would ruin the experience.
If you decide for an epi, just make sure you have a good anesthesiologist.