Hernia Pain, Symptom Relief And Healing!!! Posted: 10-04-05 14:02pm
Hi, I am on my third hernia just now, it
is femoral and not progressed very far.
The surgeon said to wait a while because
it might heal and it did get better in
between but has just gotten worse again
even though I have tried not to put any
strain on it.
Did any ones hernia ever heal on its own?
And did any of you try that method
that some chiropractors/kineologists do to
fix hernias?
I really don't want to go through another
operation, I am only 22 and kind of
scared that if I have it operated again it
still won't be fixed or stay fixed and
with all that scar tissue there they can't
really do much already.
Also I have heard that the mesh they use
can cause the nervs to be constantly
irritated and cause chronic pain,
sometimes leading to another operation
where the nerves have to be removed and I
really don't want to go through that.
Has any one experienced anything like
that?
Any input on any one of my many questions
would be really much appreciated!
Thanks,
lena
Last edited by Lena121 on 04-13-06 08:12am; edited 4 times in total
|
Lena121
New User, Becoming EHEALTHy
Joined: 04 Oct 2005 Posts: 24 Location: UK
Posted: 11-03-05 15:49pm
Okay, I thought I would let you guys know,
about 10 days ago I came across this site
that said that you can relieve hernia pain
and symptoms by massaging the reflexpoints
on your feet. So I read up on it and
started massaging my feet, which were
pretty sore at the pressure points at the
start. After a couple of days the pain
started to recede, and believe it or not,
the bulge in my groin got smaller and
smaller too.
For the past four days I actually can't
feel it anymore at all, my groin feels
solid again, just like my left side, and
even though I am staying off the exercise
still to give it a chance to heal I am
confident that, if it isn't fixed, then
that I can at least keep the hernia at bay
without having a third surgery, which I am
so incredibly relieved about.
I have also been taking silicea to improve
the connective tissue and hawthorn for
about a month as well, I read that this
has been used for hernias too so I am just
taking that as well until the bottle runs
out.
I am not saying that this is the ultimate
remedy against hernias or for healing
them, I just thought I let you know that
so far it has worked for me and, fingers
crossed, hopefully it will stay that way.
:-)
|
Georgy
New User, Becoming EHEALTHy
Joined: 22 Nov 2005 Posts: 3 Location: Australia
Hernia - Inguinal Posted: 11-22-05 03:06am
My husband has had inguinal hernia and had
an operation done on it. Due to having
liver chirosis they did not put the mesh
in but just patched it up as best they
could (well that is the doctors story
anyways).
Because of the liver chirosis he went to
the specialist and all the specialist did
was charge $75 consultation fee every
couple of months so that he could write
our a prescription for water retention
with all the usual side effects like
hormones and impotence.
As I am a great beleiver in natural
healing I took him to an accupunturist who
helped him on his way to recovery. It
only took 6 months for my hubby to be 90%
healthy again. When he went back to the
specialist after 6months he was absolutely
shocked at the change (mind you hubby
hadn't been taking the medication that the
specialist wrote out for him).
Anyways, the hubby being the typical man
he is decided yep, I can do whatever I
please now and either lifted something too
heavy, moved to wrong way or whatever and
gave himself another hernia.
The accupunturist was able to help him
with that too. It took between 6weeks to
12 weeks to for it to completely go away
and after three months when it was time to
do the general blood tests and ultrasounds
for the specialists I got the lady who did
the ultra sound to have a look at his
hernia, she would not believe me when I
told her that he recently had a hernia.
As the hubby being a typical male cannot
wait for things to go wrong did himself in
again and I am now doing refelexology on
his hands and feet. It is slowly but
surely helping him also.
What we have found also to held is ginger
to soothe the inflamation, rosehip vital
is a must as this helps with the vitamin c
which actually heals generate/heal tissue
cells as well as barley grass which gives
the body all the vitamins/minerals etc
that it needs. Pretty much food for the
body.
Hope this helps anyone who has problems.
It may not be for everyone but it
certainly helped my hubby.
As far as the barley grass and the rosehip
vital goes my family live and breath by
it. The story as far as barley grass
goes from what I hear has the following
history.
A chinese dr? Pretty sure chinese dr had
stomach cancer and was given a couple of
months to live and was told he couldnt be
helped. He got to the point where he
couldn't eat. Anyway where this guy
lived they had barley shoots/grass growing
all around and his wife cut them up and
gave them to the hubby, after a while he
couldn't eat it like this so she ground
them up into a power for the hubby to eat.
He got to the point where he couldn't
eat it like that either so she diluted it
in water. Slowly but surely he got
better. This is pretty much how barley
grass came about so the story goes.
There are many different varieties of
barley grass around but I am sticking with
the premium one which is in a clear bottle
and the bottle is in a cardboard box.
Cost a lot more but is well worth is
weight in gold. It has bought my hubby
back from the grave as far as his liver
chirossis goes and I don't really care
what any doctor has to say about natural
medicines and remedies.
Oh well, hope I havent offended anyone
yours in health
georgy
|
Lena121
New User, Becoming EHEALTHy
Joined: 04 Oct 2005 Posts: 24 Location: UK
Hernia Healing? Posted: 02-27-06 17:39pm
Hi, I thought I would update. I stopped
the reflex zone massages on my feet once
the pain had went away, and strangely
after it did my stomach didn't really pop
out any more either. I think the hawthorn
helped this as well, because when I
stopped taking it in december and started
to do some moderate swimming and fast
walking the bulge came back, not as big as
before but still, it popped out and I
could push it back in.
Since then I found out that taking vitamin
q10 complex (30mg) helps with muscle tone
so I started taking that, still with the
silica and this seems to do the trick. I
can lift up to 4 kilos again without my
intestine pushing out, before I could not
even lift 2 kg without that happening, so
this is really much better. If I go over
the limit carrying shopping my intestine
still sometimes seems to press against the
muscle strand and it is painful, but I
actually haven't had to push the intestine
back in in about a month or so. I am
hoping that it is actually healing
(fingers crossed!!!) and am still taking
it easy with exercise. I do walk five
days a week at a pretty fast pace downhill
to university which is about a 25 minute
walk and that isn't a problem at all. I
can also do short runs without getting any
problems, I am still too scared to dare
anything more since I really believe that
the hernia is getting smaller and I don't
want to risk it getting bigger again if it
might be in the process of actually
healing.
So my advice to anyone with a hernia would
be:
do foot massages, the sore spots are the
ones you need to pay attention to, but buy
a reflexology book since people who have
liver disease etc. Aren't meant to use
it.
Also:
take anything that strengthens muscles
such as silica and vitamin q10, I think
omega fish oils might help as well as well
as taking a multivitamin for general
health.
Vitamin c is also especially important, as
well as calcium and magnesium, so maybe
one of those a-z vitamin products would be
a good idea to take.
Hawthorn can also relieve symptoms and
pain!
Recent research has shown that people who
do not get their hernia operated are
usually not less in pain than the ones who
do, and waiting several years before
having an operation does generally not
have any bad effects.
I can confirm this from personal
experience, before both previous
operations a considerable amount of time
passed by before I was correctly diagnosed
and I didn't feel much more disabled
before either surgery, it was really only
the doctor scare talk ("you can die if it
gets trapped" and "ohh, horseback riding
is the worst you can do with a hernia")
made me have them.
Now, third time around I am luckily a bit
better informed and I won't have another
operation unless I feel that there is
absolutely no way around it.
|
Georgy
New User, Becoming EHEALTHy
Joined: 22 Nov 2005 Posts: 3 Location: Australia
Hawthorn , Reflexology And Hernia Posted: 03-11-06 22:49pm
Thanks for the update.
In regards to the question about a hernia
healing on its own yes it can heal on its
own and my husband is living proof of
that. He is on his third hernia but only
due to his health being low with his liver
and his inability to be careful when
lifting heavy objects. He seems to think
he is superman.
The first hernia he had he had it operated
on and mind you the doctor did not do a
very good job on it because not long after
it came back. The second hernia he had
mended on its own with the help of
accupunture and natural/herbal
medicines.
He is now onto his third hernia which is
healing.
As of today I have my hubby on hawthorn
and since your last update I had him on
the multivitamin complex. All the
medication that I have him on are from the
health food shop as they provide 100% cold
pressed medicines. I find that the
natural medicines you buy at the chemist
or grocery stores are heat pressed and
they are no good simply because all the
good things evaporate out of them and
there is pretty much nothing left in them
when they get to you.
Havent' heard of the reflexology not being
good for liver but shall keep that in mind
now. I presume you have put a lot of
effort into following that up greatly
appreciate your feedback on that one.
My hubby has been taking the liver tonic
tablets for about 2 months now and mind
you his liver did a back flip for a while
and this is why I started him back on the
natural therapies. After 2 months of the
natural therapies his eyes have only a
slight tinge of yellow in them.
His hernia has been helped also by the
milk thistle in it. The intestines were
not only pushed oustide of the wall but
have gone into his testicle but with the
milk thistle it is not as large as it was
before and hopefully now with the multi
vitamin and hawthorn this should help even
more to reduce and totally heal with
time.
The only reason I think the hernia got as
far is it did was that he is the type of
person that cannot sit still and not do
things like heavy lifting etc. He always
has to do something.
Going by the size his hernia was and is
now, he is healing in leaps and bounds.
What I also found useful for the hernia is
for him to lie down on his back and lift
his rear end up a bit for half an hour
twice a day. This allows for the
intestines and pelvis to return to their
appropriate positions giving the torn
tissue a bit of a rest from the pressure.
It is gradually healing with this also.
Worth while trying?!?!
Hope this helps. Any feed back you may
have let me know and we shall try any
suggestions.
Georgy
|
Lena121
New User, Becoming EHEALTHy
Joined: 04 Oct 2005 Posts: 24 Location: UK
Posted: 03-12-06 13:21pm
Hi georgy, thanks so much for your reply
and feedback, I think I will try that with
the milk thistle now that you have
mentioned it, I have heard that it is
really good for body cleansing and that so
I will definatly give it a shot.
Also I believe that the vitamin q 10
complex is what has greatly contributed to
my hernia healing, since I have been
taking it it has become really so much
better I can't believe it.
It doesn't protrude anymore at all and I
did some exercise on my stepper for 10
mins two days ago which was fine, no pain
afterwards and no bulge, yay!
I will still be careful with it and try
and slowly increase the time that I
exercise, I really want to go swimming but
want my hernia to be slightly more stable
before I go and power on for an hour, I
just love swimming too much :-)
i am also doing some strengthening
exercises my physiotherapist taught me
after my first operation, you basically
put a ball (like the rubber ones for your
kids) that isn't too hard and big between
your knees while sitting on a chair and
you just push the ball with your knees
slightly together, count till five and
release again. Wait five to ten seconds
and repeat again a couple of times, that
strengthens those thigh muscles and the
groin area.
I think this might be too early for you
hubby just now while his hernia is still
protruding, but once it isn't anymore this
might be a good way of preventing new
hernias from building and so that he can
keep on lifting all those heavy things.
It must be worse for a guy, I already feel
stupid half the time when I have to tell
my boyfriend "can you please lift that for
me, it is too heavy" but imagine a guy
having to do that? Tell him I feel for
him, I absolutely hate being helpless and
I love my exercise, not being able to do
it so frustrating, and I am absolutely
jigging and impatient to start properly
and to do more.
Take care and tell your hubby that I hope
his groin is back to normal soon!
Lena
|
Lena121
New User, Becoming EHEALTHy
Joined: 04 Oct 2005 Posts: 24 Location: UK
Update Posted: 04-13-06 08:18am
Thought I would let you all know, my
hernia seems to be pretty much healed,
touch wood, at least it isn't giving me
any problems anymore at all.
I have went swimming 1-2 times a week for
the past weeks, an hour each and when I
swim I swim properly, and after the first
session where I had some muscle ache I
have had no problems during or afterwards
at all.
I notice that my right leg (where the
hernia was located) is much weaker than my
left now because I have been taking the
pressure off it so much. I am now
concentrating on getting the strength back
into it and in building up the muscles
again so that the whole groin area can get
stronger again.
I can also lift and carry at least 4 kilos
now without any protrusion, I think I can
problably do more but don't want to risk
it in case something does happen.
Take care,
lena
|
davidak
New User, Becoming EHEALTHy
Joined: 08 Nov 2007 Posts: 33 Location: London, UK UK
Thanks: 0
Thanked:1
Posted: 11-08-07 08:53am
I realised I had a hernia about 2 months
ago. Since then it has got slightly worse.
It is in my groin, right side, just above
the leg and sometimes it feels slightly
painful, at other times I notice it not at
all.
I just found this forum, and this page and
am interested in finding out what other
men have done to cause the hernia to heal
without surgery.
I am scheduled to have surgery on 18
December, the open cut and put in the mesh
type.
But I am worried that the pain of the mesh
on the nerves will be too much to bear and
that the hernia may reoccur anyway.
I would prefer to strengthen myself and
get the hernia to be healed using more
natural methods if possible.
I have been doing some exercises, but
someone here also mentioned things like
milk thistle and Q10, which I shall start
taking more (not really taken them much in
the past). I also take astragalus for
general immune system strengthening as
well as other health supplements (mostly
bought from Higher Nature).
What other supplements are best to take to
defeat the hernia quickly so that I do not
need to have the surgery?
|
chugach7
New User, Becoming EHEALTHy
Joined: 09 Nov 2007 Posts: 2
Hernia? I'm In My Prime!!! Posted: 11-09-07 07:23am
I'm a 34 year old guy who's in pretty damn
good shape. I hike, mountainbike, &
snowboard regularly. I also climb
mountains to go backcountry snowboarding
as often as possible. I don't work out at
all, hurt my back long ago, again this
summer, and do have a few creaks and
moans, BUT.... feel strongly that I'm not
far from being physically stronger than I
have ever felt in my life.
How disgusted was I when I felt a dull
pain in the groin a few days ago? Pretty
sick. My father and nephew have both had
the hernia surgery, so I guess it runs in
my genes, but I am in far superior
physical shape than my father ever even
thought of.
I DID move a big pile of gravel two
days prior with a wheel barrow, and I
guess I'll blame it on that, but the
tender testicles and pea sized lump on my
pubic line didn't come to notice for two
days.
What's the story on the testes? One of
the posts mentioned intestines dropping
into the scrotum? The pain is minimal and
hasn't progressed in two days, but I'm
interested in acupuncture and natural
remedies as I just recently lost health
care. I read on WebMD, and tried later,
to "push back in the lump" after applying
BioFreeze, to no avail. How critical is
it that I see a physician if the pain and
lump lessens?
More importantly, whether or not I opt
for Canadian surgery, what are my chances
that I can exercise and rehabilitate my
abdomen and resume my very active
lifestyle?
Doctor, Will I be able to snowboard
this winter, PLEASE??????
|
davidak
New User, Becoming EHEALTHy
Joined: 08 Nov 2007 Posts: 33 Location: London, UK UK
Thanks: 0
Thanked:1
Posted: 11-09-07 17:30pm
Lena121
wrote:
Okay, I thought I would let
you guys know, about 10 days ago I came
across this site that said that you can
relieve hernia pain and symptoms by
massaging the reflexpoints on your feet.
So I read up on it and started massaging
my feet, which were pretty sore at the
pressure points at the start. After a
couple of days the pain started to recede,
and believe it or not, the bulge in my
groin got smaller and smaller too.
What website was that? Do you recall?
|
davidak
New User, Becoming EHEALTHy
Joined: 08 Nov 2007 Posts: 33 Location: London, UK UK
Thanks: 0
Thanked:1
Post Hernia Surgery Exercises? Posted: 12-20-07 18:31pm
I had my hernia (right inguinal) surgery
Tues 18 Dec 2007 at the Royal Free
Hospital. There were some delays in
getting through the operations, so mine
was later than expected, but the surgery
went well and I am now recovering at home.
There was some pain at first that was hard
to bear, but painkillers helped.
Today (Thursday) I have not needed the
painkillers, and seem to be making good
progress. I shall have to drink more
hawthorn tea again, after reading what was
written in one of the messages here, as I
really do not want any more pain.
Sometimes I have to cough, and that puts
stress on the abdomen and on the repaired
area. Otherwise I seem to be doing well
and hope to be going outside tomorrow
without any problems.
But I was wondering if there are any
special exercises to do after surgery to
help with the healing process? I certainly
am going to avoid any heavy lifting and
anything that puts stress on the wound. I
think that walking will help, but is there
anything else? While sitting indoors I
tend to wiggle my feet and legs around a
bit, stretch them out and back, as some
simple exercises to help.
|
dogsofwar
New User, Becoming EHEALTHy
Joined: 05 Jan 2008 Posts: 2
Alternative Medicine Posted: 01-05-08 20:33pm
Hello There,
i searched the web and found that there is
some alternative chines medicine, here are
the names :
1. hearease
2. HAWTHORNIA
did anyone have ever tried these stuff ?
talking with i doctor i have found that
there are some exercise that may help the
situation, did anyone ever heard about it
?
as for the food supplements the might help
it , whats recommendation there are ? (
stuff like Q10) ?
thanks!!!
|
davidak
New User, Becoming EHEALTHy
Joined: 08 Nov 2007 Posts: 33 Location: London, UK UK
Thanks: 0
Thanked:1
Posted: 01-07-08 07:28am
I am taking hawthorn tea occassionally,
that helps.
For health supplements, I take
astragalus
burdock root
olive leaf extract
slippery elm bark
probiotic mints
vitamins
arnica tablets (to take away bruising),
also I used arnica cream for the bruise on
my hand (from where they put the drip in)
and that bruise has now gone completely
plus pure concentrated aloe vera juice,
taking 20 ml in water once daily.
I use supplements made by Higher Nature
and Solgar mostly.
|
crawdaddy
New User, Becoming EHEALTHy
Joined: 24 Mar 2008 Posts: 1 Location: Martha's Vineyard, MA United States
How does Hawthorn help Hernia? Posted: 03-24-08 16:16pm
am reading all of your good suggestions on
self-healing but don't understand why
Hawthorn would help -- i thought it was
for Heart problems?
|
davidak
New User, Becoming EHEALTHy
Joined: 08 Nov 2007 Posts: 33 Location: London, UK UK
Thanks: 0
Thanked:1
Hawthorn and hernias Posted: 03-24-08 18:29pm
Quoting from a website about a product
that can help with hernias:
"Introduction: When pain or cramps occur
in the lower abdominal area, it may be a
hernia or other muscle discomfort and
weakness. There are about 5 million hernia
sufferers in the USA. Since there are no
recognized medications for hernias except
for hiatus hernia (a stomach problem), the
standard treatment is a surgery.
Hawthornia is a 100% natural formula well
proven in China to be effective to relieve
hernias (except hiatus hernia) and other
related symptoms caused by general
Qi-weakness or over-exercises. Hawthornia
relieves most symptoms of groin, femoral,
and inguinal hernias, and some of
umbilical hernia, especially in the early
stage of occurrence.
Main Ingredients: The 11 ingredients are
hawthorn, fennel, citrus seed, litchi
seed, China-berry fruit, peach kernel,
corydalis tuber, three-nerved spicebush,
nutgrass flatsedge, kelp, and oriental
water plantain. With a special process
these natural herbs are combined together
to produce the synergic effect to improve
Qi and to strengthen the lower abdominal
organ support muscles and tendons,
therefore the symptoms of hernias are
relieved. These herbal remedies have been
widely used in China over hundreds of
years with no side effects.
Main Actions: The herbs work
synergistically to strengthen Qi and the
organ support muscles and tendons in the
lower abs, so that the organs, including
intestines, will go back to stay in their
original positions, hence won’t fall
into any opening on the body wall,
therefore the symptoms of hernias
disappear. Of course, Hawthornia works
best when little symptoms have been felt;
if the lump becomes too big, and symptoms
remain after 2 bottles of Hawthornia, one
may need a surgery to seal the opening
first, then taking Hawthornia also help to
avoid symptoms happen on the other side of
lower abdomen. Usually after taking
Hawthornia for only a few days, the
symptoms are much relieved, and one could
stop taking Hawthornia, or only take it
when the symptoms come again, or take
Hawthornia as a nutritional supplement."
I cannot post a link to the site as it is
forbidden to do so on this forum Do a search on
Google for an excerpt from the text above.
|
Artie
New User, Becoming EHEALTHy
Joined: 01 Jul 2008 Posts: 31
Thanks: 0
Thanked:1
hernia Posted: 07-01-08 04:44am
Hi -- I'm 55 have a very small, painless,
asymptomatic inguinal hernia on the right.
I MAY have a tiny on the left as well, the
doc's aren't sure (?).
Like everyone out there, I have read the
endless surgery horror stories about mesh
complications, infections, rejections,
etc, and DESPERATELY want to avoid
surgery.
So far, the doc's (two regular doc's and
one specialist) have said "watchful
waiting" is basically ok for now. Maybe
they're coming to realize that the risks
of surgery may, in some cases, be greater
than the risk of just leaving things
alone.
However, I'm scared of doing anything that
might worsen the condition or "provoke" an
accident, so I find myself being
ultra-ultra-careful all the time, which is
very limiting (I feel like I'm becoming an
invalid).
I've been told that mild Pilates can be
helpful, but I've seen one or two websites
warning that it could make things worse
(??). Same with cycling, have seen both
sides. Anyone know anything about this?
I've ordered Hawthornia, and am interested
in trying vitamin Q10.
Any info on "alternatives" would be DEEPLY
appreciated as I don't want to start the
"surgery cycle" with one operation after
another. Many thanks.
|
GDSM
New User, Becoming EHEALTHy
Joined: 09 Jun 2008 Posts: 13
Thanks: 6
Thanked:0
Re: hernia Posted: 07-01-08 15:57pm
Artie
wrote:
Hi -- I'm 55 have a very
small, painless, asymptomatic inguinal
hernia on the right. I MAY have a tiny on
the left as well, the doc's aren't sure
(?).
Like everyone out there, I have read the
endless surgery horror stories about mesh
complications, infections, rejections,
etc, and DESPERATELY want to avoid
surgery.
So far, the doc's (two regular doc's and
one specialist) have said "watchful
waiting" is basically ok for now. Maybe
they're coming to realize that the risks
of surgery may, in some cases, be greater
than the risk of just leaving things
alone.
However, I'm scared of doing anything that
might worsen the condition or "provoke" an
accident, so I find myself being
ultra-ultra-careful all the time, which is
very limiting (I feel like I'm becoming an
invalid).
I've been told that mild Pilates can be
helpful, but I've seen one or two websites
warning that it could make things worse
(??). Same with cycling, have seen both
sides. Anyone know anything about this?
I've ordered Hawthornia, and am interested
in trying vitamin Q10.
Any info on "alternatives" would be DEEPLY
appreciated as I don't want to start the
"surgery cycle" with one operation after
another. Many
thanks.
First I would like to state that if your
hernia is asymptomatic then yes, watchful
waiting is a very good idea. It will give
you more time to research and possibly
find the right surgeon for yourself. Not
all hernias need to be repaired with a
mesh implant, although that is how most of
them are fixed now days. But you should
find a surgeon that you are comfortable
with and ask him what are all of your
alternatives, if all he offers is mesh,
ask why. Tell him that you have heard that
there may be complications with these
products and are more interested in a full
tissue repair with out mesh. If he tells
you he can not do it that way, ask him for
a referral to someone who can. It does
sound like you do have time on your hands
to research and find the right way to
repair the hernia when the time comes. It
is so much better when you see the
surgeon, when you have researched and
already know what the options are. He will
be amazed at how well informed you are.
i had a painfull hernia for five years and
it was killing me so i had it fixed about
a year ago with scope surgery ( just three
little holes) i got the mesh job and it
worked out great. in six weeks i was all
okay ang i am still doing fine. i am sorry
i waited so long.
|
Artie
New User, Becoming EHEALTHy
Joined: 01 Jul 2008 Posts: 31
Thanks: 0
Thanked:1
more serious mesh concerns Posted: 07-03-08 03:16am
Hi
You're very lucky. I've just read through
dozens of posts about horrific mesh
complications. Many have had to have the
mesh removed -- one guy was in intensive
care for six weeks as a result. The
stories are so grotesque and scary that I
had to stop reading them.
Please, see the many posts on mesh
complications. I've done tons of research
on umpteen websites, and the message is
clear: although many people are lucky
(hopefully you're one of them!), many
people are having the most HORRIFIC
problems thanks to mesh.
I saw a surgeon last week. He ONLY does
mesh, and he ONLY uses standard,
heavyweight mesh, the type most linked to
serious problems in various trials &
studies. The more mesh material, the more
the body reacts against it. It make
sense.
I am terrified of having sheets of plastic
stapled into my body. It's obvious that in
many people, the body reacts badly,
causing these terrible complications. I
personally know of two people in this
situation; one may never recover. The mesh
has apparently caused a fistula that has
broken through her abdomen (to the
surface). The doctors can't do anything
further for her.
I've looked at study after study, all of
which are showing roughly a 30% incidence
of chronic pain after hernia repair. 30%.
That's shocking, for any type of surgery
-- let alone something that is usually
billed as so "simple and safe" (???).
I'm in Brighton, England. There's a new
"bio" mesh produced in the UK called
Permacol. It's made of denatured,
sterilised porcine (pig) material. SO FAR
it's showing excellent results in terms of
NOT producing those horrible infections,
rejections, adhesions, etc. I believe
Surgisis in the USA is the same material.
The Shouldice procedure is only done
correctly at the famous Shouldice Hernia
Clinic in Toronto. When it is attempted
elsewhere, they do a "modified" version,
which is well-known for bad results.
That's why mesh was brought in during the
1990s -- because of all the recurrences
resulting from the "modified" Shouldice
method, which cut corners (bad pun) and
often failed.
If I could get to Toronto, that's where
I'd go. The Shouldice Clinic. No question!
I see very few posts from the UK about
this issue. People here tend to question
doctors and hospitals less than they do in
the USA. There is very, VERY little
awareness about this in the UK --- despite
100,000 hernia ops performed every year
here. Why the silence?
I've contacted a bio research firm and
they confirmed the excellent results of
Permacol. I then contacted the company
that makes it and have asked them for a
list of nearby surgeons who use this
material instead of plastic.
In the meantime I can only hope & pray
my hernias remain asymptomatic long enough
for me to do enough legwork so that I do
not suffer the fate of so many people on
this site -- and many other sites -- who
have had mesh implanted with horrible
results.
Again, I know many people who've had
hernia mesh surgery with no problems at
all. You are, hopefully, one of them! KEEP
LUCKY...and be well.
|
Artie
New User, Becoming EHEALTHy
Joined: 01 Jul 2008 Posts: 31
Thanks: 0
Thanked:1
doing research Posted: 07-03-08 15:44pm
First I would like to state that if your
hernia is asymptomatic then yes, watchful
waiting is a very good idea. It will give
you more time to research and possibly
find the right surgeon for yourself. Not
all hernias need to be repaired with a
mesh implant, although that is how most of
them are fixed now days. But you should
find a surgeon that you are comfortable
with and ask him what are all of your
alternatives, if all he offers is mesh,
ask why. Tell him that you have heard that
there may be complications with these
products and are more interested in a full
tissue repair with out mesh. If he tells
you he can not do it that way, ask him for
a referral to someone who can. It does
sound like you do have time on your hands
to research and find the right way to
repair the hernia when the time comes. It
is so much better when you see the
surgeon, when you have researched and
already know what the options are. He will
be amazed at how well informed you
are.[/quote]
Very true! The surgeon I saw last week was
amazed at how much research I'd done -- he
spoke to me in medical terms. Then again,
after a year of this, I'm a walking hernia
textbook.....UNFORTUNATELY. He actually
said at one point, "hmmmm....you know more
than I do...." However I don't get his
whopping fee (!).
It's very difficult to get a pure tissue
repair here. If it exists, it would be a
"modified" version of the true &
correct Shouldice procedure, meaning it
would be a cut-corners job. Which is why
they stopped doing it that way here &
replaced it with mesh (quick 'n'
easy....or so it seemed). I've been warned
by a doc friend "never" to have mesh.
However that may not be an option. One
reasonable alternative might be the new
"bio" mesh, Permacol. It is proving (so
far) to be much safer than the plastic
horrors.