Abortion Debate Forum - I Doubt Outlawing Abortion Will Do Any Good!
Medical questions     Health forums     Help     log in    

I Doubt Outlawing Abortion Will Do Any Good!

New Topic  Reply  Ask A Doctor - Offline
Medical Questions-> Health Forums -> Abortion Debate -> I Doubt Outlawing Abortion Will Do Any Good!
Medical Questions
Author Message
blackwinded

New User, Becoming EHEALTHy
Joined: 02 Sep 2005
Posts: 45
Location: US of A
I Doubt Outlawing Abortion Will Do Any Good!
Posted: 09-05-05 05:16am

For all those who are pro-life and want to outlaw abortion, I don't understand how you think this will keep people from aborting their fetus??


It will be horrible if and when abortion is outlawed. This will only result in women going out to find someone who will perform an illegal abortion--possibly who doesn't know what they are doing and may wind up killing the woman!,
....Or result in the woman doing a self abortion (starving herself, punching herself in the stomache over and over, etc.) outlawing abortion may possibly result in some women committing suicide, for gosh sakes!

I know that if I ever get pregnant and if abortion has been outlawed by that time, i'm sure I will just result to starving myself. I mean, I don't see abortion as homicide (unless the fetus is over 3 months along), so abortion being illegal isn't going to stop me.


For those of us who honestly don't see killing a fetus to be homicide, it's not going to do any good to outlaw abortion. Sure, if we get caught having an illegal abortion, we'll be put in jail, but what good would that do? And it's very unlikely that anyone would be caught, especially if they self-aborted.



Also, I don't understand how you people can call us "murderers", "baby killers", or whatever other names you have for us. If someone honestly doesn;t agree that abortion is anywhere near the same as killing an actual born baby, then how can we be murderes? Some of us go more by science, then by the bible, ya know!.

Oh, and why do people think that a fetus is more precious and worthy than an animal? Animals are the picture of true innocense, yet I don't think many of you care very much (or at least not nearly as much as you do when a fetus is aborted) that thousands of animals are dying everyday and becomming extinct due to what we humans have done to the world. An animal has the ability to see, hear, smell, feel love, fear, pain, anger, and have a sense of being, where as a very young fetus does not have the ability to feel any of that! Yet somehow, it is not nearly as tragic for an innocent animal to die as it is for a fetus? A fetus which will become a child which will become an adult and will only add to overpopulation of humans and maybe possibly commit crimes and maybe even murders, and be an problem fool like most of the rest of people on this planet! And add to the destruction of this once beautiful place! People sicken me! People are not innocent once they are grown up. Animals are always innocent. I think the entire human race should be whiped out (yes, including me) and the earth and animals should have been left to their beautiful selves, never to cause polution or crimes or any of this comlete discusting crap!



I hate this damn, ugly , poluted, overpopulated, over christianized world! It sucks and blows! There is no way out! "majorite always rules!"
...Ah! I hope I dont kill myself over all this some day! Likely it will kill me first! %#@*!!!#


Last edited by blackwinded on 09-05-05 05:22am; edited 1 time in total
|
blackwinded

New User, Becoming EHEALTHy
Joined: 02 Sep 2005
Posts: 45
Location: US of A

Posted: 09-05-05 05:20am

Why do they replace redrum (read it backwards) with "not a nice act" ? How annoying. How stupid!
|
Izzy

Active User, Really EHEALTHy
Joined: 16 Oct 2004
Posts: 883
Location: Earth

Posted: 09-05-05 05:49am

There is sufficiant evidence to suggest that if abortion were made legal 90% of abortions would cease thats means only 10% would get an ilegal abortion that around 15,000, thats 5,000 more than before roe v wade still its not bad for a population polluted with pro choice lies for 30 years.


90% of ilegal abortions were done by doctors in clinics not in butcher shops or elsewhere, the safty of abortion is not due to the legality of aortion but the medical advances in drugs and in sterilisation, if you check the statistics and plot a graph you will see the safty of abortion since its become legal is not much safer if at all any safer than it was in 1972 before legalisation.

Why should we care if women die when they homicide children, would you care if a rapist died as a result of raping someone?


Gb
|
Izzy

Active User, Really EHEALTHy
Joined: 16 Oct 2004
Posts: 883
Location: Earth

Posted: 09-05-05 05:52am

"if someone honestly doesn;t agree that abortion is anywhere near the same as killing an actual born baby, then how can we be not a nice actes"

well if someone believes 10 year old children are adults and has sex with them, how can they be pedophiles?
|
Izzy

Active User, Really EHEALTHy
Joined: 16 Oct 2004
Posts: 883
Location: Earth

Posted: 09-05-05 06:07am

"some of us go more by science, then by the bible, ya know!."

ah, I see, so you do agree that scientifically - to be precise biologically speaking the unborn child is a unique and individual human being and is fully alive and growing.

Oh and scientifically a 12 year old perhaps younger (i have heard of 9 year olds fathering or getting pregnant) could be classed as a adult, scientifically of course I guess you believe pedophililia is acceptable too.

"oh, and why do people think that a fetus is more precious and worthy than an animal?"

the same reason I think your more precious and worthy of life than an animal


"a very young fetus does not have the ability to feel"

so pedophillia would be ok if the child didnt know what was happening?

"a fetus which will become a child which will become an adult and will only add to overpopulation of humans and maybe possibly commit crimes and maybe even not a nice acts, and be an problem fool like most of the rest of people on this planet! And add to the destruction of this once beautiful place! People sicken me! People are not innocent once they are grown up."

a fetus is a child!

Lets kill everyone who has ever commited a crime, lets kill everyone who has ever killed another human being, lets kill everyone who is an idot, lets destroy the human race forever.... Crazy!

Btw - the world is not over populated at all, infact we are in line for a huge under population crisis in the next 20 - 50 years.

"i hate this damn, ugly , poluted, overpopulated, over christianized world! It sucks and blows!"

to tell you the truth, the world is not christianized, in fact pope b16 has called for the re-christianization of the west, because we are not christian, btw I think the world is wonderful, nature that is, there is too much pollution but you have to realise that the world is not...Is not over populated and certainly not over christianized.
|
blackwinded

New User, Becoming EHEALTHy
Joined: 02 Sep 2005
Posts: 45
Location: US of A

Posted: 09-05-05 06:28am

izzy wrote:
"if someone honestly doesn;t agree that abortion is anywhere near the same as killing an actual born baby, then how can we be not a nice actes"

well if someone believes 10 year old children are adults and has sex with them, how can they be pedophiles?



if someone truly believes that a 10 year old child is an adult, then that would be a delusions and they would (hopefully) be termed "not guilty be reason of insanity" they didn't realize that what they did was wrong. My point exactly! So called "baby killers" simply don't see anything worng with abortion. They (we) don't see it the way you christians do. That's why I don't understand why people who have abortions are termed "muderers"

your "arguement" turned out to be a very good example of what I am reffering to. Nice job
|
blackwinded

New User, Becoming EHEALTHy
Joined: 02 Sep 2005
Posts: 45
Location: US of A

Posted: 09-05-05 06:37am

izzy wrote:
there is sufficiant evidence to suggest that if abortion were made legal 90% of abortions would cease thats means only 10% would get an ilegal abortion that around 15,000, thats 5,000 more than before roe v wade still its not bad for a population polluted with pro choice lies for 30 years.



90% of ilegal abortions were done by doctors in clinics not in butcher shops or elsewhere, the safty of abortion is not due to the legality of aortion but the medical advances in drugs and in sterilisation, if you check the statistics and plot a graph you will see the safty of abortion since its become legal is not much safer if at all any safer than it was in 1972 before legalisation.




Gb


*illegal


i think you are right that not very many people would get illegal abortions if abortion was outlawed. It would be very difficult. But, I think plenty of women would still self-abort.



["why should we care if women die when they homicide children, would you care if a rapist died as a result of raping someone?"]


i guess you just can't even try and understand where other people are comming from. That not everyone is christian. That not everyone believes a fetus is quite the same as a baby. You locked your mind and threw away the key.

And yes, I might care if a rapist died just because they raped someone, but it would depend. Most rapists are either mentally ill or have suffered rape/abuse/molestation themself, resulting in their criminal behavior and I dont necissarily believe a rapist deserves to die if it is because they are mentally or emotionally destroyed.
|
blackwinded

New User, Becoming EHEALTHy
Joined: 02 Sep 2005
Posts: 45
Location: US of A

Posted: 09-05-05 07:11am

["ah, I see, so you do agree that scientifically - to be precise biologically speaking the unborn child is a unique and individual human being and is fully alive and growing. "]

i agree yes, it is fully alive and growing just as is a virus or bacteria or a single sperm, but not anywhere close to a fully developed human being.

Oh and scientifically a 12 year old perhaps younger (i have heard of 9 year olds fathering or getting pregnant) could be classed as a adult, scientifically of course I guess you believe pedophililia is acceptable too.

Oh yeah...That's exactly what I said!




["the same reason I think your more precious and worthy of life than an animal']

first of all, that doesn;'t explain anything. Second: why do you think that my life is more worthy? Oh yeah, because the bible says so, huh?
... Bible shmible


[so pedophillia would be ok if the child didnt know what was happening?]

..So you are agreeing that a fetus does not have the ability to feel? Mentally or physically? Yet you still think abortion is completly outrageous....*ugh* I just dont get it.

And it sure as heck would not be nearly as horrible as if the child did know what was happening. Yet, that child is still a child. Much more developed than a fetus. So I believe it is completly different and your arguement isn't even sufficient in my opinion.






["a fetus is a child!"]


disagreed ! It's a human form, but not nearly close to what we think of as a baby or a child.


[lets kill everyone who has ever commited a crime, lets kill everyone who has ever killed another human being, lets kill everyone who is an idot, lets destroy the human race forever.... Crazy!]

wow! This is pointless to respond to. You took me way out of context. You aren't taking into concideration that I don' see a fetus as being the same thing as a "child" if I was with you on the belief that a fetus is equal to a child, then I would not be supporting abortion rights. Duh





["btw - the world is not over populated at all, infact we are in line for a huge under population crisis in the next 20 - 50 years."]


lol. That's a load of crap. I wonder where in the heck you would get false information like this? Must be george bone-headed bush!



["to tell you the truth, the world is not christianized, in fact pope b16 has called for the re-christianization of the west, because we are not christian, btw I think the world is wonderful, nature that is, there is too much pollution but you have to realise that the world is not...Is not over populated and certainly not over christianized.[/quote]

to tell me the truth? Your a liar! The world is obviously over-populated. And yes, the west is pretty much christianized...About 85% that is. So in order for the world to be concidered christianized to you, that means every single person must be christian? ?? That's not what I meant by it! In my opinion, it just means that the majority of the population is christian and trying to force their beliefs on us and that, for the most part, they are succeeding. (not succeeding in converting us, succeeding in taking away our rights)
but the west is not suppose to be christianized because this is supposedly a free country with freedom of religion. But really it's not, is it? Because of liars like you.
|
blackwinded

New User, Becoming EHEALTHy
Joined: 02 Sep 2005
Posts: 45
Location: US of A

Posted: 09-05-05 07:19am

skar wrote:
skar wrote:
so because someone will break a law we shouldn,t have a law ?




Way to go total anarchy just so termination can stay legal way to blackmail the state/goverment.



blackwind no response is this not what you wanted?



skar, you have to give me more than five minutes to respond to your comments. Be prepared because I might not even respond for a couple days. I'm not on the internet all the time, alright? So try and be patient.


And no, I dont think that just because people will break a law we shouldn't have laws. That;s not at all what I said. I simply said I don't think it will do much good. But no, I don't think their should be a law against abortion because I am pro-choice. It isn't fair but I think abortion is a different issue than most because so many people feel so strongly on it. Your making everything so simple...So black and white...As if every issue is the same as the next.
|
Izzy

Active User, Really EHEALTHy
Joined: 16 Oct 2004
Posts: 883
Location: Earth

Posted: 09-05-05 08:08am

Well who cares what you think?

Only 25% of the population regard abortion as a intrinsic and unchallenged womans right, so, in the end, you dont really count do you, believe what you want, we are still going to make it illegal.
|
Izzy

Active User, Really EHEALTHy
Joined: 16 Oct 2004
Posts: 883
Location: Earth

Posted: 09-05-05 08:32am

"you will never make it illegal... It is a part of our society now. Too bad. No one cares what you think anyways!"

really, that remains to be seen, since a good majority of people voting for bush done so because he is (so called) pro life, its a part of society that most people dislike and it seems more and more people especially the politions do actually care what the christians think. With a good 75% of americans being christians, you gotta see rightly so!

Even in britain where there is only 6 million practising catholics, it seems more and more polititions are listening to the church and have already been working with the church to keep euthinasia illegal.
|
Izzy

Active User, Really EHEALTHy
Joined: 16 Oct 2004
Posts: 883
Location: Earth

Posted: 09-05-05 08:43am

"ya, nothing like taking away a person's right to their religion"

thats not taking away a persons right to their religion.

"keep it up. The backlash will slice your cult open."

like it did in rome?

How many of us will have to die this time - let me be the first!

"no one wants to be forced to live by your hateful bible."

love is not hate, and hate is not love. You personally may find it hateful but the majority believe the bible to be a book about the love of god for his people...So what ya gonna do, kill us - let me be first
|
Izzy

Active User, Really EHEALTHy
Joined: 16 Oct 2004
Posts: 883
Location: Earth

Posted: 09-05-05 08:58am

Or else what?
|
Izzy

Active User, Really EHEALTHy
Joined: 16 Oct 2004
Posts: 883
Location: Earth

Posted: 09-05-05 09:06am

Force you to do what?
|
Izzy

Active User, Really EHEALTHy
Joined: 16 Oct 2004
Posts: 883
Location: Earth

Posted: 09-05-05 09:48am

Tell me a nation that is christian and dosnt want to be, show me a christian who is forced to be a christian
|
bd1012

Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 31 May 2004
Posts: 1998
Re: I Doubt Outlawing Abortion Will Do Any Good!
Posted: 09-05-05 10:12am

blackwinded wrote:
for all those who are pro-life and want to outlaw abortion, I don't understand how you think this will keep people from aborting their fetus??



It will be horrible if and when abortion is outlawed. This will only result in women going out to find someone who will perform an illegal abortion--possibly who doesn't know what they are doing and may wind up killing the woman!,
....Or result in the woman doing a self abortion (starving herself, punching herself in the stomache over and over, etc.) outlawing abortion may possibly result in some women committing suicide, for gosh sakes!


I know that if I ever get pregnant and if abortion has been outlawed by that time, i'm sure I will just result to starving myself. I mean, I don't see abortion as not a nice act (unless the fetus is over 3 months along), so abortion being illegal isn't going to stop me.



For those of us who honestly don't see killing a fetus to be not a nice act, it's not going to do any good to outlaw abortion. Sure, if we get caught having an illegal abortion, we'll be put in jail, but what good would that do? And it's very unlikely that anyone would be caught, especially if they self-aborted.




Also, I don't understand how you people can call us "not a nice persons", "baby killers", or whatever other names you have for us. If someone honestly doesn;t agree that abortion is anywhere near the same as killing an actual born baby, then how can we be not a nice actes? Some of us go more by science, then by the bible, ya know!.

Oh, and why do people think that a fetus is more precious and worthy than an animal? Animals are the picture of true innocense, yet I don't think many of you care very much (or at least not nearly as much as you do when a fetus is aborted) that thousands of animals are dying everyday and becomming extinct due to what we humans have done to the world. An animal has the ability to see, hear, smell, feel love, fear, pain, anger, and have a sense of being, where as a very young fetus does not have the ability to feel any of that! Yet somehow, it is not nearly as tragic for an innocent animal to die as it is for a fetus? A fetus which will become a child which will become an adult and will only add to overpopulation of humans and maybe possibly commit crimes and maybe even not a nice acts, and be an problem fool like most of the rest of people on this planet! And add to the destruction of this once beautiful place! People sicken me! People are not innocent once they are grown up. Animals are always innocent. I think the entire human race should be whiped out (yes, including me) and the earth and animals should have been left to their beautiful selves, never to cause polution or crimes or any of this comlete discusting crap!



I hate this damn, ugly , poluted, overpopulated, over christianized world! It sucks and blows! There is no way out! "majorite always rules!"
...Ah! I hope I dont kill myself over all this some day! Likely it will kill me first! %#@*!!!#

i love you! I am also a member of vhemt btw.
|
Izzy

Active User, Really EHEALTHy
Joined: 16 Oct 2004
Posts: 883
Location: Earth

Posted: 09-05-05 14:23pm

Its mirror

and america is a good 75% christian, so your oviously wrong

and I love being a christian, wouldnt change it for the world, litterally I would not give it up to become the supreme ruler of the world.
|
paganangel

Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 22 Jun 2005
Posts: 377
Location: VA
Re: I Doubt Outlawing Abortion Will Do Any Good!
Posted: 09-05-05 19:19pm

blackwinded wrote:
I mean, I don't see abortion as not a nice act (unless the fetus is over 3 months along),


so why over 3 months? Do you realize that by saying that you are a major hyporcrite? It's okay for them to have an abortion at 3 months but anything of that and they are mur*deres...Hmmm....Doesn't make much sense to me.

I am 100% pro-life!! Abortion should be outlawed except in .E.X.T.R.E.M.E. Cases such as life of the mother/incest/rape..
|
sandyallen

Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 02 Feb 2004
Posts: 4580
Izzy
Posted: 09-05-05 22:19pm

An apple is not an orange, so therefore a fetus is not a child, it is not even a baby, it is a fetus.
There is an over-population, the jails are full, their are not enough jobs to go around, we had to stop our medical assistance program due to lack of funds because their are too many people on it already, no room for children needing to be adopted, people are losing their jobs left and right, more child abuse, neglect, along with adults. You really need a reality check. I seriously doubt that you are old enough to remember when abortion was illegal before and what went on then.
There will always be abortion whether legal or not or even self-abort, would you rather see them born and abused and neglected or aborted, if something is not wanted then that person should have a right to have a proper procedure done and it is none of your business what she decides to do, you are not walking in her shoes, you do not have the right to judge, because maybe their is a rightful reason she is doing this.
|
Izzy

Active User, Really EHEALTHy
Joined: 16 Oct 2004
Posts: 883
Location: Earth

Posted: 09-06-05 02:26am

"an apple is not an orange, so therefore a fetus is not a child, it is not even a baby, it is a fetus."

but an apple and an orange are both fruit so therefore a fetus and a baby are both children.

"there is an over-population,"

your wrong we are heading for an underpopulation crisis with in 20 - 50 yrs, at the moment the population is rising but that is set to setdy out at 9 billion people and then drop sharplly as the aging population dies.

And the rest of your post I couldnt be bothered with.
|
Related Topics
This Forum This Category All Forums
Jump to:  
Goto page 1, 2  Next
New Topic   Reply
Medical Questions -> Health Forums -> Abortion Debate -> I Doubt Outlawing Abortion Will Do Any Good!



Page 1 of 2
We comply with the HONcode standard for trustworthy health
information:
verify here.