Sensitivity is important too....Not always interested in the guy stuff...Smiles are important..Genuine smiles..Honesty...Even if it's brutally honest...
Physically... I dunno... I think some of the things I liked most about my husband was his hands looked like he's knows what it's like to work rather than always getting by the easy way...His eyes have a sweet and gentle look, he's clean cut, shaves, keeps his hair neat, dresses cool, has a nice butt to pinch. :p
to alot of girls I think they aren't always looking for looks, but it's how they handle their lives that attracts a girl. Most ladies are looking for a guy to take care of them and be a partner. Girls like to be independant but there is also the dream of having someone to take care of her. Looks can factor into that though, because if a guy doesn't even take care of himself, how are we supposed to expect him to take care of us.
I don't know if that's at all what you were looking for but I hope I helped some.