Join Our Community!
Share
Avatar
Q: Advice Needed Asap
asked by: nan57 on August 9th, 2005
New User
My spouse and I fight all the time. We are currently seeing a counselor but haven't been for a while since he works crazy hours.

I need some help with a problem and I hope someone has some input.

Last week I told him that my mother's 80th birthday was coming up and my brother and I wanted to take everyone out to dinner (there's 9 of us altogether). He said that was fine. Now today, only one day before we go to dinner he tells me that we can't afford to pay for 1/2. He said he would only pay for himself, me and our 2 kids. His argument is that things are a bit tight at the moment for us and my brother is very comfortable finacially and my husband feels my brother should pay for most of this...If not all of it.

I don't know what to do. It's embarrassing to say we can't afford it. I offered to pay for all of it out of my paycheck (i earn a very small amount and I usually use it for clothes and stuff for myself and the kids) but my husband says that's not the point. He insists that my brother shoud have offered to pay for every one just because he has more money than we do. My question to him is what does this have to do with my brother...Aren't we doing this for my mother??

Do I tell my brother that we need seperate checks? How can I say we won't pay towards my mom's dinner if it's for her birthday?? My husband said he'd stay home. How does this help? Now i'd have to explain his absence.

I feel that we could go the extra few dollars since an 80th birthday comes only once in a lifetime. My mother would feel horrible if my husband didn't show up.

Does anyone have any advice??
Did you find this post useful?
|
Replies(3)
Avatar
sillypoint
replied on August 16th, 2005
New User
Well, as a bloke, I can see where he's coming from. Sure it's for your mother but you can only do as much as you can afford. And if its both you and your brother wanting to take her out its fair u should both pay what you can afford to. In all honesty I think you should mention this to your brother and see if he understands. Tell him things are a bit tight (if they actually are) and he might help out. Your brother certaintly shouldn't pay for everyone, but maybe he could pay the larger proportion. If not, then maybe reconsider the actual 'gift' you are giving her. My mother would be happy if I just arranged such a dinner and paid for her, with every1 else paying for themselves... So there's another option. It's a bit selfish of all the other guests to assume that u and your brother will pay for them, and so I can sympathise with your husbands reluctance, especially if money is an issue.

Although I have to say I think your husband is being immature to say he would stay at home, and ridiculous to suggest your brother should pay for it all. He's in the wrong, he should be more flexible and understanding, but he's based his argument on a reasonable-ish point. It's the kind of thing that would never be an issue if things were going smoothly in the marriage, he's being deliberately awkward, and you're right to feel embarrased about that.
Did you find this post useful?
|
Avatar
nan57
replied on August 16th, 2005
New User
Thanks for the reply. Funny as it seems, the night before we went out to dinner we had a talk. He apologized for his behavior and said he was wrong and he responded that way because of his ill feelings about how my brother did not offer him a job when he was out of work. I explained to him that my brother doesn't know our financial situation and if we don't ask for help, people may not know we need it. I know for a fact that if I asked him for help in any way he would never question, he would just give. Dinner worked out fine and I paid for half of the dinner out of my paycheck. All is happy.

Thanks again.
Did you find this post useful?
|
Avatar
babycat03
replied on September 13th, 2005
New User
Great
I just love happy endings.

Take care and hope your fiancial situation gets better hun.

Lisa
Did you find this post useful?
|
Quick Reply
Search