Eating Disorders Forum - Which Is Worse For You? Anorexia Or Bulimia
Medical questions     Health forums     MarketPlace     log in    

Which Is Worse For You? Anorexia Or Bulimia

New Topic  Reply  Ask A Doctor - Offline
Medical Questions-> Health Forums -> Eating Disorders -> Which Is Worse For You? Anorexia Or Bulimia
Medical Questions
Author Message
bianca

New User, Becoming EHEALTHy
Joined: 29 Jul 2005
Posts: 7
Location: Toronto
Which Is Worse For You? Anorexia Or Bulimia
Posted: 07-31-05 01:02am

I'm wondering that now.. Because although both have their separate complications, I think bulimia is much much worse. Like the fact that you're regurgitating acidic gastro-intestinal secretions into your delicately constructed esophagus and throat is pretty bad. In the long run I think it might even develop into throat cancer. Youre also killing your heart, involuntarily giving it palpitations and whatnot. You rot your teeth like helllllll, to the point that you can no longer drink hot nor cold, only lukewarm things. Dehydration is another thing. So yah... What do you guys think??
|
Nikia

Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 27 Nov 2003
Posts: 74
Location: Wisconsin
I Think That Bulimia Is More Unsafe
Posted: 07-31-05 09:46am

In that more people just suddenly drop dead without warning.
Anorexia is not healthy either, especially long term. I think that most anorexics are identified by others before they have serious damage. I have read though that anorexia has the highest mortality rate of any mental illness though.
Anorexia varies on how severe it is. If you fast completely, you will drop dead within a couple of months. Other anorexics do eat what might look like a "healthy diet" to an outsider, but it is not for them because they continue to lose weight even when they are underweight. Obviously the healthy diet anorexics would do better longer than the complete fasters, especially if they are also taking vitamins.
You do come to a point though where you just don't have reserves of stuff anymore. Your body suffers as you are chronically malnourished vitamin wise. You get cold. You get tired. You get moody. You don't have spare fat, protein, or carbohydrates floating around in your body like the average american. You come to the point where your body can't handle trying to be normal if you continue with what you are doing. If you restrict even more, you face serious health problems. Your organs are protein too, after all. I think that's perhaps why long term anorexics have a higher death rate. It becomes progressively more damaging with each passing month.
|
mshanson

Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 28 Nov 2004
Posts: 102
Location: California
Both Are Bbbbaaaaadddd!
Posted: 07-31-05 20:42pm

Both diseases are deadly ~ 10% of people with these disorders die of them (probably more, but some deaths remain undiscovered because of the shame). Many people switch from one to the other ~ I did, several times. Anorexia is easier to spot so anorexics often get help faster, but they are weaker so they die anyway. Even if you don't die, it's kind of a living death to be so screwed up every day. I spent many years in that hell. Comparing diseases is not really the point ~ the point is to recover from either or both as soon as you can!
|
lonely_angel

Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 11 Aug 2005
Posts: 128
Location: missouri

Posted: 08-11-05 23:48pm

Hey I know that both are really bad it's just that the people who are doin it really don't think about that type of stuff though. Like they know whats happening to their bodies they just well I don't know it's hard to explain I have been bulilmia for about a year now I always know what I am doin to my body but it doesn't really phase me though, and I purge like 1-2 times a day. But living with it really sux I just don;t know how to tell my parents though thats the hardest thing for me to do and I am scared about how the treatment will go also....
~de~
|
unsure_foracertainty

New User, Becoming EHEALTHy
Joined: 18 Aug 2005
Posts: 4
Who Can Really Say...
Posted: 08-18-05 03:22am

How can you really say which is worse? I don't know if there is really any way to say which is better unless its factually supported by some medical studies... Anyhow, its like the moon and the sun - both in the sky (so similar) yet appearing at completely different times of the day/night (so opposite).

Neither are fun... I see how my cousin has suffered from both and now mainly ana - it's horrible. I've had my difficulties with mia exaserbated by oe and that's been horrible. Still I struggle with what I choose to term disordered eating habits or whatever; regardless, according to my psychologist the chances of seizuring while over the toilet are pretty high.

So, I guess it depends on the eventuality of the pistol you choose and how you want to die, if you continue. Over a toilet or in a bed or wherever else. The whole toilet scenario kind of helped me during a period of b/p. Anyhow...
|
AloneInTheWorld

New User, Becoming EHEALTHy
Joined: 25 Aug 2005
Posts: 4
Location: Texas

Posted: 08-25-05 22:41pm

They aren't really opposite tho...The sun shines bright the moon is dark...Bulimia makes u lose tons of weight as does anorexia. Both are unbelievably dangerous and should not be practiced by anyone. There is no justification as to which is better. None are ovbiously better, you have all these girls on this website telling their stories about how they hate thereselves because they are anorexic or bulimic. Both are unhealthy ways to lose weight and you cant choose whcih one is better because they both ultimately result in death. I think we should all choose which candybar is best and all of us should eat it with no shame....Easier said than done im affraid. So you see, neither are better...Im personally bulimic and im going on a year...Its tough and a literally disgusting habit but im working on it...Or trying to...But I dont look at it like...Damn..I should of been anorexic, I ultimately wish there was an option where I could be happy with myself and anorexia may be cleaner! But in no way is it healthier...No way!




Much love,
mandy
|
Related Topics
This Forum This Category All Forums
Jump to:  
New Topic   Reply
Medical Questions -> Health Forums -> Eating Disorders -> Which Is Worse For You? Anorexia Or Bulimia



We comply with the HONcode standard for trustworthy health
information:
verify here.