Abortion Debate Forum - Memories of Dachau page 2
medical questions | health forums

Memories of Dachau

New Topic  Reply  Ask A Doctor - Offline
Medical Questions-> Health Forums -> Abortion Debate -> Memories of Dachau
Author Message
FISHX

Active User, Really EHEALTHy
Joined: 27 Dec 2004
Posts: 920
Location: UK

Posted: 03-27-05 16:00pm

Hey scumbag you no nothing about me do not ever insinuate that I am a racist again.
I thought that people on here wern't allowed to be offensive?
Did you find this post useful?
|
FISHX

Active User, Really EHEALTHy
Joined: 27 Dec 2004
Posts: 920
Location: UK

Posted: 03-27-05 16:07pm

Steen can you never just be civil no one was attacking you until you attacked?
Did you find this post useful?
|
foreverblue

Active User, Really EHEALTHy
Joined: 17 Jan 2005
Posts: 577

Posted: 03-27-05 16:09pm

Steen where was izzy lying are you saying that history is wrong?Before the second world war the worlds economy had collapsed and jewish people were in charge of the banks at the time{though I in no way blame them for it so dont even attempt to call me racist or anti sematic}all I am stating are historical facts,the germans where starving has was most of europe,whatever hitlers reasons for the extermination,it was the act of a madman,all izzy has done is put his own interprtation on hitlers reasons,that in no way makes him anti sematic he is not hitler nor did he take part in the extermination of jews.
Did you find this post useful?
|
Izzy

Active User, Really EHEALTHy
Joined: 16 Oct 2004
Posts: 883
Location: Earth

Posted: 03-27-05 16:51pm

Neither do I condone such a vile act of homicide, unlike some
Did you find this post useful?
|
2ferano

Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 23 Dec 2003
Posts: 3717

Posted: 03-27-05 17:53pm

Steen commented on izzy's remark that stated why the german's loved him. And steen corrected that comment. I believe that is what the "lie" was, but I don't know.
Actually, I have never met a racist prochoice person. It is usually quite the contrary. Prochoice people are generally more understanding and open-minded and less likely to be small-minded enough to be a racist. In fact, even on this site the only racist remarks are made by a prolife person. Although, that really doesn't count as there aren't many people on this forum to begin with.
Regardless of why hitler was intimidated by the jews and chose to try to get rid of them, abortion is not like the holocaust.
Jlee I truly hope you are never raped by a monster or have a pregnancy that will kill both you and the baby and be forced to make a decision that you never wanted to have to make. But, even if you chose for you and the baby to die or to have the baby of your attacker, how can you honestly expect every other woman to do that? Have they not already been through enough? Selfish or not, it is her body, her life and her decision. I find others trying to control what she does although it has no affect on them whatsoever more selfish than her making a decision that affects her and her life. Just because someone chooses to have an abortion doesn't mean they are a hateful, awful or selfish person. They were just put into a situation that most people have never been in. And the people who were in it and chose to have the baby anyway, well they were either stronger or just held different beliefs. But, either way I can't believe that you would honestly judge them. All people are different, need different things and are capable or incapable of different things, and they make their decisions based on that. Not all decisions can be made based on what you believe or what you think is "right."
i like how you ignore everything that any prochoice person here states and say that all we ever say is that it is about, "the womans right to choose what affects her body..." if you would read, you would see that isn't all that "we" say and it is quite foolish to say that.
Did you find this post useful?
|
steen

Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 18 Nov 2004
Posts: 1797
Location: Upper Midwest
Re: Surprise, Surprise....
Posted: 03-27-05 21:59pm

foreverblue wrote:
you really are sad steen,you are trying to say that hitler was pro life,
no, I am not I am saying that izzy's post was downright anti-semitic, and that you and your prolife friends cheered him on, while ridiculing my post pointing out the anti-semitic items in izzy's post.

Not my fault that you cheered an anti-semitic post. Perhaps you should then have read more carefully?
Quote:
no I think you will find he was pro choice,
actually, hitler was neither. He insisted on abortions for jews, gypsies etc., and denied them for "aryans."

and that is irrelevant. My response to izzy has nothing to do with abortion. It was solely per its anti-semitic content. That you then speak out to disagree with me and cheer izzy on, exactly what do you think that makes you look like?
Quote:
izzy though maybe not quite getting his point across was not saying,nor did i,fishx or jlee,that he hated jews.
but blamed the jews for the stock market crash, claimed that they run the worlds banking system and thus were responsible for germany's economic woes and thus hitler had a reason for the holocaust. Did you miss that part of izzy's post? Are you saying that izzy merely was unclear in his posting? It was very anti-semitic. And then all of you immediately cheering him on and attacking those who objected to the anti-semitic tone, that speaks for itself.
Quote:
once again you choose to try and cause discord and arguments steen,truley pathetic.
no, I am challenging your lending credence to a flagrantly anti-semitic post by izzy merely because he is a prolifer.

You should immediately have distanced yourself from izzy's post. Did you actually read it? I would advice you going back and doing so before replying again.
Quote:
it was this power over the world the jews had that hitler resented so much
ah, and what "power" was that? Oh please tell me how the jews controlled the world, why don't you? Are you going to lend credence to izzy's anti-semitism now?
Quote:
how can you twist what is clearly written
i was not twisting anything. Izzy wrote a piece of hatemongering that attacked the jews, essentially a justification for hitler's holocaust. I am baffled that you could have missed that.
Quote:
then try and call other people,
you supported izzy's post, didn't you? And you harped on sandy and I for calling izzy on his anti-semitic remarks. How does that not make you supporting anti-semitism? Perhaps you would like to rephrase your support in a bit of a different form? I frankly doubt that you are all anti-semitic, but the way you all posted, you were in clear support of anti-semitism.
Quote:
as izzy put that it was this power that he or pro life hated
that "power" is a anti-semitic deception. And no, prolife/prochoice has nothing to do with this.
Quote:
no he put it was what hitler hated,but has hitler was pro choice
no, he wasn't. Hitler was the fascist leader of an incredibly authoritarian state. There was no "choice" about anything, that claim is flat-out false. Again, this has nothing to do with abortion or prolife/prochoice. It has only to do with you guys cheering on izzy's anti-semitism.
Quote:
i think using your own twisted form of logic that this must mean pro choice is anti semetic,
you can stop your lies and deception. This has nothing to do with pl/pc.
Quote:
but we already know most pro choicers are racists any way,ie the founder of that great abortion provider/informer planned parenthood.
ah, yes. As usual, pl lie as much as they possibly can stuff into a post. "most pro choicers"? Yes, I should have known you incapable of being honest. So aside from being an outright liar, are you also anti-semitic? Yes or no?
Did you find this post useful?
|
steen

Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 18 Nov 2004
Posts: 1797
Location: Upper Midwest

Posted: 03-27-05 22:03pm

fishx wrote:
hey scumbag you no nothing about me do not ever insinuate that I am a racist again.
i am accusing you of supporting a completely anti-semitic post. Did you miss that? Are you agreeing with izzy's anti-semitic post or not? If not, then why cheering izzy on and attacking those who were calling him on it? We have very good reason to call you guys on it. Do you suppoort the anti-semitic claims in izzy's post? Yes or no?

Quote:
i thought that people on here wern't allowed to be offensive?
anti-semitism is very offensive. Yet you cheered it on. Care to revise your support and accusations?

This is a test of your integrity, fishx. Are prolifers always right even if they preach anti-semitism? Are prochoice always wrong, even if they challenge anti-semitism?
Did you find this post useful?
|
steen

Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 18 Nov 2004
Posts: 1797
Location: Upper Midwest

Posted: 03-27-05 22:08pm

foreverblue wrote:
steen where was izzy lying are you saying that history is wrong?
i am saying that izzy's portaryal of history is false.
Quote:
before the second world war the worlds economy had collapsed and jewish people were in charge of the banks at the time
nope. Some of the banks had jewish ceos and similar. That doesn't mean that the wordl's banking system was under jewish control.
Quote:
{though I in no way blame them for it so dont even attempt to call me racist or anti sematic}
i am challenging you on your support for izzy's anti-semitic claims. If you support his claim, you support anti-semitism. It is that simple.
Quote:
all I am stating are historical facts,
really? Prove it!!!!!!!
Quote:
the germans where starving has was most of europe,whatever hitlers reasons for the extermination,it was the act of a madman,
agreed.
Quote:
all izzy has done is put his own interprtation on hitlers reasons,
yes, a decidely anti-semitic revisionist historic spin. I don't know what the @^%$%@$ you learn in the schools in the the us or uk, but if your history endorses izzy's claims, then I would take a serious look at the politics behind your revisionist history book.
Quote:
that in no way makes him anti sematic he is not hitler nor did he take part in the extermination of jews.
but he advocated decidedly anti-semitic falsehoods. Do you support him doing so? Are you saying that izzy's post was accurate and justified? Please say yes, and I will document how you are anti-semitic, just give me the chance.
Did you find this post useful?
|
steen

Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 18 Nov 2004
Posts: 1797
Location: Upper Midwest

Posted: 03-27-05 22:22pm

izzy wrote:
neither do I condone such a vile act of not a nice act, unlike some
you don't condone anti-semitism? Then why did you write in support of it?
Did you find this post useful?
|
steen

Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 18 Nov 2004
Posts: 1797
Location: Upper Midwest
Re: Surprise, Anti-semitic Pls
Posted: 03-27-05 22:24pm

jlee77 wrote:
steen wrote:
jlee77 wrote:
i see steen and ms. Sandyallen have contributed their usual jarble to this post. Boy...What a contribution.
so you agree with izzy's anti-semitism. Yes, I am not surprised. Fundies sometimes hate jews and cheer on hitler and his holocaust like izzy just did.

now that's just silly steen, to "note" that I agree with hitler or in any way admire him. Sheesh.
ah, but yu did agree with izzy in support of his anti-semitic post.
Did you find this post useful?
|
steen

Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 18 Nov 2004
Posts: 1797
Location: Upper Midwest
Re: Surprise, Anti-semitic Pls
Posted: 03-27-05 22:33pm

jlee77 wrote:
steen wrote:
jlee77 wrote:
steen wrote:
jlee77 wrote:
i see steen and ms. Sandyallen have contributed their usual jarble to this post. Boy...What a contribution.
so you agree with izzy's anti-semitism. Yes, I am not surprised. Fundies sometimes hate jews and cheer on hitler and his holocaust like izzy just did.

now that's just silly steen, to "note" that I agree with hitler or in any way admire him. Sheesh.
ah, but you did agree with izzy in support of his anti-semitic post.

really? Please find where I said " I agree with the anti-semitic post". Thanks.
you criticized sandy and me for our objection to izzy's anti-semitic post. Thus you support what izzy wrote. You support anti-semitism. It is that simple. Care to revise your support for izzy's anti-semitism now that your attention has been directed at it? I am giving all of you that chance under the tentative assumption that you just didn't pay attention to what you supported.
Did you find this post useful?
|
2ferano

Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 23 Dec 2003
Posts: 3717

Posted: 03-27-05 23:14pm

Yes, you have every right to debate. But to say in general, as you did, that it isn't about the woman's right to chose is excluding rape, etc. So if you feel differently in those circimstances then instead of just stating that abortion is wrong and that a woman doesn't have the right to chose, maybe you should be more specific. You were implying that all prochoice people feel the exact same way and that all we ever say is that it is the woman's right to choose and you know as well as everyone else that isn't true.
Did you find this post useful?
|
steen

Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 18 Nov 2004
Posts: 1797
Location: Upper Midwest

Posted: 03-28-05 00:59am

jlee77 wrote:
what I said was:

" see steen and ms. Sandyallen have contributed their usual jarble to this post. Boy...What a contribution. :roll:"

....Because you were commenting on izzy and sandy was cheering you on. It was a simple observation of the petty little insults and reference to your jumping to conclusions as always, that's all.
so you didn't like me criticizing izzy's anti-semitism, and you didn't like sandy supporting this challenge of anti-semitism. And that certainly makes you a supporter of izzy's anti-semitism.

Yes, I noticed that you did not disawow it yet. That is very telling.

Tell me, jlee, just so I know how extreme you are, are you also one of those who claim that the holocaust never happened, or is your anti-semitism confined to claims and complaints about the jewish bankers that ran the world and ruined christian nations?
Did you find this post useful?
|
foreverblue

Active User, Really EHEALTHy
Joined: 17 Jan 2005
Posts: 577

Posted: 03-28-05 04:42am

steen wrote:
[
Quote:
that in no way makes him anti sematic he is not hitler nor did he take part in the extermination of jews.
but he advocated decidedly anti-semitic falsehoods. Do you support him doing so? Are you saying that izzy's post was accurate and justified? Please say yes, and I will document how you are anti-semitic, just give me the chance.



thank you steen you have just proved my post.You state if I agree with izzy you can prove me wrong,so therefore you must have the evidence to do so,yes.Therefore your first post to izzy was meant to cause drama and discord,because if you can prove me wrong then you should be able to prove izzy wrong,so why did you not post your facts and evidence,instead you choose to argue and cause problems.



I am not anti jewish and for you to assume,because I pulled you on your post,that I am really makes me laugh.You remind me of the british goverment if you complain about the immigration problems in this country then they label you a racist,if you complain about the war then you are a traitor.So you see steen I am used to people like you attacking when shown to be in the wrong.Now if and this i9s a big if you have the evidence then show it and prove history wrong,as if you could.
Did you find this post useful?
|
FISHX

Active User, Really EHEALTHy
Joined: 27 Dec 2004
Posts: 920
Location: UK
Re: Surprise, Surprise....
Posted: 03-28-05 05:31am

fishx wrote:
jlee77 wrote:
i see steen and ms. Sandyallen have contributed their usual jarble to this post. Boy...What a contribution. :roll:

very well written kjn...But please don't expect people like steen and the obvious are going to accept the truth. It's simply too painful and true to them. They turn their heads and try and believe their "truth", it's easier for them that way. They feel the baby in the womb does not have as many rights as the jews did because of the number we call age. Typical of such arrogance. Get used to it if you plan on frequenting this site. Just a forewarning.

And jenn (brianbaby), your very right. Blah blah about "woman's right to choose what to do with her body". That's all it is ever about with pro-choice. The issue is the killing of a human life due to various different reasons and what makes it wrong is when it's for selfish immature reasons, such as "not being ready". Cry me a river. Get over it and adjust your life to your blood. It's the decent right thing to do. God created us...Not to be destroyed.









bravo I bow to the mighty jlee :wink:

sincerly fishx.





this is what I responded to steen I can find nothing anti semetic in this post so show me please.

I didn't even aknowledge nor respond to izzy's post.
Did you find this post useful?
|
FISHX

Active User, Really EHEALTHy
Joined: 27 Dec 2004
Posts: 920
Location: UK
Re: Surprise, Surprise....
Posted: 03-28-05 10:54am

jlee77 wrote:
fishx wrote:
fishx wrote:
jlee77 wrote:
i see steen and ms. Sandyallen have contributed their usual jarble to this post. Boy...What a contribution. :roll:

very well written kjn...But please don't expect people like steen and the obvious are going to accept the truth. It's simply too painful and true to them. They turn their heads and try and believe their "truth", it's easier for them that way. They feel the baby in the womb does not have as many rights as the jews did because of the number we call age. Typical of such arrogance. Get used to it if you plan on frequenting this site. Just a forewarning.

And jenn (brianbaby), your very right. Blah blah about "woman's right to choose what to do with her body". That's all it is ever about with pro-choice. The issue is the killing of a human life due to various different reasons and what makes it wrong is when it's for selfish immature reasons, such as "not being ready". Cry me a river. Get over it and adjust your life to your blood. It's the decent right thing to do. God created us...Not to be destroyed.









bravo I bow to the mighty jlee :wink:

sincerly fishx.





this is what I responded to steen I can find nothing anti semetic in this post so show me please.



I didn't even aknowledge nor respond to izzy's post.


fishx...Huh? That wasn't directed at you hun. ?? ;o)




i know that your post wasn't directed at me mine was directed at steen trying to insinuate that I am racist just pointing out that I posted nothing to state that I am racist.

You know I have taken some insults on this site but this is the most offencive insult I have ever had.
Did you find this post useful?
|
steen

Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 18 Nov 2004
Posts: 1797
Location: Upper Midwest
Re: Surprise, Surprise....
Posted: 03-28-05 11:49am

fishx wrote:
fishx wrote:
bravo I bow to the mighty jlee :wink:

sincerly fishx.

this is what I responded to steen I can find nothing anti semetic in this post so show me please.


I didn't even aknowledge nor respond to izzy's post.
you supported jlee in her cheering on izzy's anti-semitism
Did you find this post useful?
|
steen

Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 18 Nov 2004
Posts: 1797
Location: Upper Midwest

Posted: 03-28-05 12:00pm

jlee77 wrote:
steen wrote:
so you didn't like me criticizing izzy's anti-semitism, and you didn't like sandy supporting this challenge of anti-semitism. And that certainly makes you a supporter of izzy's anti-semitism.
Yes, I noticed that you did not disawow it yet. That is very telling.

Tell me, jlee, just so I know how extreme you are, are you also one of those who claim that the holocaust never happened, or is your anti-semitism confined to claims and complaints about the jewish bankers that ran the world and ruined christian nations?

again....No. I was commenting on your and sandyallen's tendency to ramble?
oh? Back-pedalling?

Quote:
no, I never said the holocaust didn't happen, now that would be ridiculous wouldn't it?
that's nice. Now., what about izzy's post in general? Do you support the anti-semitism in his post?
Did you find this post useful?
|
steen

Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 18 Nov 2004
Posts: 1797
Location: Upper Midwest
Re: Surprise, Surprise....
Posted: 03-28-05 12:02pm

fishx wrote:
you know I have taken some insults on this site but this is the most offencive insult I have ever had.
and supporting izzy's anti-semitism, even through jlee's post is highly offensive as well.

Why are you so reluctant to now disawow izzy's anti-semitism? You have had ample oportunity by now?

So just tell us straightforwardly. Do you agree with the portrayal of jews as it is done in izzy's post? Yes or no?
Did you find this post useful?
|
steen

Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 18 Nov 2004
Posts: 1797
Location: Upper Midwest

Posted: 03-28-05 12:47pm

jlee77 wrote:
there...Do ya get it now?
yes, I get it that you will do any kind of squirming to not have to admit that you supported izzy's anti-semitism.

It is obvious by now that you will not disawow that anti-semitism. So my point regarding you still syands.
Did you find this post useful?
|
Related Topics
This Forum This Category All Forums
Jump to:  
Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4  Next
New Topic   Reply



Page 2 of 4
We comply with the HONcode standard for trustworthy health
information:
verify here.