Thanks for the advice, ladies!
Yeah, I actually had a root canal on this tooth and was going in to get a crown put on, but it got really weak after the root canal and broke in half, so the dentist just had to pull it.

He just used novacaine; I checked with my OBGYN before my appt. to make sure that was okay!
I've taken 3 Tylenol in the past 24 hours, so I'm hoping that'll do the trick. My mouth definitely isn't as sore today as it was yesterday, so that's good anyway. Thanks again for the help, girls!!