Breathing difficulties :can Montelukast (singulair) stop working Posted: 11-17-07 06:41am
Hello, first time poster here who spent
all day yesterday reading all the posts to
try and find help.
Lots and lots of similar posts but I'm
compelled to write my own in the hope that
someone, somewhere will be able to help.
My daugter (now 6), had no medical
problems until she had an attack of croup
in January following her 3rd birthday.
Over the next 2 months she had a further 2
attacks. All 3 attacks were approx 6
weeks apart. The last one was in the
March.
During May of that year she started having
difficulty breathing. Even walking out to
the car left her breathless and exertion
on any level was torture. This continued
until September and suddenly ceased. No
medication or tests were offered/given by
the GP.
Everything was fine until the following
May when it all started up again and the
GP prescribed a reliever inhaler which had
no effect. Between May and September she
was given preventer inhalers in various
strengths, medications and dosages but
none of them worked. The GP did say
though that there was signs of allergy in
her nose and eyes so also put her on
Cetirizine tablets - one a day. There was
no improvement.
From September to the following May (which
is May this year) ....not a problem.
This May it all started up again and we
were at our wits end because nothing
seemed to be working. At this point no
allergy tests had been done so I requested
a referral to see a specialist. While we
were waiting for the appointment she was
given Montelukast (Singulair in the US)
around June time and overnight the
difference was remarkable! They were like
the wonder pill!
We were so relieved. I should point out
here that there still hasn't been an
allergy test.
They worked perfect until about 3 weeks
ago (end of October so they worked for
about 5 months) and they suddenly stopped
working. We are devestated because 1)
they've stopped working and 2) my daughter
is back to her breathless state and it's
gone past September.
I've always maintianed that I didn't think
it was asthma because other than the
breathlessness (which is daily and all
day) she doesn't seem to have any of the
other usual sypmtoms. She doesn't wheeze,
she doesn't cough, she's fine at night and
none of the asthma medications she's been
on have made a difference.
This week the asthma nurse has said that
finally there's agreement and it's not
asthma but she is convinced it's
hyperventilating. I'm at my wits end!
There still haven't been any allergy tests
(and even to my untrained eye the inside
of her nose is really inflamed and red and
puffy) but instead of looking for the
allergens, she's trying to teach new
breathing techniques as a means to control
it (mainly nose breathing which is causing
distress and having little effect because
of the swelling).
Her next solution is to have my daughter
in for a few days to run exercise tests
and observe overnights because she thinks
it may be cardiac.
I think I'm slowly going mad. Cardiac?
There's no chest pain, no hypertension, no
family history, no previous myocardial
infaction and no abnormal ECG. Why would
that be appropriate before an allergy
test.?
A 3 day stay in hospital for these tests
or an allergy test.
When I try to point this out I'm getting
her annoyed and she twists it back to me
and why wouldn't I want to go for the full
battery of tests.
I think it's overkill and unnessasary but
she's making me feel like a bad mum.
Allergy has been mentioned since day 1 and
I feel that if we knew what they were, we
could take any steps needed to put
triggers at a minimum to try and help.
This is really long and rambling, I know.
It's because I'm distraught with worry and
no-one is listening to me. I'm also under
pressure because on her bad days my
daughter is missing school because she's
breathless by the time she gets there and
there's nothing that will put the air back
in her, other than not moving. At school
that's not possible. Everyone seems to
spend more time fretting about the school
absence than finding out how to stop the
cause of the absence and I feel like I'm
dammed if I do and dammed if I don't.
Does anyone know if the Montelukast
(singulair) could just stop working?
Does anyone have anything similar to these
symptoms?
Just a recap.
Breathless May to September (until this
year)
Only med to work was Montelukast, which
has stopped working after 5 months.
Nothing we know of has changed in
activity, location, environment.
I'm asking for guidance because the advice
I'm being given goes against what my gut
feeling is telling me and when I try to
ask for things to be done in a logical
path, I'm being met with hostility.
I should point out that I'm in the UK and
the service is provided by the NHS which
has notoriously long waiting times and who
probably operate in a different manner to
the healthcare sevices in other
countries.
But all I want is to find out a) what's
causing my 6 year old daughters breathing
problmes and b) what to do to try and
remedy them.
I'm sorry this is so long. But PLEASE if
you have ANY advice or links or
suggestions for anything that I've
written, no matter how small, please
post.
Thank you.
On a side note, we have been given an
appointment to go in (for what I assume
will be the long awaited allergy tests)
but I'd like to ask - what is the
proceedure for afterwards? If the tests
come back with allergies, what would
normally happen? Would there be a
histamine blocker precribed and time given
to see if it works? I ask because I'm not
familiar with allergy and I feel like I'm
just 1 little cog in the big healthcare
machine and all the other, professional
cogs are dismissing my input. I'd like to
know what I'm talking about when I go for
the appointment.
|
MandMs
Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 26 Jan 2007 Posts: 2268 Location: Strumica, Macedonia
Thanks: 46
Thanked:11
Posted: 11-19-07 04:52am
SINGULAIR is approved to help control
asthma in adults and children and for
relief of symptoms of indoor and outdoor
allergies, but has not been studied as a
treatment option for both conditions in
the same person.
Is your daughter taking fast-acting
inhalation medication for her breathing
difficulties, too?
Does she experience stuffy, runny nose and
sneezing?
Are these attacks of breathing
difficulties always starting in May?
Have you noticed that breathing problems
were preceded with stress or other
emotional triggers?
|
wickedwanda
Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 18 Mar 2006 Posts: 109 Location: Alberta.
Thanks: 0
Thanked:1
Google Vocal Vord Dysfuction Posted: 01-06-08 01:43am
it mimics asthma and, can be triggared by
allergies, basicall y the voice box is not
working and you tend to whezze loud or not
at all.. give it a try god bless ww