Join Our Community!
Share
Debate Forums > General Debate Forum > What If? (Page 3)
User Profile
Marianne0558
on November 6th, 2007
Supporter
Again... not all people who are God-fearing are very caring individuals.
I must bring up the topic of the Catholic priests molesting the little boys..
Are they very caring? I would say not.
Sicko pervs.
Did you find this post useful?
|
Avatar
LainieNY
replied on November 6th, 2007
New User
I find most people can't seperate religion & God. To believe in God, they feel it is a religion. Most religions are based from the Books of the Bible. Religion and the Bible are two seperate enitites.

The old saying, how can you believe the Bible, man wrote it. With that concept, I say, how can you believe history? Did not man write your history books? To deny one, then one must deny all man written materials.

The different religions of the world, have omitted or inserted their own Books from the Bible. My opinion for those actions, is to control their people. It is up to us, to research all materials before forming a intelligent opinion.

The debate about creation & the evolution theory, I find a useless debate. There are missing links in the evolution theory. People don't want to believe in the Bible because there is missing information, in the next breath, they say they believe in evolution theory, though there is missing links in the line of human evolution.

Science is working on another theory, The String Theory. If they prove that theory, it will change the way we see things about creation & evolution. For more info on the string theory, PBS did a show on the String theory, here is the link to the transcript. http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/transcripts/3 012_elegant.html
Did you find this post useful?
|
Avatar
redeme
replied on November 6th, 2007
Experienced User
"The old saying, how can you believe the Bible, man wrote it. With that concept, I say, how can you believe history? Did not man write your history books? To deny one, then one must deny all man written materials."

-not true at all history books are written on evidence that we find and put together from the past. the bible is a man made claim of the existence of god, jesus ect ect based on no evidence or proof what-so-ever
Did you find this post useful?
|
Avatar
LainieNY
replied on November 6th, 2007
New User
Marianne0558 wrote:
Again... not all people who are God-fearing are very caring individuals.
I must bring up the topic of the Catholic priests molesting the little boys..
Are they very caring? I would say not.
Sicko pervs.


Your right, they aren't that caring, they are homosexual pedophiles, who has joined an org. to satisfy their own desires. So let's destroy the Church because of people's actions?

How about Oprah's school in Africa. Girls were molested, should we shut down that school?

I believe we are resonsible for our actions. We and not any particular org should be condemn. If I didn't believe that, then I would have to believe all Muslims are terrorist & murders, so we should do away with them.

You are right, not all people are God fearing, some have their own agenda for joining a org.
Did you find this post useful?
|
Avatar
Tylanas
replied on November 6th, 2007
Especially eHealthy
Gu£st wrote:
what you feel, how can you feel something is right or wrong, if there is no God?


How can animals feel it is a not-smart idea to kill their own kind? Almost NO animal in the world murders its own kind. It is programmed in them via evolution and natural selection that killing one's own species is bad, and is not going to help the species survive in the long-run. It's just logical that murder makes no sense. Tacking on the moral value of "bad" is a purely human development.

On that note, chimpanzies DO murder each other in the same way humans murder each other during war. Invading troops of chimps are accosted by the home troop, and beaten off. Often, one or more will die. The home troop will then often cannibalize the enemy's corpses. This is very human like behavior, lending itself towards proving evolutionary theory even more.

Quote:
society, who cares about society


Humans do. We are social animals, just like dolphins, chimps, wolves, etc. We NEED each other to survive. We need social interaction to stimulate our brains and keep them healthy. Many other animals suffer psychologicaly in isolation just as humans do. It is literally part of our blood and genes to form communnitties.

Quote:
- just a bunch of busy bodies trying to tell you how to live

Not at all. You clearly do not understand the anthropological meaning of a society.
Did you find this post useful?
|
Avatar
LainieNY
replied on November 6th, 2007
New User
redeme wrote:
"The old saying, how can you believe the Bible, man wrote it. With that concept, I say, how can you believe history? Did not man write your history books? To deny one, then one must deny all man written materials."

-not true at all history books are written on evidence that we find and put together from the past. the bible is a man made claim of the existence of god, jesus ect ect based on no evidence or proof what-so-ever


The British Museums has authentic letters written by Pontius Pilot to Herod on Jesus's healings, raising the dead & the feeding of the masses, plus the actual events that happened at the time of his death and after his death.

Archeologist and anthropologist have found so much of what was written about cities & people to be true.
Did you find this post useful?
|
Avatar
Tylanas
replied on November 6th, 2007
Especially eHealthy
LainieNY wrote:


Science is working on another theory, The String Theory. If they prove that theory, it will change the way we see things about creation & evolution. For more info on the string theory, PBS did a show on the String theory, here is the link to the transcript. http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/transcripts/3 012_elegant.html


String theory is very cool; I've been watching the development of it for years Very Happy
Did you find this post useful?
|
User Profile
Birch
replied on November 6th, 2007
Extremely eHealthy
Gu£st wrote:
"You need belief in God to have care for other people? You are devoid of care for others without God??? "

Yes I need God to have care for others.....

I would be devoid of care for others without God, but so would every human being alive.... Catholics believe in one God, from whom all good things come.

If God did not exist then nothing would be Good or Bad, Rape would be equal to buying a starving man his lunch.

"he just admitted too that i dont understand it... i am special then cause i dont believe in god but i dont do thiese thinks i am highly moral but i dont need a god to scare me in to doing what right that is just plain stupid"

Not at all, you are not moral at all, no one is that is the twist, "no one is righteous, no not one" you are not moral, your just brainwashed by society into acting a certain way because soicety deems it is "moral" to act in that way, you dont even know yourself or the extent of the capability of every human being to do evil, I do.

"dont other people do that anyway?"

Its getting more and more common as religion becomes less and less.


Does not your heart tells you how to treat others? Would you not know that causing injury to someone was wrong without a faith in a deity? Do you have so little value for yourself and your own potential impact on others to think this way?

No wonder you think so little of others. You have no care for yourself. Shocked

If it was proven that there was no god, I'm sure a mass panic and a mass exodus out of this life would ensue by individuals like you, who do not appreciate the beauty in everyday life like you should.
Did you find this post useful?
|
Avatar
redeme
replied on November 6th, 2007
Experienced User
LainieNY wrote:
redeme wrote:
"The old saying, how can you believe the Bible, man wrote it. With that concept, I say, how can you believe history? Did not man write your history books? To deny one, then one must deny all man written materials."

-not true at all history books are written on evidence that we find and put together from the past. the bible is a man made claim of the existence of god, jesus ect ect based on no evidence or proof what-so-ever


The British Museums has authentic letters written by Pontius Pilot to Herod on Jesus's healings, raising the dead & the feeding of the masses, plus the actual events that happened at the time of his death and after his death.

Archeologist and anthropologist have found so much of what was written about cities & people to be true.



is this what your talking about?

http://www.orthodox.cn/patristics/apostoli cfathers/herpilat.htm
Did you find this post useful?
|
User Profile
sillysallie1990
replied on November 6th, 2007
Experienced User
Eiri wrote:
Gu£st wrote:
what you feel, how can you feel something is right or wrong, if there is no God?


How can animals feel it is a not-smart idea to kill their own kind? Almost NO animal in the world murders its own kind. It is programmed in them via evolution and natural selection that killing one's own species is bad, and is not going to help the species survive in the long-run. It's just logical that murder makes no sense. Tacking on the moral value of "bad" is a purely human development.

On that note, chimpanzies DO murder each other in the same way humans murder each other during war. Invading troops of chimps are accosted by the home troop, and beaten off. Often, one or more will die. The home troop will then often cannibalize the enemy's corpses. This is very human like behavior, lending itself towards proving evolutionary theory even more.

Quote:
society, who cares about society


Humans do. We are social animals, just like dolphins, chimps, wolves, etc. We NEED each other to survive. We need social interaction to stimulate our brains and keep them healthy. Many other animals suffer psychologicaly in isolation just as humans do. It is literally part of our blood and genes to form communnitties.

Quote:
- just a bunch of busy bodies trying to tell you how to live

Not at all. You clearly do not understand the anthropological meaning of a society.



he needs to take psycology classes cause he dont get it at all!!! i was trying to explain to him but i couldnt find the words lol. bravo eiri you did what i couldnt...
Did you find this post useful?
|
Avatar
Gu£st
replied on November 6th, 2007
Active User, very eHealthy
"Ok well Buddhists don't believe in God. They are caring individuals. Hindu people don't believe in God, they're caring too.
Some atheist people are caring as well."

Yes but there is a God.

"yeah i totally dont believe in the existence of god at all and i care about other people still"

Yes but there is a God

"religion is in no way becoming less and less"

over all the Catholic Church is growing very fast between 5-10% every year, across the globe, but in our society the west it is decreasing at 5% every year.

"How can animals feel it is a not-smart idea to kill their own kind? Almost NO animal in the world murders its own kind. It is programmed in them via evolution and natural selection that killing one's own species is bad, and is not going to help the species survive in the long-run. It's just logical that homicide makes no sense. Tacking on the moral value of "bad" is a purely human development. "

because there is a God.

"Humans do. We are social animals, just like dolphins, chimps, wolves, etc. We NEED each other to survive. We need social interaction to stimulate our brains and keep them healthy. Many other animals suffer psychologicaly in isolation just as humans do. It is literally part of our blood and genes to form communnitties. "

i.e from God

"Not at all. You clearly do not understand the anthropological meaning of a society."

and you clearly do not understand that we are Designed as social creatures.

"Does not your heart tells you how to treat others?"

my heart? a lump of muscle in the chest?

What do you mean by heart?

I know what you mean, of course it does, that is because there is a God.

"Would you not know that causing injury to someone was wrong without a faith in a deity?"

Yes I would know it is wrong as would most people (but not everyone) because despite our faith in god he still exists even if we dont believe in him.
Did you find this post useful?
|
User Profile
Marianne0558
replied on November 6th, 2007
Supporter
Your only argument is "Because there is a God."
How do YOU know? Have you met him/her?
You don't KNOW, you have faith there is a God.
Did you find this post useful?
|
Avatar
Gu£st
replied on November 6th, 2007
Active User, very eHealthy
because people can "feel" what is right and what is wrong in their "heart" - this proves there is a God.....take some time to think about it.
Did you find this post useful?
|
User Profile
Marianne0558
replied on November 6th, 2007
Supporter
No, it proves we have a central nervous system and a functioning brain.
Did you find this post useful?
|
User Profile
Rodge
replied on November 6th, 2007
Active User, very eHealthy
Gu£st wrote:
because people can "feel" what is right and what is wrong in their "heart" - this proves there is a God.....take some time to think about it.


I have a toaster. I don't like toast, but it makes muffins just the way I like them. This proves that there is a God. Take some time to think about it.
Did you find this post useful?
|
Avatar
Tylanas
replied on November 6th, 2007
Especially eHealthy
Gu£st wrote:
"Ok well Buddhists don't believe in God. They are caring individuals. Hindu people don't believe in God, they're caring too.
Some atheist people are caring as well."

Yes but there is a God.


Prove it. I can prove gravity. I can't prove Buddha existed, but I'm not claiming him to be divine. His teachings aren't dependent on his existence. The words he said, or the words someone wrote in his name, still have meaning, whether he existed or not.
Did you find this post useful?
|
Avatar
Gu£st
replied on November 6th, 2007
Active User, very eHealthy
"No, it proves we have a central nervous system and a functioning brain."

biology proves that, not general moral consensus.

what you said is like saying mountians prove we have eyes.



"I have a toaster. I don't like toast, but it makes muffins just the way I like them. This proves that there is a God. Take some time to think about it."

well of course there is a difference between preference and morals.

between morals and opinions on what is right and wrong.

"Prove it."

Eiri you have already proven it.
Did you find this post useful?
|
Avatar
Tylanas
replied on November 6th, 2007
Especially eHealthy
No, I haven't. No one can prove God exists. Me asking for proof does not prove his existence. My existence in itself does not prove his existence.

Now, prove it. If you cannot, then STOP claiming it as fact.
Did you find this post useful?
|
Avatar
redeme
replied on November 6th, 2007
Experienced User
"yeah i totally dont believe in the existence of god at all and i care about other people still"

Yes but there is a God

lol wow! what a surprize
Did you find this post useful?
|
Avatar
Tylanas
replied on November 6th, 2007
Especially eHealthy
redeme wrote:
"yeah i totally dont believe in the existence of god at all and i care about other people still"

Yes but there is a God

lol wow! what a surprize


lol wow prove it.
Did you find this post useful?
|
Quick Reply
Search