haha my one year is coming up in 2 weeks, but I've been making ideas for a few months
First let me say, that scrapbook idea was awesome. I love creativity and that was just a stellar use of it. I would stay creative and see what your mind comes up with. Maybe recreate your first date. Look at the things you know he loves and build something around that. For example if he likes football tape his favorite team's game, buy him a jersey, get him tickets for the game, and if you are intimate with him...dress up like one of his teams cheetleaders
Just think of what his favorite things are and go with that, in the end it's the thought that counts... and I'm sure just being with you on your anniversary will mean the world to him.
and on a personal note, thank you for reminding me that I only have until the 18th to turn my ideas into reality