Join Our Community!
Share
Debate Forums > Abortion Debate Forum > What Is the Difference?
Avatar
Q: What Is the Difference?
asked by: Verizon-y on October 16th, 2007
Extremely eHealthy
Consider two scenario; A & B
Scenario A:
A husband and wife had "marital relations". A certain sperm is destined to meet up with a certain egg.

Both sperm & egg each have unique DNA, so the resulting union is destined to create a specific future child.

The hair color, eye color, shape of features, height, gender, intelligence, all are contained in the sperm and egg before they ever meet.

Just as they are about to come together, the wife sneezes. Just that teeny bit of jostling causes the sperm to not penetrate the egg.

That little red haired, freckle faced girl will never be born.

Scenario B:
Let's try that exact scenario again, this time with no sneeze, but same exact sperm and egg. Blue-eye carrying female sperm fuses with red haired freckle faced egg.

Unfortunately, husband & wife cannot bring another child into the world for whatever reason. So right after her missed period, wife goes to doctor to get RU486 and terminates her 2 week long pregnancy.
At this point the zygote is a blastocyst, not even an embryo. It wasn't yet attached to the sides of thr uterus/It never developed any organs, no brain. Would not feel, was not self aware, etc., etc.

That little red haired, freckle faced girl will never be born.

So what is the difference in the outcomes?
Did you find this post useful?
|
Replies(3)
User Profile
Jules
replied on October 16th, 2007
Extremely eHealthy
One is intentional, the other is not. To some people that is the moral difference.
Did you find this post useful?
|
User Profile
meblonde01
replied on October 16th, 2007
Extremely eHealthy
Nothing they are both dead and not able to have a life.. However, the first scenario they never met. So a developing human being was never started. the second scenario a developing human being is destroyed preventing it to grow.
Once again. there is a difference in just cells and when the two meet (if left alone) would turn into a human being.
One cell can not do it on their own. it takes the two together..

Big difference.. Live forming or life not yet forming!
Life not started.. Life destroyed.
Did you find this post useful?
|
Avatar
Verizon-y
replied on October 16th, 2007
Extremely eHealthy
But there is no difference to the embryo. Here are other ways to view the same question:



There is no difference between a couple having sex and their birth control working, and the same couple same sexual act but birth

control fails, but woman has an abortion.

The only "suffering" is borne by the woman. The child that will not exist will not exist in either scenario.

The potential child does not know his parents used birth control, so that is why he isn't here, and he wouldn't know his mother had

an abortion, either.

Actually, you can add a third scenario in which the couple just skips the sex that night altogether. Same end result, child that would

have been born had they copulated still doesn't know he wasn't brought to fruition.

Tell me the difference as it pertains to the embryo between a couple having sex and their birth control working, so a child is not born

from that union,

and

The same scenario but bc fails, woman gets pregnant, and aborts embryo at 4 weeks, so a child is not born from that union.

From the perspective of the child never born, what is the difference?



------------------------------------------ -------------------

Every month that a woman has a viable egg and men have viable sperm, they decide whether or not to bring that life to fruition or not.

Every single egg and every single sperm are COMPLETELY UNIQUE, having different DNA from each other, and from the parents.

Each one represents a totally diffeent and unique potential person. I myself have often wondered if my husband and I hd conceived

one month earlier or one month later, what that child would have been like.

Would that be the child with blond hair and my husband's gift for drawing and painting? How about the child with my curls and my

personalty? Each one is completely unique.

The point is that they do exist, they aren't just imaginary. The real DNA that could create them is alive in the here and now. But they

can't all have the right to life.
Did you find this post useful?
|
Quick Reply
Search