I'm glad to hear that therapy has helped! Yes, I totally believe that in the beginning, things used to be good. It is sometimes hard to see where we (or a relationship) are headed; however, I know that our character, and life, are built upon many small actions that add up.
And I appreciate your kind words of advice, but fortunately, MY husband of 20 years is not a controlling abusive man. Unfortunately, I saw it all happening to a dear childhood friend of mine, and I suppose that's why I happened to look thru this forum. Because of my friend's experiences, I've become aware that it can happen to anyone, even educated , middle-class, professional women (my friend is a highly-respected registered nurse with a Master's degree who has supervised units, floors and entire departments at major medical centers).
For over 15 years, other friends and I urged her to get out of this marriage to a man that a court-ordered psychiatrist eventually called a "psychopath". She finally did, but not before he was able to alienate their only child from her (thru constant lies about mother to the child, and physically keeping them apart) and steal a significant chunk of her finances.
She kept hoping that he would change, and stayed and stayed and stayed while "they worked on things" (yeah, some therapy there 8-10 years into the marriage, but there were never any consequences when "he slipped"). In the meantime over the years, he siphoned off their money in unexplained bits and pieces, and also got himself a mistress (whom he promptly married when the divorce was final).
I don't want to give the impression that I'm advocating that you (or anyone else reading this) bail out of your marriage NOW because your life isn't practically perfect, or you both have some rough spots!
In fact, I'm a firm believer in demonstrating commitment to your marriage (like the song goes - "love is a verb"). I agree that professional help is indeed a good way to go (even for marriages that aren't in definite trouble).
But I also firmly believe that setting boundaries, and the courage and strength to stick to them are vital to your success. I don't know if you even believe in a Creator, but I do and I have learned a lot about Him. God defines Himself as a distinct being, & He is responsible for Himself - we should do the same. God has limits/boundaries, and we should also. God confronts sin & allows consequences for behavior; we should also. It is NOT "mean" or "unloving" or even "unchristian" to hold other people responsible for their feelings, choices and behaviors.
You said that your husband gets very scary when he gets out of control (although the instances are further apart). Because of that, and especially because of my friend's experiences, I just want to encourage you to be clear-eyed and realistic about what actual progress has been made.
Maybe your properly-set boundaries need to be strengthened and violations of the boundaries need to be enforced? That is probably best answered by you and your counselor. Or maybe you feel that progress is way too slow & you need a different therapist - some are definitely better than others. If you already have a relationship with God, I highly recommend talking to Him about this as well! And if you don't or you're not sure, but you're interested in this, Christian churches that believe in the importance of "small groups" or "home groups" are among the very best at helping you develop this relationship. (We go to a Vineyard church ourselves, but I know others that promote small groups). In fact, it was my friend's getting involved in a small church that ultimately re-kindled her love & obedience to Jesus (the psychopath had tried to minimize it during the marriage), and gave her the courage and strength to take many hard, but necessary steps.
Finally, you may have already read this book, since you wrote about boundaries, but if you haven't, or for ANYONE who has wondered how to answer someone who wants their time, love, energy or money, or wondered if you can still set limits and be a loving person - these are wonderful books! -
"Boundaries", and "Boundaries in Marriage", both by Dr. Henry Cloud and Dr. John Townsend.
Coffeeson, I pray that you and your husband will be committed to each other, committed to growing in love and wisdom, and able to again appreciate and enjoy the good things about each other. May you see more evidence this week of the good things that God wants to give you both - because He loves you both very much and has only good plans for you. May God be honored, and His Kingdom advance, and His will be done.
Don't feel obligated to reply - just know that I pray for you, and all others who are struggling to repair a marriage and struggling to do the right things.