Join Our Community!
Share
Parenting > Parenting Debate Forum > Are Children Taught to Share Or Born Sharing?
User Profile
Q: Are Children Taught to Share Or Born Sharing?
asked by: yogahoneybunny on August 2nd, 2007
Supporter
I was having a discussion with my sister-in-law tonight over dinner about this question...while our cousin's 2 1/2 year old was throwing a trantrum b/c she didn't want to share crayons.

So...do you think nature or nurture is stronger in the development of a child's ability to share?
Did you find this post useful?
|
Replies(10)
Avatar
kaerbear
replied on August 2nd, 2007
Most Diplomatic Poster
that's an interesting question. i'd say that it depends on the child and where they are at in their development but that it is always important to teach them not just by telling but by example. i think a 2 year old is going to have some issues with sharing regardless because many of them wouldn't have a lot of empathy at that age. of course, i don't have anything to back that up but my own opinion. i just think that they should be taught but you shouldn't expect them to really start to get it until they are a little older.
Did you find this post useful?
|
Avatar
taykare
replied on August 2nd, 2007
Supporter
according to child developments clinics that I have gone to with my daughter they are born to be selfish as they can not grasp the concept of sharing quite yet some do but not very many. Like I have said before I have twins and they have shared everythingfrom birth and on and when they were 1,2,3 they shared sometime great like the perfect little girls and othe times it turned into ww3 and I had to take the toy way. The my hubby started buying the same toys for each of them. This does not always work as they get mixed up even with names on them and we get ww3 all over again. Now that they are 5 theyare much better about sharing and like too their little sister on the other hand everythingis hers even mommy and she will block them push them what ever she has to to keep her things. She tries and is learning and it will come so I most definatly think they are born that way
taykare
Did you find this post useful?
|
Avatar
Anne123
replied on August 3rd, 2007
Experienced User
Maybe twins are better at sharing because they started out sharing a womb! Smile

I think sharing in general is a learned behaviour. Our primal instinct would be to guard our resources.
Did you find this post useful?
|
User Profile
sick_mama17
replied on August 3rd, 2007
Active User, very eHealthy
Taught to share.
Did you find this post useful?
|
Avatar
Magical Logic
replied on August 3rd, 2007
Extremely eHealthy
Anne123 wrote:
Maybe twins are better at sharing because they started out sharing a womb! Smile

I think sharing in general is a learned behaviour. Our primal instinct would be to guard our resources.
not my twins. they are only 9 months but they already fight over toys. usually Eternity is the one taking the toy away.
Did you find this post useful?
|
Avatar
Tylanas
replied on August 3rd, 2007
Especially eHealthy
I think the act of sharing is a taught behavior. It's not exactly evolutionarily advantageous to give away something you have, but it is socially advantageous.

Yes, children may be born as more pre-disposed to be empathetic, or to be possessive, so teaching sharing to certain children may be more difficult, but I don't think many children will automatically share or not share.
Did you find this post useful?
|
User Profile
benc152
replied on August 20th, 2007
Experienced User
taught.

most behaviour is taught.
Did you find this post useful?
|
Avatar
Mommy35
replied on August 21st, 2007
Extremely eHealthy
I think you have to teach them to share.

Incidently, this is something that many adults I know never learned to do.
Did you find this post useful?
|
User Profile
Sedux
replied on September 19th, 2008
New User
I think children are not born to share. They are taught to share. Depending on the values that the parents instill in their child, those are the values they will know how to express as adults. It is human nature to be selfish. And human nature to sin. For instance, you don't find people teaching their children how to lie. Or how to be bad. They eventually come across that on their own by their own observations. We have to teach our children not to lie etc etc.
Did you find this post useful?
|
User Profile
diamondsz
replied on April 6th, 2009
Extremely eHealthy
Children are taught to share, we are born with the impulse of being selfish are from then taught to be somewhat selfless.

Someone else said all behaviour is taught, hes pretty much right although there is some exception, never forget exceptions.
Did you find this post useful?
|
Quick Reply
Search