IDK what you went with, but i have basically the EXACT SAME BREAK and i didnt get sergery. they said dont stick stuff down ur cast, but it was ichy, so i used a glow stick necklace to itch. it really wasnt that bad because you are in a knee high cast for 1 month, and a walking cast for the next. i have reduced my physical therapy time down segnificantly because i work my muscles out in my walking cast by doing leg lifts and other exercises. i believe its alot cheaper just to go the cast rout, and it's not the worst experiance in the world. let me know how ur leg healed and went. mine is almost completely healed and i dont have metal in my leg to mess with me at the airports.