I ordered the black paste and the Keloid salve. I used it for a few days, keeping it on overnight, with the gauze stuck on it, the way the instructions tell you to do. First day or so, nothing. 3rd day, it made the keloid on my chest feel raw and somewhat irritated. I left off for a couple days, and tried again, wearing it overnight with the gauze. Still felt a little raw, but when I woke up the next day, my keloid was swollen and sore. I washed all remnants of that stuff off and just let the keloid get some air. I waited a couple days and then I used the keloid salve, which seems more like a vaseline based product, figuring that it would be less harsh. Once again, for a couple days, seemed okay, but then, the rawness, soreness and finally a slight enlargening of the keloid. That was it for me. Haven't used the stuff since!