Join Our Community!
Share
Conditions and Diseases > Back Pain Forum > male with herniated disc
What structures make up the spine? We review basic spine anatomy here...before identifying potential causes of back pain....
Click here to learn about the most common causes of back pain, and things that increase your risk of backache. We cover lower back pain and upper back pain....
Back pain symptoms may seem obvious. But do you know when symptoms of back pain are more serious or when to see a doctor? Learn what action to take & when...
Avatar
Q: male with herniated disc
asked by: lev189 on October 16th, 2008
New User
Hi I'm a new member and I'm looking for any advice.
Here's my story. About 6 weeks ago, I lifted someone up about 130 lbs and held them on my shoulders while on a trampoline for about 30 seconds. After putting them down about five minutes later I began epxerienced pain in the lower right side of my back and extreme tightness. About 10 minutes after this I realized that when bending down to touch my toes I couldn't go passed my knees, and also my right leg was having pain/numbness. Anyway that is how I herniated my L5-S1 disc.

After this I began seeing a Chiropractor and Acupuncturist. After the first week my pain in my back went down but I was still experiencing limited range of motion and numbness down my right leg. Anyway it has been 6 weeks now since this happened and I currently feel good. I no longer have any pain in my back. My symptons now are: When I wake up every morning I still have a little numbness in my leg, and limited range of motion. However after about an hour my range of motion is back and the numbness is gone. If I sit for a long period of time when I get up I have some numbness in my leg but again after about 5 minutes of walking it goes away. If i lie in the supine position when my right leg is lifted about 50 degrees I still get pain in my low right back. My MRI which i got 2 days ago confirms I do have a minor herniation in L5-S1.

Here is my dilemma I'm a very active male, a goalie in hockey , and love working out. I want to be able to play hockey again and I have been working out lightley already just no back or legs. I worked core on a ex ball for the first time in a month (my chiro told me I can't but i didn't listen) on monday, and I felt great the next day, actually since working core I feel better than I ever have. My chiropractor doesn't want me doing anything because she says I can make it worse. However I feel fine and not doing anything gets me depressed. My acupuncturist who is my uncle told me since I feel almost 100% definitely work core, do a light workout with no back or legs, and I can play hockey with a Back Stabilizing belt. I want to be 100% and feel no more symptoms.

My doctor (general doctor) about a week ago prescribed me anti-inflamtories, muscle relaxers, and lidoderm patch. I haven't taken or done anything he said because I don't feel any pain and my chiropractor said that will only take away my pain when I take it no actually make it better. She also said muscle relaxers may help or worsen the problem and they make me drowsy. Since I feel almost 100% i'd rather not take a chance at making it worse.

A lot of people have told me to take physical therapy. They said since I almost feel 100% therapy will help me get to a complete recovery.

I now do not know what to do. I want to play hockey, and workout. I feel fine get occasional numbness but no pain in my back at all. I don't want to take pain killers or muscle relaxers. And most importantly I want to feel no symptoms at all including numbness. Should I start physical therapy and drop everything else? Is it safe to play hockey? Should I work core and workout lightly, minus my back and legs? Please help me!

Thank You and sorry for this loooong post.
Did you find this post useful?
|
Replies(2)
Avatar
PhillyBlunt
replied on October 17th, 2008
New User
Well i have the same herniated disc, same level, different cause.
I havent been able to work out either. If the pain is bad enough, you'll take the pain killers. I have been prescribed Flexaril, starting today and i have to say it has helped me, but that is also taking Darvocet aswell.
Physical therapy did NOT help me. it only made it worse. When i take the pain killers, i can actually walk and SOMETIMES i can do crunches again.
I would try it, but im not you.
Did you find this post useful?
|
Avatar
littleonefb
replied on October 24th, 2008
Extremely eHealthy
I posted this on your other post, not realizing that you had a double post. It was removed and then returned to the forums.
So I am copying and pasting from the other post you made.

No apology needed for a long post. You gave great information in it so that you can get input about your problem.

First let me say this. You are playing with fire in combining all kinds of different treatments for a herniated disc, but you did not say who diagnosed you with the the herniated disc.

You are also very lucky that the chiropractor didn't make your herniated disc worse. I have seen that happen so many times, it's scary to think that you have been getting that kind of treatment.

Your chiropractors advise to do nothing but in exercise is terrible advise and you should disregard every bit of that advise and stop seeing the chiropractor ASAP.

It is vitally necessary to strengthen your core muscles right away, but the problem is, you are not doing it under the guidance of an experienced physical therapist that is knowledgeable on the proper exercises to do with spine problems. If you do the wrong exercises you will further damage your disc and create more problems in your spine.

Your GP gave you one huge boat load of medication for your pain, far more than you should have gotten.

Your uncle is also 100% wrong in his advise on what you should be doing as well.

Under no circumstances should you be playing hockey right now, with or without some kind of stabilizing belt. You may feel 100%, but it is highly doubtful that your disc has fully healed.

You need to see a spine specialist, either an orthopedic surgeon who specializes in spines or a neurosurgeon who specializes in spines only.
They will be the only ones that properly diagnose your spine problem, determine if the only problem you have is a herniated disc and be able to determine why your disc herniated.

Don't be afraid with the title surgeon beside the spine specialist's name. They are the only doctors that are really qualified to diagnose and treat you. A good spine surgeon will try all conservative treatments first, before even the mention of any kind of spine surgery.

In your case, being an athelete, and your age, I would suggest that you see a sports medicine orthopedic surgeon that specializes in spines for evaluation and treetment.
They will be the best type of spine surgeon for you to see.

If you want to be 100% healed and not take a chance getting worse, then it's time you make a quick decision and head off to a spine surgeon right away.

If you continue as you are doing, you will not only not be 100%, but you run an extremely high risk of further damage to your spine, and never being that 100% that you want to be.

If you do not treat the herniated disc properly with proper diagnosis and treatment, you will not let it heal properly, it will always be a problem for you, continue to herniated and eventually be a useless disc that will require major spine surgery.

Good luck and I hope you take my advise and get to the ortho spine surgeon ASAP

Fran
Did you find this post useful?
|
Quick Reply
Search