With the x-rays showing no break, that baffles me...However, if you are older, age sets in...Knuckles will swell and become painful...I saw this in my Father years ago...I hope it heals itself...

Caroline

Thanks Caroline for replying.Because of the time that has lapsed , the pain and deformity to knuckles and middle finger, I think there must be an injury to the tendons perhaps and I had better arrange to see someone privayely , as up to now no one including various GP'S physios etc have been able to sort it.