Join Our Community!
Share
Mental Health > Depression Forum > Depression - Do self-help books help?
Do you know how doctors define clinical depression? Learn more about this brain disorder and types of depression that doctors diagnose here....
Can depression run in families? Can hormones really make you depressed? Yes! Learn more about causes and conditions of clinical depression here....
People with depressive illnesses do not all experience the same symptoms. Do you know the signs and symptoms of depression? Read on to learn more....
Avatar
Q: Depression - Do self-help books help?
asked by: Snapper57 on April 6th, 2008
New User
I suffer from mild depression and I'm beginning to suspect I'm addicted to self-help books. I cant get enough of them, books, dvd's, bookmarked web sites. . .

The thing is, whilst they often contain much wisdom, none of them seem to hold any long term solutions. One problem is the step-by-step approach of some of these programmes. I find myself starting step one, full of enthusiasm only to loose interest by the time I get to step 3.

Another problem is they assume everyone is going to respond to the advice in the same logical way. Unfortunately, when one is depressed logic goes out of the window and attention span is reduced to that of a nat's.

I have even tried hypnotherapy, The Landmark Forum (the best one by a long way) and my GP who wanted to give me pills.

Sometimes I just feel like I'm falling into a black hole - I'm 50 and no wiser. Not sure why I'm writing this or what I want from this post, but I bet I'm not the only one that's frustrated by self-help! Confused
Did you find this post useful?
|
Replies(8)
User Profile
PenguinsRus
replied on April 7th, 2008
Moderator
Self books can be the most helpful resource in the world for one person and do completely nothing for the next. Also, it can vary from day to day. Someone could love a book one day and think its a waste of paper the next. It is really all about what helps you.

Have you tried any other methods of helping yourself? Have you talked to others about how you feel? Have you tried things to calm your mind and body, such as yoga, walks in parks, meditation, etc? If the books aren't working for you, I'd recommend trying other methods until you find something that seems to be helping a bit. Good luck! I hope you start to feel better soon.
Did you find this post useful?
|
Avatar
Snapper57
replied on April 7th, 2008
New User
Thanks Penguin, You are right, sometimes I find them useful, just a bit frustrated at the moment. I have started walking 5 miles a day, and it definitely helps, plus I've lost over a stone in two months which makes me feel much better about my appearance. I have thought about meditation and yoga, wouldn't mind giving it a go.

Thanks again, I do appreciate you taking time to answer my message.
Cheers
Andy
Did you find this post useful?
|
User Profile
PenguinsRus
replied on April 7th, 2008
Moderator
Congrats about losing the weight! That is great for just two months!! Yoga helps me a lot because it really really relaxes my body and mind at the same time and just calms me. Typically I recommend waiting to try medication just because it can make you seem like a zombie sometimes, but if nothing else seems to help out then you should give it a shot.
Did you find this post useful?
|
User Profile
been-there
replied on April 8th, 2008
New User
Hi Snapper57,

I know what you mean about the self-help books. At one point they were all I could buy and yet I never finished 3/4 of them. For me it was the idea of what they might be able to do - 'this one might be able to fix me' rather than the content itself.

In hindsight I think a lot of them cover many of the same things and if you can get some ideas or advice from them that you find helpful, even if it is just one point, then I would say you could counsider it handy. Smile

In the end I found Tony Robbins very helpful, in particular his Personal Power cd's however they are pretty pricey so you may want to try borrowing one or two first to see if they are for you. I have a few friends that I have also recommended them to and they have also found them useful.

In relation to meditation, The mediatation Society of Australia run a free online, self-paced course that you may find useful. The address is http://www.meditation.org.au/index.asp .

And congrats on the weight loss, have you ever thought about entering a charity walking event? It sounds like you would do really well with all that walking you have been doing!

Best wishes,

Heather
Did you find this post useful?
|
Avatar
Snapper57
replied on April 11th, 2008
New User
Thanks Heather, i will explore the meditation link and the charity walk sounds like a great idea. Thanks again x
Did you find this post useful?
|
Avatar
845
replied on July 30th, 2008
New User
I have a history of depression in my family. There is no one thing that beats depression. Its a combination things. Self help books will work, but people need to put their complete faith in whichever one they choose.

Try making friends. I would describe depression as a hole nothing will fill. You have to try and fill that hole constantly. It can literally be anything you like. If you enjoy reading self help books it isn't an addiction. Its what you enjoy doing. You are only wasting your time if you are not learning anything. Maybe you just haven't found the one self help book. It's best to pick something to do religiously and stick to it.
Did you find this post useful?
|
Avatar
Snapper57
replied on July 31st, 2008
New User
Depression - Do self-help books help?
Thank you for your post. I absolutely agree with you, a combination of things is usually the most effective way to cope with depression. Since the original post I have got on with my life and at the moment, I am better able to cope with lifes ups and downs - have just graduated from uni with a 2.2 and now looking to start a new career in education and freelance graphics. So I have created a future to live into and that's what drives me upwards and onwards!

I think I was wasting time - self help books are a way of procrastinating for me but I realise that this is not always the case for everyone. All I would say is question why you read them, if they move you on, great, if not, what are you avoiding/not doing?
Did you find this post useful?
|
Avatar
CarolDiane
replied on August 1st, 2008
Extremely eHealthy
Absolutly! The more you understand about your disorder. The more you will be able to cope with it and have the knowledge to back it up. Kinda like your own mental phamacy.
Did you find this post useful?
|
Quick Reply
Search