Join Our Community!
Debate Forums > Abortion Debate Forum > Are you suffering from Post Abortion stress?
Welcome to the eHealth Debate Forums Community connecting patients, doctors, and people who like to help.
For more information about Abortion Debate, read the topics below or use our FREE Ask a Doctor service!
Ask a Doctor
User Profile
Q: Are you suffering from Post Abortion stress?
asked by: diamondsz on July 3rd, 2008
Extremely EHEALTHy
Are You Suffering from Post-Abortion Stress?
If you have had an abortion(s), you may be suffering from post-abortion stress. Answering the following questions can help you figure out how the abortion(s) may have effected your life.

Do you find yourself struggling to turn off feelings or memories related to your abortion(s)? Do you need to keep reminding yourself to just forget it or put it behind you?

Do you become uncomfortable around reminders of the abortion, such as being around babies, pregnant women, doctor's offices, or when hearing news reports about abortion?

Do you feel nervous or anxious at the idea of telling a loved one about your abortion? Is your abortion a secret that is holding you back from greater intimacy with others?

When you do choose to share your abortion experience with others, are you overcome with strong feelings such as anger, sorrow, grief, or guilt?

Do you have trouble talking about the abortion issue as a political issue? When you do talk about it, do you find it hard to respect opposing views, or do you becoming overly emotional, either in support of or opposition to it?

Do you have an unhealthy sense of fear that you, your loved ones, or your other children will be hurt or killed? Are you "smothering" or overly protective of your children?

Do you tend to look at life in terms of "before" and "after" the abortion(s)? Has the abortion changed the way you look at yourself? Are there traits about your "self" before the abortion that you lost but would wish to regain in your life? Do you become angry or depressed more easily?

Have you experienced "reconnectors" to your abortion, such as nightmares, flashbacks, or hallucinations, such as hearing a baby cry?

Was there a period after your abortion when you experienced an increase in the use of alcohol or drugs (illegal or prescription)? Have you experienced other forms of emotional deadening?

Have you experienced any suicidal thoughts? Do you take risks that put your life in danger? Do you try to hurt yourself? Have you developed any eating disorders?

Have you lost interest in taking care of yourself? Do you care about how you look? Have you tried to become less attractive to avoid the risk of becoming involved in a relationship, love, and sex?

Do you have trouble with finding, building, or maintaining good relationships with people of the opposite sex? Do you have trouble with issues of trust and control? Do you get involved in hurtful or abusive relationships? Do you tolerate abuse because you don't feel you deserve any better?

Is there an increased distance between you and your parents or siblings because of the past abortion(s)? Is there tension between you and others because the abortion is something everyone avoids talking about?

Have you lost the desire for sexual intercourse? Do you have increased pain during intercourse? Have you become promiscuous because of low self-esteem? Have you lost your desire to have children?

Do you experience periods of depression, heightened anxiety, or cramping during certain months of the year, particularly during the months that would correspond to the month of your abortion(s) or the due date of the aborted pregnancy?

Have you lost your faith? Have you lost a sense of God's peace? Do you think God still loves you? Are you afraid of God? Have your rejected belief in God for emotional reasons rather than thoughtful reasons?
Did you find this post useful?
|
Quick Reply


Replies(10)
User Profile
diamondsz replied on July 3rd, 2008
Extremely EHEALTHy
Why dont the make something called Post pregnancy stress, Im sorry but why are people asking questions that can be twisted.

These questions are asked by members of Elliot institute http://www.af terabortion.org/stress-q.html

Anyway, if pro-life is saying that it genuinely makes people feel bad after, yes it does for people who wanted the pregnancy and was forced into abortion. I just don't someone telling me that because, my life has its up and downs that I have post abortion stress.

Some of these questions are foul play.
Did you find this post useful?
|
User Profile
diamondsz replied on July 3rd, 2008
Extremely EHEALTHy
Having dreams about a child also represents your inner child and how you miss being a kid, having freedom and not having to be in reality.

I am not saying some people are not affected but I dont believe everyone is and after having people making me feel horrible for it, I just didnt tell people because they would mentally dump on me, make me feel bad because I didn't.

This is what they wrote in regards to counselling, these are trained professionals like come on....

Please note: Since the Elliot Institute is a research and education organization only, we are not qualified to evaluate the counseling services offered by the following groups. We do, however, recomend that anyone seeking counseling get a referral for a person who has had specific training and experience in post-abortion counseling. Many professional counselors are unaware of, or even hostile to, post-abortion issues. Some may insist that the "real" problem lies elsewhere, not with the abortion. Such counselors may actually make a woman's problem worse. She should get a referral to a qualified post-abortion counselor.
Finally, please be aware that many of these groups have different philosophies and approaches to post-abortion counseling. The person seeking counseling should ask lots of questions about the counselor's approach in order to find someone he or she feels comfortable with. In all cases, the counselors should be non-judgemental and supportive. Post-abortion counselors are very understanding of the reasons why women have abortions and what they go through afterwards.

http://www.aft erabortion.org/resourc.html
Go to someone you feel comfortable with, go to someone who will be supportive and really get down to the problems, not someone who will tell you what your problem is.
Did you find this post useful?
|
Avatar
aochriss replied on July 3rd, 2008
Active User, Really EHEALTHy
The most common emotion experienced after an abortion is RELIEF.

Sure, some women regret an abortion, just as some regret having children, getting married, buying a house, getting divorced, having their tubes tied,etc., etc. But there aren't enough women regretting abortion to call it a syndrome.
Did you find this post useful?
|
User Profile
lucy315 replied on July 3rd, 2008
Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Re: Are you suffering from Post Abortion stress?
diamondsz wrote:
Are You Suffering from Post-Abortion Stress?
If you have had an abortion(s), you may be suffering from post-abortion stress. Answering the following questions can help you figure out how the abortion(s) may have effected your life.


I figured since I have had an abortion (and I'm bored today Wink ) that I'd answer the questions....

Quote:
Do you find yourself struggling to turn off feelings or memories related to your abortion(s)? Do you need to keep reminding yourself to just forget it or put it behind you?


Nope. The only memories I have are of the absolute relief and happiness I felt when it was finally over.

Quote:
Do you become uncomfortable around reminders of the abortion, such as being around babies, pregnant women, doctor's offices, or when hearing news reports about abortion?


Nope. I actually adore other pregnant woman. I have two friends who are currently pregnant, and I can't wait to meet the little guys. (yes, they are both having boys!)

Quote:
Do you feel nervous or anxious at the idea of telling a loved one about your abortion? Is your abortion a secret that is holding you back from greater intimacy with others?


I feel no shame at all for choosing abortion, and have told my close friends and some family. They all know why I decided to abort, and all have stood behind my decision. In fact, 3 of my closest friends have had an abortion. One had 2 of them. It's more common then most people think.

Quote:
When you do choose to share your abortion experience with others, are you overcome with strong feelings such as anger, sorrow, grief, or guilt?


Not at all.

Quote:
Do you have trouble talking about the abortion issue as a political issue? When you do talk about it, do you find it hard to respect opposing views, or do you becoming overly emotional, either in support of or opposition to it?


I have no problems talking about/arguing my side with people who have different views on the topic.

Quote:
Do you have an unhealthy sense of fear that you, your loved ones, or your other children will be hurt or killed? Are you "smothering" or overly protective of your children?


I have no other children, and don't worry about my loved ones being killed.

Quote:
Do you tend to look at life in terms of "before" and "after" the abortion(s)? Has the abortion changed the way you look at yourself? Are there traits about your "self" before the abortion that you lost but would wish to regain in your life? Do you become angry or depressed more easily?


The only thing that has changed since my abortion is the fact that I am EXTREMELY careful when having sex, as to make sure it never happens again. I consider that a good thing and a lesson learned.

Quote:
Have you experienced "reconnectors" to your abortion, such as nightmares, flashbacks, or hallucinations, such as hearing a baby cry?


Actually, yes. However, the nightmares I had for a few weeks after the abortion were about the woman who attacked me after I left the clinic. In my dreams, she tried to shoot me! I think the dreams came from the fact that we didn't know haw far this woman would go, and when she was chasing me, throwing baby blankets at me, and pulling on the back of my sweatshirt, my boyfriend shouted "get in the car, she could have a gun!!" I really was scared for my life. She only made my pro-choice views stronger.....

Quote:
Was there a period after your abortion when you experienced an increase in the use of alcohol or drugs (illegal or prescription)? Have you experienced other forms of emotional deadening?


Nope. I have never done an illegal drug, and actually have never even had a sip of alcohol. I have been on prescription drugs for 10 years for OCD, agoraphobia, anxiety disorder, and for panic attacks. Thats one of the reasons I chose abortion.

Quote:
Have you experienced any suicidal thoughts? Do you take risks that put your life in danger? Do you try to hurt yourself? Have you developed any eating disorders?


Nope

Quote:
Have you lost interest in taking care of yourself? Do you care about how you look? Have you tried to become less attractive to avoid the risk of becoming involved in a relationship, love, and sex?


No to all.

Quote:

Do you have trouble with finding, building, or maintaining good relationships with people of the opposite sex? Do you have trouble with issues of trust and control? Do you get involved in hurtful or abusive relationships? Do you tolerate abuse because you don't feel you deserve any better?


I'm with the same guy I was with when I had the abortion, and our relationship is the same as it was beforehand.

Quote:
Is there an increased distance between you and your parents or siblings because of the past abortion(s)? Is there tension between you and others because the abortion is something everyone avoids talking about?


None at all. My parents knew that I could never continue with a pregnancy with all the problems I suffer from. They stood behind me 100%.

Quote:
Have you lost the desire for sexual intercourse? Do you have increased pain during intercourse? Have you become promiscuous because of low self-esteem? Have you lost your desire to have children?

Do you experience periods of depression, heightened anxiety, or cramping during certain months of the year, particularly during the months that would correspond to the month of your abortion(s) or the due date of the aborted pregnancy?


I have terrible anxiety, but it has NOTHING to do with my abortion. I have suffered from it for may years.

Quote:
Have you lost your faith? Have you lost a sense of God's peace? Do you think God still loves you? Are you afraid of God? Have your rejected belief in God for emotional reasons rather than thoughtful reasons?



I honestly believe that God does love me, and every other woman who has aborted. People make mistakes, God forgives.
Did you find this post useful?
|
Users who thank lucy315 for this post: Moo  Milan 
User Profile
Milan replied on October 18th, 2008
Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Re: Are you suffering from Post Abortion stress?
diamondsz wrote:
Are You Suffering from Post-Abortion Stress?

Post-Abortion Stress - sounds scientific doesn't it, but don't be fooled — it's a made-up 'term' that is NOT recognized as an official syndrome or diagnosis by the American Psychiatric Association, the American Psychological Association, or any other mainstream authority, it is a bogus affliction invented by the religious right.

Simply put, there is no such medical term.

Talking about the Easter Bunny doesn't make it anymore real, and the same rule applies with made up terms.

Regarding the elliot institute: Its founder is David C. Reardon who is a known radical anti-choice activist, and was described in the New York Times Magazine as the "Moses" of the "post-abortion movement". The same New York Times article stated "Academic experts continue to stress that the psychological risks posed by abortion are no greater than the risks of carrying an unwanted pregnancy to term." A study of 13,000 women, conducted in Britain over 11 years, compared those who chose to end an unwanted pregnancy with those who chose to give birth, controlling for psychological history, age, marital status and education level. The researchers found that there was "equivalent rates of psychological disorders among the two groups."

Brenda Major, a psychology professor at the University of California followed hundreds of women ages 15 to 35 from the day they had their abortion.

LESS THAN 1% of them had any stress from the abortion. The rate of clinical depression among women who had an abortion was the same as the national rate for all women ages 15 to 35.

Another researcher found that less than 10 percent of women have symptoms of depression or other psychological distress after an abortion — this is the same exact rate experienced by women after childbirth. There is no secret that pregnant women have a rush of hormones. Every year seemingly normal women commit neonaticide. The research indicates that it is these hormones from the act of being pregnant that causes stress in some women, and NOT any 'decision' about terminating said pregnancy.

Anyone who has ever studied hormones knows that they are the single most powerful reaction in the human body. They control our very existence, and if you tried to remove any hormones from your body you would die within minutes. When a woman is going through the reproduction cycle, one hormone can regulate the production and release of other types of hormones. It is this "hormone cocktail" which some women are susceptible to which controls their feelings after they become pregnant, after an abortion or after childbirth.

Research indicates that relief is the most common emotional response following abortion, and that psychological distress appears to be greatest before, rather than after, an abortion.

In 1989, the American Psychological Association (APA) convened a panel of psychologists with extensive experience in this field to review the data.

The panel concluded that "research with diverse samples, different measures of response, and different times of assessment have come to similar conclusions. The time of greatest distress is likely to be before the abortion. Severe negative reactions after abortions are rare and can best be understood in the framework of coping with normal life stress." While a few women may experience sensations of regret, sadness or guilt after an abortion, the overwhelming responses are relief and happiness. (ref: Adler NE, et al. "Psychological factors in abortion: a review." American Psychologist, 1992, 47(10): 1194-1204).

In another study (Russo NF, Zierk KL. "Abortion, childbearing, and women's well-being." Professional Psychology: Research and Practice, 1992, 23: 269-280.) researchers surveyed a national sample of over 5,295 women, many of whom had abortions between 1979 and 1987, the time they were involved in the study. The researchers were able to learn about women's emotional well-being both before and after they had abortions. They concluded at the end of the eight-year study that the most important predictor of emotional well-being in post-abortion women was their well-being before the abortion. Women who had high self-esteem before an abortion would be most likely to have high self-esteem after an abortion, regardless of how many years passed since the abortion.

In a commentary in the Journal of the American Medical Association Nada Stotland, M.D., former president of the Association of Women Psychiatrists, stated:

"Significant psychiatric sequelae after abortion are rare, as documented in numerous methodologically sound prospective studies in the United States and in European countries. Comprehensive reviews of this literature have recently been performed and confirm this conclusion. The incidence of diagnosed psychiatric illness and hospitalization is considerably lower following abortion than following childbirth"

In other words, more woman are happy after an abortion then after having a baby.

Further more, Doctor Nada Stotland stated "Significant psychiatric illness following abortion occurs most commonly in women who were psychiatrically ill before pregnancy, in those who decided to undergo abortion under external pressure, and in those who underwent abortion in aversive circumstances, for example, abandonment."

Henry P. David, PhD, an internationally known scholar in this area of research, reported the following at an international conference.

"Severe psychological reactions after abortion are infrequent. The number of such cases is very small, and has been characterized by former U.S. Surgeon General C. Everett Koop as 'minuscule from a public health perspective'...For the vast majority of women, an abortion will be followed by a mixture of emotions, with a predominance of positive feelings. This holds immediately after abortion and for some time afterward...The positive picture reported up to eight years after abortion makes it unlikely that more negative responses will emerge later."

Russo and Dabul reported their conclusions of an eight-year study in Professional Psychology:

"Although an intensive examination of the data was conducted, controlling for numerous variables and including comparisons of Black women versus White women, Catholic women versus non-Catholic women, and women who had abortions versus other women, the findings are consistent: The experience of having an abortion plays a negligible, if any, independent role in women's well-being over time, regardless of race or religion. The major predictor of a woman's well-being after an abortion, regardless of race or religion, is level of well-being before becoming pregnant...Our findings are congruent with those of others, including the National Academy of Sciences (1975), and the conclusion is worth repeating. Despite a concerted effort to convince the public of the existence of a widespread and severe postabortion trauma, there is no scientific evidence for the existence of such trauma, even though abortion occurs in the highly stressful context of an unwanted pregnancy."

The only reason why the anti-choice movement made-up the term 'post-abortion stress' is to manipulate women's feelings. They have a history of making up terms that no medical association recognizes or uses. They are counting on your ignorance and hoping that you don't learn the facts listed above. Ask yourself, why would they have to use trickery and make-up terms like this if the truth was on their side? Wink
Did you find this post useful?
|
User Profile
Birch replied on October 18th, 2008
Supporter
The only time I feel stress from my abortion is when people insinuate I should have to justify myself to them. Very
Happy
Did you find this post useful?
|
User Profile
Lilly Ivy replied on October 18th, 2008
Extremely EHEALTHy
You could ask the same type of questions to someone who was forced to gestate and give birth against their will.
Did you find this post useful?
|
User Profile
diamondsz replied on October 18th, 2008
Extremely EHEALTHy
Lilly Ivy wrote:
You could ask the same type of questions to someone who was forced to gestate and give birth against their will.


I know, I just dont agree with what they wrote, I see post partum being worse, depresion that is.
Did you find this post useful?
|
User Profile
Milan replied on October 18th, 2008
Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Ye, postnatal depression can be hell. There should be laws protecting women who are going through it.
Did you find this post useful?
|
User Profile
Lilly Ivy replied on October 18th, 2008
Extremely EHEALTHy
Milan wrote:
Ye, postnatal depression can be hell. There should be laws protecting women who are going through it.


Of course there's not. Only for abortion, because if you have that baby, you are just SO happy! Rolling Eyes
Did you find this post useful?
|
 
Subject
Message
Jump to: