Join Our Community!
Debate Forums > Abortion Debate Forum > Abortion and philosophy
Welcome to the eHealth Debate Forums Community connecting patients, doctors, and people who like to help.
For more information about Abortion Debate, read the topics below or use our FREE Ask a Doctor service!
Ask a Doctor
User Profile
Q: Abortion and philosophy
asked by: diamondsz on June 5th, 2008
Extremely EHEALTHy
Alot of what I read on abortion and philosphy differ from alot of our views that we do have so far but I want to bring it to the next step.

In one particular article that I like he explains that their is three levels of debates on this subject, we are on the first if we can call it that/pre-first level of debate. Pro-choice debate is able to bring their debate to the third level and the pro-life side has made it into second level but much the less can't go any higher due to certain rights circumstances.

In philosophy religion is not on the same plain, we dont use other people views to make our decisions but our own free will/independent thought ( ex. religion.)

The main point was consciousness, the fetus is not at the same as a newborn nowhere near and therefore it came down to had the higher level of such and why person hood is granted a persons consciouness .

The article can be found at
http://www.philosophynow.org/archive /articles/36goldblatt.htm

I love how it was said though, religion should never be brought into a debate, what about the non-religious person, the atheist and the agnostic. It isn't in the article but in philosophy in general, philosphy considers religion on a different plain as it only believe knowledge come from god and not our inner selves as where wisdom is what we make of it.

Alot of us when we get into a heavy debate, we have a tendancy to talk about how the z/e/f shares charactheristics of a pararsite, although some would say that we hate, we don't we just have a different level of views on this. To deny that it does its almost foolish but at the same time what cant be denied is the fact that it is a natural process but it can also be unnatural (Birth-control etc.)


****************************************** ****************************************** ******
A few questions, I am not against religion (im agnostic) but should religion really have any say on us?

Now I know a few of you on here are very respectful (even if you are religious) therefore I am not talking about the odd few good ones!

Their is religious organization that still want contraceptives banned, it is a christian organization called STOPP, they are also trying to rid school of sexual education and to have abstinence only programs.

Is it a really positive way to be promoting to bunch of rebellious teenagers that sex is not acceptable or to make one feel bad about their own body?
Did you find this post useful?
|
Quick Reply


Replies(3)
Avatar
cmyked replied on June 5th, 2008
Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Religion is WHY some people think the way they do and feel the way they do: they cannot speak or even think without its influence. That's okay. Religion can be brought into this debate as long as the religious person remembers that while THEIR opinions may be based on faith, other people's feelings aren't. The religious person has to remember that while they may follow the laws of God, they cannot force someone else to do so.
Did you find this post useful?
|
User Profile
Darkmoon replied on June 5th, 2008
Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
cmyked wrote:
Religion is WHY some people think the way they do and feel the way they do: they cannot speak or even think without its influence. That's okay. Religion can be brought into this debate as long as the religious person remembers that while THEIR opinions may be based on faith, other people's feelings aren't. The religious person has to remember that while they may follow the laws of God, they cannot force someone else to do so.


I agree with this. Or at least, they need to remember that they can't force people to follow the laws of THEIR particular god. Other gods have other rules and so forth.
Did you find this post useful?
|
User Profile
diamondsz replied on June 6th, 2008
Extremely EHEALTHy
cmyked wrote:
Religion is WHY some people think the way they do and feel the way they do: they cannot speak or even think without its influence. That's okay. Religion can be brought into this debate as long as the religious person remembers that while THEIR opinions may be based on faith, other people's feelings aren't. The religious person has to remember that while they may follow the laws of God, they cannot force someone else to do so.


I completely understand that, that is one thing I respect but we both know that the majority dont feel the same and have a tendancy to bring it either way.

Good point though!!
Did you find this post useful?
|
 
Subject
Message
Jump to: